Karl Rove was the only Bush administration staffer who had it on Air Force One on Sept. 11, 2001. Barack Obama famously resisted giving up his after being elected president in 2008. And the paparazzi captured Sarah Jessica Parker's twins chewing on hers.

The BlackBerry -- aka the Crackberry, the addictive, must-have accessory for political and professional elites since the late 1990s -- may at last be heading the way of the '57 Chevy, technically obsolete in light of the iPhone and other glitzy touchscreen devices but forever emblematic of an era.

On June 17, BlackBerry's stock priced tumbled after the phone's Canadian manufacturer, Research in Motion, announced layoffs in the wake of worse-than-expected quarterly profits.

In a statement, RIM's co-CEO Jim Balsillie said, "Fiscal 2012 has gotten off to a challenging start. The slowdown we saw in the first quarter is continuing into Q2 and delays in new product introductions into the very late part of August are leading to a lower-than-expected outlook in the second quarter."

Advertise with us

That announcement triggered an online deluge of BlackBerry obituaries by disenchanted users -- "Wheels Coming Off at Research At Motion," blared the headlines -- mostly criticizing RIM for its complacency in responding to new touchscreen technologies pioneered by Apple's iPhone in 2007 and, more recently, by the heavily marketed Android.

"RIM has given up on its users and taken itself out of the fight. Therefore I have given up on RIM," wrote "a once-loyal customer of RIM who decided he can't take it anymore," posting on www.Crackberry.com.

So what happened?

Besides the company's failure to compete with the new generation of touchscreen smartphones, there are other factors at play, experts say. And some believe predictions of its demise are premature.

But there's no doubt that the BlackBerry -- the first handheld email device to truly penetrate into the American mainstream -- has some serious catching up to do.

Advertise with us

"When Steve Jobs introduced the iPhone in January 2007, the folks at RIM should have immediately called a crisis meeting," said Walt Mossberg, the Wall Street Journal's technology columnist. "It was a complete gamechanger."

"The nice people at RIM did not keep up with what made them great," added Shelly Palmer, author of "Beyond the Digital Divide: How to Use Social Media and Digital Tools to Reinvent Yourself and Your Career." "They essentially allowed the iPhone, and later the Android, to eat their lunch."

The BlackBerry originally catered to business users, touting its ease of integration with existing in-house corporate computer systems. Companies bought them up by the thousands. The phone, in fact, was made for company IT departments, not individual consumers, experts say, noting that they excelled early on at security and corporate integration.

That, in fact, is how the BlackBerry took off -- "by selling 25,000 phones a pop to a General Motors rather than to 25,000 individuals walking around," Mr. Palmer said.

"They became ubiquitous in business because corporate IT directors said to their CEOs, 'Oh, you want a handheld?' Well the BlackBerry is the easiest for us."

Advertise with us

That was because after signing a contract with a company, BlackBerry representatives would install an email server inside that company which would be directly connected with RIM's computers in Canada, which would handle all email traffic. A company's IT staff was always on a first-name basis with BlackBerry troubleshooters.

Individual consumers caught on quickly, however, becoming fans of its tactile keyboard. Plus, BlackBerry's carriers, Verizon and Sprint, were more reliable than AT&T's sketchier network, which made operating an iPhone in Manhattan and other places an exercise in frustration.

Now, though, the iPhone is on Verizon's network, and Microsoft Exchange and other servers are as secure as BlackBerry's was.

Employees have been pressuring companies to allow them to use their iPhones and their Androids and their other smartphones for business, instead of a company-issued BlackBerry.

Indeed, BlackBerry's slump is signaling another trend: "the demise of the corporate IT crowd," said Rodger Morrow, a Sewickley-based speechwriter and communications consultant. And with shrinking bottom lines, these days, "Corporations are now trying to get out of the hardware business, and would much rather outsource their IT to Apple or Google, given those companies 'cloud' storage capabilities," he said.

Advertise with us

Compared with the large, colorful screens of the iPhone, and all its features, the BlackBerry, whose App store is minimal, at best, "just isn't as emotionally satisfying," Mr. Palmer said, noting that the ergonomics and aesthetics of the iPhone and the Android "make them far more easy to use, with every button or icon where you'd expect it to be."

Culturally, the BlackBerry did seem to represent the new Millennium. In his memoirs, Mr. Rove recalled how his colleagues gaped at his ability to communicate on 9/11 through his BlackBerry -- even as all other government communications shut down. Washington workaholics, such as political analyst Mark Halperin, were described in profiles as multitasking on a BlackBerry while working out on a Stairmaster.

There's even a website called celebrityblackberrysightings.com ("January Jones rocking her BlackBerry while shopping."), but, perhaps tellingly, recent photos showed actress Jennifer Love Hewitt with her new iPhone 4.

While teenagers like BlackBerry's BBM messaging application, the phone's popularity among America's business class made them openly suspect among some young iconoclasts -- who couldn't really afford them anyway.

"I used to openly ridicule my friends who had them," said Lance Uppercut, 24, of Wilkinsburg, who works at Avalon, a hip used-clothing store in Squirrel Hill. "They were too business-oriented for me."

Advertise with us

Still, at least one Pittsburgher isn't ready to let go yet.

"They'll have to pry it out of my cold dead hands," declared Barbara Schwarck, an executive coach based in Regent Square who travels frequently. She praises the phone's tiny, easy-to-use keyboard, its long battery life and ability to make inexpensive calls overseas just by exchanging its U.S. "SIM" card for a foreign one.

That flexibility made the BlackBerry coveted abroad, and the company's international revenue did increase 67 percent year-over-year.

For a time, they were expensive and hard to find outside the U.S., Ms. Schwarck recalled. Two Saudi Arabian exchange students who lived with her bought their own and when they returned home, "sold them for a whole bunch of money."

But therein lies a problem, argues Mr. Palmer, noting that highly secure emails couldn't be hacked until the company, under political pressure, "made a whole lot of deals with foreign governments," including the United Arab Emirates.

Advertise with us

Some aren't ready to turn their back on the company yet, citing its favorable balance sheet, with more than $2 billion of cash and no debt. Plus, its operations generated nearly a billion dollars of cash last quarter alone -- plenty to use for new R&D.

"While the old, outdated, BlackBerry as we knew it may be dying, I am not buying the conventional wisdom that RIM can't remake the BlackBerry in an all-new way," said Mr. Mossberg, noting that in 1997, Apple was nearly bankrupt just before Steve Jobs returned. "While BlackBerry has stumbled, I'm not willing to write them off. Companies make comebacks."

Still, the company's forays into touchscreen technology -- at least initially -- were a disaster. The BlackBerry Storm, unveiled as the iPhone's competitor, was nearly impossible to use, consumers said.

And while RIM has sold nearly 500,000 Playbook tablets so far, that device has been criticized for having an operating system that wasn't built in-house, plus it currently doesn't support email without connecting to a BlackBerry.

While the jury is still out, it looks as though an American cultural icon, once a symbol of with-it-ness, may be headed for a museum near you, Mr. Morrow said.

Advertise with us

"I'm sitting here in the Sewickley Starbucks, across from a friend, watching him working on the new iPad 2," Mr. Morrow said last week.

"Two years ago, it would have been his iPhone. Four years ago, he would have been sitting there with his BlackBerry."

Mackenzie Carpenter: mcarpenter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1949.