In a very public Twitter spat this week, Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto complained about Uber’s plan to send self-driving cars back onto the city’s streets without meeting his safety guidelines.
But the city doesn’t have much authority to make Uber, or any other self-driving firm, listen.
That lack of local jurisdiction is plaguing cities, nationwide, as those with self-driving pilots reel from the fatal Uber crash that left 49-year-old Elaine Herzberg dead in Tempe, Arizona, in March. Since then, the San Francisco company has temporarily suspended its autonomous vehicles from roads in North America. On Wednesday the company said it would end its testing in Arizona completely.
Pittsburgh, which welcomed Uber almost two years ago as the Steel City became both an engineering hub and a test track for the technology, is struggling to get some control now.
The city has limited powers related to traffic in its municipal code under both the Department of Public Safety and the Department of Mobility and Infrastructure, said Tim McNulty, communications director for the mayor’s office. Beyond that, the city’s position may be considered by a state task force.
“We also are cooperating with the state to support policies that recognize the unique characteristics of an urban area,” Mr. McNulty wrote in an email Thursday.
Read More
The city is represented on the Autonomous Vehicles Task Force, a group that includes the Federal Highway Administration, AAA, Carnegie Mellon University and General Motors, said Erin Waters-Trasatt, press secretary for the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation.
“The city’s concerns would be part of the discussion of the task force,” she said. PennDOT did not say the city has any specific powers of its own to regulate self-driving car firms.
PennDOT is primarily tasked with regulating companies like Uber, but even at the state level, nothing is set in stone that could give pause to self-driving companies with a presence in Pittsburgh, including Uber, Argo AI, Aurora Innovation or Aptiv.
Those companies did not return requests for comment on Thursday.
In April, PennDOT introduced guidelines for autonomous car companies operating in the state, but none of the suggestions are obligatory — yet. That’ll take the approval of the Pennsylvania General Assembly, which is reviewing the draft legislation.
Among other items, PennDOT urges companies to immediately halt all testing of vehicles that knowingly share hardware or software with a car that is part of a National Transportation Safety Board investigation. Uber agreed to those conditions in April.
Ms. Waters-Trasatt added that PennDOT is continuing to work on updating those guidelines for automated vehicles in the state. The department will share that progress next Thursday with the self-driving firms to gather their feedback and input.
“The legislature has not given PennDOT the ability to issue legally binding requirements for [automated vehicle] testing, so tester buy-in is critical until the vehicle code is updated,” she wrote in an email.
“While we have not shared the specifics of the guidelines with testers yet, the administration has had conversations with Uber about the need to comply with the guidance before testing resumes and has appreciated Uber’s commitment to do so.”
Uber has been under a federal investigation since the deadly crash in March. On Thursday the NTSB released a preliminary report, which said that Uber disables its cars’ factory installed emergency braking systems while under computer control to reduce the potential for “erratic behavior.”
Instead, the vehicle operator is expected to intervene when braking is necessary in autonomous mode.
In the Arizona fatality, the self-driving system determined that emergency braking was needed to avoid a collision with the victim, Ms. Herzberg, 1.3 seconds before she was struck. The vehicle was traveling at 39 miles per hour at the point of impact, according to the report.
In a statement Wednesday, Mr. Peduto said the city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure created additional requirements for Uber — on top of state guidelines — that it must meet before it resumes testing on public roads.
Mr. NcNulty noted that part of the reason the mayor created the department was to have an increased ability to engage in safety conversations.
Under Mr. Peduto’s proposed rules, self-driving cars could not exceed 25 miles per hour in the city, regardless of legal speed limits, he said.
The mayor added Wednesday that he found out Uber planned to restore its autonomous fleet to Pittsburgh roads sometime in the summer via social media, a move he said was not constructive.
On Thursday, an Uber spokesperson presented a different description of its communications with Pittsburgh. The spokesperson said on May 9 and May 10, the company notified the city, county and state of its intent to restore operations by the end of June.
Uber said it would look into the mayor’s suggestions before returning to the road.
A meeting with the city on May 18, which the company cited in a tweet Wednesday, focused more closely on the specifics of Uber’s pending return to city roads, according to the company.
You never responded to our requirements. You never informed us of today’s announcement. You never followed up on my requirements after fatality in Arizona. Your PA lobbyist has ignored everything & instead has reached out to other electeds to cover your mistakes. Time to change! https://t.co/dIAtob9Z8O
— bill peduto (@billpeduto) May 23, 2018
Working productively with @CityPGH, @Allegheny_Co and @PennDOTNews towards a safe return to self-driving operations is our top priority. That's why at every step we've proactively reached out to relevant officials at each level of government.
— Uber Comms (@Uber_Comms) May 23, 2018
Mr. Peduto’s social media response claimed that the company’s “PA lobbyist has ignored everything & instead has reached out to other electeds to cover [their] mistakes.” Shari Shapiro is head of Uber’s public affairs in Pennsylvania and works out of Philadelphia.
When Uber first set up shop in Pittsburgh in 2016, Mr. Peduto was enamored with the company and its then-CEO Travis Kalanick — the two were even known to exchange text messages. Since then, Mr. Peduto’s relationship with Uber has been a roller coaster ride.
In January 2017, Mr. Peduto expressed frustration when the company would not cooperate with the city on its bid for the Smart City Challenge with the U.S. Department of Transportation. Pittsburgh lost out on the $50 million in funding, he contended, because Uber was absent on the application.
Around the same time, he jabbed the company for Mr. Kalanick’s involvement in a business advisory council under President Donald Trump.
A few months later, the mayor said the company had a “moral obligation” to provide economic benefits to the communities it tests in. Mr. Peduto was also irked by Uber’s decision to begin charging for trips in the autonomous cars that were originally piloted as free.
Pittsburgh Technology Council, a trade organization based in the South Side, said it has reached out to the mayor’s office to see if it could help Uber and the city find middle ground, but had not heard back yet as of Thursday afternoon.
“We think it’s a special thing to have Uber operating here in southwestern Pennsylvania ... but we also think safety is important,” said Brian Kennedy, senior vice president for operations and government affairs. “We look forward to hearing what Uber has learned and how they can operate safely in the city.”
Courtney Linder: clinder@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1707. Twitter: @LinderPG.
Updated at 6:30 p.m. May 24, 2018.
Join the Tech.pgh Community!




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.