If a robot is interacting with you, it should probably apologize if it malfunctions.

That’s a general rule of thumb that Jodi Forlizzi discovered while creating an artificial scenario for a robot that she knew would make mistakes.

“We can vary how the robot would recover from its error,” Ms. Forlizzi said. “We can try hundreds of different things and test them out with people and see how they actually respond before we actually build the technology.”

As an interaction designer, she’s tasked with building these “user enactments” that let researchers dig into the ways people will react to technology.

Advertise with us

In November, Andrew Moore, dean of the school of computer science, named Ms. Forlizzi director of the 25-year-old Human-Computer Interaction Institute at Carnegie Mellon University, which examines relationships between computer technology, human activity and society.

Her pathway into a tech career was unorthodox.

“Imagine someone in art school then moving to one of the leading science schools in Philadelphia and forging a lot of interesting relationships,” she said, reminiscing on her early years. “I’m definitely an outlier.”

Catching the research bug

After graduating from the University of the Arts in Philadelphia with a bachelor’s degree in illustration, she worked as an artist.

Advertise with us

Before long, she was designing highly technical illustrations for science textbooks, creating graphics on stuttering and taste research at the University of Pennsylvania. That work was formative because those were her first interactions with scientists.

She officially caught the research bug and went back to school to earn her master’s degree in interaction design from CMU, then a nascent field.

In 1998, she began working as an innovator and project manager for former boutique qualitative research firm E-Lab LLC, based in Chicago. Half of the staff there were designers and the rest were anthropologists and social scientists, all working to research new product designs for companies in the automotive, personal care and utilities industries.

But Cambridge-based IT provider Sapient Corporation acquired the firm, and “the lovely, funky office” was going to change dramatically.  In 2000, she received a call from the former heads of the design department at CMU, asking her to join the school’s faculty. This looked like a chance to gain a foothold in design research.

After six years on CMU’s staff, her lead mentor suggested that Ms. Forlizzi earn her Ph.D. She felt it unnecessary at the time — after all, the Wilkinsburg resident already had secured the job she wanted.

Advertise with us

Nonetheless, she went on to earn a Ph.D. in human-computer interaction from CMU in 2007. Her research: the way people cleaned with iRobot’s Roomba vaccuum cleaners in the home.

Her takeaways?

With the Roomba, people vacuum the house more often — at times other than on their scheduled cleaning days; men and kids were excited to use it; handheld vacuums were left in the — ahem — dust after a time, while people continued to use the Roomba a year later; and this type of technology could help the elderly, who have a difficult time lugging around heavy cleaning equipment.

Fifty different solutions

Interaction designers pore over what they call “wicked problems,” or complex, societal issues that could have many different solutions.

Advertise with us

To solve the dearth of fresh drinking water in developing countries, for example, you might design bottles. Or transportation mechanisms. Or policy. There’s not one correct answer, and that’s something Ms. Forlizzi knows well.

While working on human-computer interaction problems in health care, she observed private homes and facilities to discover how the elderly declined. Then she came up with 50 different ways that robotic technologies could help.

Next, she grouped those into five areas. One dealt with assistance for those who spend most of their time in one chair, another tackled ways to help elderly people who don’t live near their children or other family members who can help them.

Ultimately, she sharpened her focus on electronic health records because documentation is not usually accessible to patients. Over the summer, she received a grant from the National Science Foundation to research open notes in health care records.

In another scenario, Ms. Forlizzi and a team of about 15 technologists, designers and human designers created a “snack bot” that delivered either healthy or sugary treats to CMU staff and found that people might change their selection if they felt judged by a robot.

Advertise with us

People could opt into study, then visit a website to order cookies, candy or fruit. The snackbot would bring it to their office.

Sometimes the robot brought exactly what was ordered and left. Sometimes, it strategically delivered unappetizing, crumbly looking cookies and shiny apples.

When the robot interacted with paraticipants, sometimes it simply chattered about campus events, like the annual Carnival celebration at the end of spring term. Other times, it knew specific information about the person. As a result, participants sometimes pretended to be other people and in other cases formed relationships of reciprocity where they gave the robot gifts.

“Now that data is more available, we can really look at the ways we can personalize people’s service,” she said.

‘I didn’t know what design was’

Advertise with us

Ms. Forlizzi said she’ll cut down her teaching time to make room for her new duties as director of the Institute, but she’ll remain a professor of service design, one of the most popular courses for graduate students pursuing degrees in human-computer interaction.

Students in her course — who come from backgrounds as disparate as firefighting and performing in Japan as a rock star — work in teams to identify a problem area, come up with solutions and find a real-world client.

Last semester, students worked with PNC Bank to design financial services for parents and teens. In the past, groups have worked with the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, UPMC and even local co-ops to design solutions for Wilkinsburg residents who have trouble finding food.

As director, she not only wants to revise the Institute’s mission, develop a hiring strategy and pitch new projects, but she wants to home in on which skills incoming students need.

“I think we are struggling in HCI and in design education to figure out what are the skills we should be teaching,” Ms. Forlizzi said, wondering where traditional design skills, like typography and color, fall in line with artificial intelligence and machine learning courses.

Advertise with us

She also believes it’s imperative to increase recognition of her field.

“Even as a kid in high school, I thought, ‘Oh, I want to be an artist.’ I didn’t think I wanted to be a designer because I didn’t know what design was.”

In the meantime, Ms. Forlizzi is eager to share her office space with a social robot named Pearl — the first robot she saw in the director’s office when she first came to CMU 18 years ago.

The now-elderly-care robot was like an early version of Amazon’s Alexa technology, verbalizing reminders for patients to take their prescriptions, among other duties.

“She’s a legacy,” Ms. Forlizzi said, smiling. “She’s the Lucille Ball of robots.”

Advertise with us

Join the Tech.pgh Community!

Sign up for Courtney Linder's free newsletter.

Courtney Linder: clinder@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1707. Twitter: @LinderPG.