n an alternate universe, hopefuls in the dating pool log on to their app of choice, a set of algorithms scans their social networks and a few options for the perfect significant other pop up.
And even better, the dating prospects don’t sit next to you at work and you probably never went to high school with them. Plus, your matches will almost always have a college degree.
That’s not a nugget from the dystopian sci-fi Netflix series “Black Mirror” — it’s the premise behind a controversial dating app new to Pittsburghers, called The League.
Created by a Carnegie Mellon University alumna, Amanda Bradford, in January 2015, The League is a San Francisco-based dating app that uses data from Facebook and LinkedIn to match users with a significant other who shares the same values as them.
But not everyone is invited to the party.
An advanced screening algorithm, tied to data on LinkedIn, keeps most applicants out of their city’s “founding class” of users on the app. When The League launched in Pittsburgh on Dec. 12, just 21 percent were accepted: 512 of 2,537.
Read More
That has some critics decrying the app as elitist, although Ms. Bradford and her staff maintain that The League’s selectivity is a way to use data for social good — especially in empowering women to question the social dynamics of dating.
“We’re using technology to improve all aspects of our life, so why not also improve our dating life through technology?” said Meredith Davis, head of communications at The League.
Mining data for love
When Ms. Bradford, now 33, was finishing up her MBA at Stanford Graduate School of Business in 2014, she exited a long-term relationship and found herself single for the first time in years.
The dating apps she used just weren’t cutting it; they were wasting her time with matches that weren’t really matches at all. So, with a background in business and information systems, she created an app of her own.
The League, which defines itself as a curated network of professionals looking to meet one another, accepts only a small fraction of applicants to maintain an aura of exclusivity and to keep the community true to its mission.
And being choosy is encouraged — users can self-select traits they would rather not find in a match. After all, The League gives its members only five choices per day.
“While your mother may call you picky, we call you self-aware,” reads part of the website’s mission statement, which also mentions that users may want to self-select partners based on their neighborhood, how attractive they are or their height.
Similar to Tinder, if both users “like” each other, it’s a match, and they can then message.
To date, The League has received at least $2.28 million in backing from seed and venture capital rounds according to Crunchbase, a platform for companies to self-report their funding.
Jack Li, a 33-year-old doctor from Lawrenceville, said he has had more success with The League than other dating services he has used in the past.
“It’s definitely different from a lot of the apps that are out there … the quality of people on there are more in line with my background and experiences,” he said. “When I go on dates, I feel like I have more of a fit with these people.”
And thanks to The League, Ms. Bradford, herself, is no longer single.
“I built the app for myself,” she said. “It was so weird that I wrote the algorithm and found someone.”
Dating and...pierogies
Not surprisingly, the city of quirks — and sports, food, tech and (formerly) steel — has exhibited some interesting trends on the app, even after only a month of operation.
The League’s current framework includes a community of groups that fall under general interest categories, like biking, but also specialty groups that appeal to regional users.
For example, there are two requests per day to add a Steelers group to The League’s platform, on average, which Ms. Davis said the company will soon include. Such groups function like a giant chat room and present a way to meet not only potential dates, but also friends.
And the “About Me” sections are even more Yinzer-centric: Ms. Davis noted that, unsurprisingly, pierogies are mentioned in users’ biographical information more often than any other city.
Exhibit A: “You bet your Pierogies I’m a diehard Steelers fan.”
Exhibit B: “Message first. I’ll Pierogie race ya.”
Although correlation doesn’t equal causation, users are also 10 percent more likely to be accepted, or “hearted,” if they mention pierogies or the Steelers.
Those regional interests don’t necessarily mean that it’s easy for young professionals to find dates without an app, though, Ms. Bradford said.
Because Pittsburgh is a city of neighborhoods, broken up with a challenging terrain of rivers and hills, “dating becomes harder,” she said. “Everyone is in their own little cliques; it’s like high school.”
In Pittsburgh, The League is pushing to get people in medical, tech and creative fields together so they can meet in scenarios where they otherwise would not.
“I think people in Pittsburgh tend to stay in their first-degree circles,” Ms. Bradford said.
The top three employers of The League users in Pittsburgh include UPMC, PNC and Dick’s Sporting Goods.

Exclusive or excluding?
The app’s selectivity, touted as its secret sauce, also forms The League’s complicated rap sheet.
Elizabeth Fein, an assistant professor of psychology at Duquesne University, said some accusations that The League is elitist may be grounded in the company’s proprietary algorithm for selecting members.
The algorithm, which is essentially a set of rules that the computer program follows, is not available to public eyes. And outside The League, computer scientists are constantly grappling with internal bias built into their algorithms — a common ethical dilemma.
“There has been a lot of concern out there about the kind of black-boxing of these processes,” said Ms. Fein, who holds a Ph.D. from the University of Chicago. “How is our credit evaluated? How do landlords select tenants? These decisions are often made by algorithms and people don’t always understand how they work.”
Further, Ms. Fein worries that entrance requirements for users, such as being “high-achieving,” are not quantifiable, or at least not in one plane.
High achievement may manifest itself as the ability to get into a prestigious university, she said, or it might mean the ambition to start your own small business or find the best possible care for someone with a disability.
“They’re talking about qualities … as if that were an individual personality trait,” Ms. Fein said. “But being high-achieving isn’t just about how smart you are or how driven you are. It’s also about your opportunities and the resources you’re given to achieve your goals.”
Like a country club, she said, an algorithm that considers one facet of success could reinforce class distinctions.
In Pittsburgh, the top three neighborhoods where The League users live include some of the most expensive properties in the city: Lawrenceville, Shadyside and Squirrel Hill.
Twelve percent of users graduated from the University of Pittsburgh, where annual tuition has risen to $18,130 for students in the arts and sciences, and 11 percent graduated from CMU, which costs $52,732 per year for a Pennsylvania resident.
Of course, The League isn’t the only app that has been branded as elitist.
Others are Tinder Select, a members-only version of the well-known swipe-right app that features A-listers, CEOs and supermodels; Raya, which is branded as a community for creatives but has caught flak for primarily including celebrities; Sparkology, an app “that caters to young and successful professionals in the metropolitan scene”; and Luxy, a millionaire dating service.
Ms. Bradford’s reaction to The League’s controversy?
“It depends on how feisty I’m feeling,” she said with a laugh. “Unless they’re going to call all of the workplaces and educational institutions elitist, I don’t think an application-based app is elitist.”
Join the Tech.pgh Community!
Sign up for Courtney Linder's free newsletter.
Courtney Linder: clinder@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1707. Twitter: @LinderPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.