When customers of First Niagara Bank receive their new chip-enabled “smart” credit cards in the coming months, the cards may take some getting used to.

Instead of signing for purchases like they always have, card holders will be required to enter a personal identification number, or PIN, at the register.

As the U.S. payments industry converts to smart cards embedded with microchips from the old magnetic stripe technology favored by fraudsters, First Niagara is breaking from the crowd. The Buffalo, N.Y.-based bank has chosen to use PIN codes, while the vast majority of its card-issuing brethren have decided on the traditional signature option — even though PINs are considered more secure.

So-called chip-and-PIN technology has been the standard in Europe and elsewhere for many years. The conversion to chip cards in the U.S. had been stalled until the massive data breaches at Target and others kickstarted the effort. But most banks aren’t fully embracing the European model, saying they want to spare customers the hassle of entering another four-digit code.

Advertise with us

That’s why most banks, such as Pittsburgh market leader PNC Bank, say they’re keeping the current system of signing for credit card purchases. Chip-enabled debit cards will continue to have PIN codes.

“PNC wants to minimize the inconvenience to its customers and retailers who may not have the infrastructure in place to accept chip-and-PIN for credit cards,” PNC spokeswoman Marcey Zwiebel explained in an email.

She noted that chip-and-signature cards are still more secure than the outdated mag stripe cards.

For First Niagara, the fifth biggest retail bank in the Pittsburgh region, the decision to go with PINs wasn’t easy, said Justin Bigham, head of consumer products management for the bank.

A major deciding factor was a recent MasterCard study that found roughly two-thirds of consumers said they would prefer using PINs with their credit cards, given the added security benefits, Mr. Bigham said.

Advertise with us

While chip cards are much more difficult to counterfeit than mag stripe cards, they don’t stop thieves from making purchases with lost or stolen cards. That’s where PINs help out. PINs can’t be faked like signatures.

First Niagara decided that the benefits of using the personal identification numbers outweighed any customer disruptions.

“We think the industry will end there eventually, so why not move there today rather than slow walk it with signatures?” Mr. Bigham said.

First Niagara began mailing customers their new chip and PIN cards this month and expects to complete the process by early next year. The bank has about 250,000 credit and 880,000 debit card accounts.

Like all new chip cards being issued in the U.S., the First Niagara cards will continue to include traditional magnetic stripes so the cards can be used at retail locations that haven’t yet upgraded their terminals to accept chip cards.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, representatives of the retail industry have been pushing Congress to step in and back the use of PINs.

“Retailers want all banks in the United States to implement chip-and-PIN, as it has been proven to dramatically reduce fraud everywhere else it has been implemented,” said Jason Brewer, senior vice president at the Retail Industry Leaders Association. Card fraud in the U.S. amounts to some $5.5 billion annually.

The FBI last week issued a memo to consumers encouraging them to use PINs at the register instead of signatures when they receive their new chip-enabled credit cards. "This fully utilizes the security features built within the [card]," the agency said.

The agency also advised people to shield the keypad from bystanders when entering a PIN, and recommended that merchants ask to see government-issued photo IDs to verify the identity of cardholders using a signature.

At Target, where the massive breach compromised personal data of roughly 100 million people who used credit or debit cards there at the end of 2013, the retailer is using PIN technology for its chip-enabled proprietary REDcards. The company has been accepting chip card payments at the register since mid-August.

Advertise with us

Last week was the deadline for U.S. retailers to have the equipment in place to process chip card transactions. If they don’t, they’ll start bearing the cost of certain fraudulent transactions that had been previously absorbed by card issuers.

Chip cards are more secure because they generate a unique security code for each transaction. If a hacker were to steal the codes, they would be useless because they can’t be reused.

For consumers, the biggest change will be getting used to inserting, or “dipping,” their cards into card readers instead of swiping them.

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.