Deciding which utensil to use when eating macaroni and cheese might not sound like the most pressing question, but questions like that are exactly what marketers want consumers to be asking themselves.
Kraft Macaroni & Cheese took to Twitter on July 10 to start a campaign based on that seemingly innocuous question.
Over the next few days, the post attracted quite a bit of attention, with about 1,700 responses and more than 114,000 votes in a digital poll. Debate between what the company dubbed “team spoon” and “team fork” became heated as hundreds of Twitter users turned their utensil preference against each other.
The support for the debate by Kraft Heinz, manufacturers of the the cheesy favorite and dozens of other packaged foods, is part of a strategy to promote “talkability,” said Michelle St. Jacques, head of brand and innovation for the company in the United States. The company has dual headquarters in Pittsburgh and Chicago.
“We’re always trying to identify new ways to connect with our consumers,” she said. “[The mac & cheese campaign] started because we saw online that people were having this debate already.”
The company also promised to change the image on the box — which had previously alternated between fork and spoon — based on the results of the poll. With 61 percent of the vote going to “team fork,” the boxes will start to feature tines underneath the pasta sometime next year.
The mac & cheese effort is part of a broader trend as companies move toward using social media interactively. It’s a shift that crosses into the real world as well.
On July 9, St. Louis-based Build-A-Bear Workshop, which operates more than 400 teddy bear creation stores around the world, announced a “pay your age” event in which customers could pay for a stuffed animal with the dollar value of their age in years. During the three days between the announcement and event, parents scrambled, preparing for the opportunity to get their kindergartners $5 furry companions. The regular prices of the plush animals range from $6 to $75, with most falling in the $30 range.
The response was immense. Lines at some Build-A-Bear stores stretched for nearly a mile, and the company was forced to hand out vouchers to customers as authorities closed some locations because of safety concerns.
“It was a great, fantastic idea, but they kind of messed up on the execution,” said TJ Crawford, director of digital strategy and marketing technology at marketing agency MARC USA in Pittsburgh.
Build-A-Bear declined to comment, citing a quiet period preceding its second-quarter earnings release. In a press release on July 12, it said “[The] Pay Your Age Day event generated an overwhelming response, resulting in long lines, extensive waits and disappointed guests.”
Regardless of the product, engaging in a back-and-forth with customers instead of the traditional one-way communication seems to be important.
“Social media in general as a marketing channel ... has evolved pretty quickly,” said Mr. Crawford. More interactive forms of marketing combine that evolution with more traditional “guerrilla marketing” and “stunt pieces,” he said.
For Kraft Heinz, the spoon-vs-fork debate is the latest in a string of interactive marketing campaigns. In June, the company’s Country Time brand announced a program to pay the fines incurred by children who operate lemonade stands without proper permits. In April, the company announced that it would introduce “Mayochup” — a mayonnaise-ketchup blend — to the U.S. if at least 500,000 people voted in favor in a Twitter poll. By a 55 percent to 45 percent margin, they did.
Not all campaigns will be successful, and some will create some backlash. “You had a lot of brands that jumped on the political bandwagon,” Mr. Crawford said.
As an example, Mr. Crawford cited a 2017 Super Bowl ad for Washington County-based 84 Lumber. That commercial referenced President Donald Trump’s promise to build a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border, and was initially rejected by Fox Sports as too controversial. The advertisement only ran after 84 Lumber made modifications.
Brands have to balance relevance with the potential for controversy, experts said. And while some topics might be outside the margins of a brand’s image, “To me, the risk you have as a brand today is sitting on the sidelines,” said Ms. St. Jacques.
So what lessons can companies take from the new interactive marketing landscape?
Mr. Crawford pointed to Canadian airline WestJet as an example of the potential for success. The company has carried out “Christmas Miracles” every year since 2012, delivering toys to children after their flights, working with charities and sponsoring other Christmas-themed and airline-related events.
Even though he didn’t fly on WestJet during the campaign, Mr. Crawford said his perception of the brand has been improved by sharing of the festivities on social media.
Some interactive marketing campaigns “are going to work and some won’t,” he said. It all depends on the topic of choice, the execution, and, maybe, a bit of luck, he said.
Ben Mikek: bmikek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3852.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.