With his hands moving among controls, his sock-covered feet shifting among wooden pedals, and his eyes locked onto a computer monitor, James Garver looked like he was playing a wigged-out version of Bach on a high-tech organ.

But what the 57-year-old gynecological surgeon really was doing June 11 in an Allegheny General Hospital surgical suite was a robotic-assisted laparoscopic hysterectomy on his 28-year-old patient, Tinisha Nelson, of the North Side.

His "organ" was the control console of the da Vinci Surgical System. The hand controls operated the robotic arms -- three instrument arms and one endoscope arm -- by which Dr. Garver was removing Mrs. Nelson's uterus. His feet controlled cauterization and clutch pedals that allow the surgeon to change from one operating arm to another and to help manipulate the laparoscope. The monitor showed him Mrs. Nelson's reproductive organs in three dimensions and magnified at 10 to 15 times normal size.

Pulled up to the leg end of the operating table was the patient-side cart to which the instrument arms were attached. A supporting surgical team comprising a physician assistant, a scrub nurse, a circulating nurse and a nurse anesthetist stood ready to assist with tasks such as equipping the arms with the proper instruments; positioning the endoscope; and moving the uterus as the surgeon was freeing it from an ovary.

Advertise with us

The da Vinci, developed and produced by Intuitive Surgical Inc., of Sunnyvale, Calif., was first used for a gall bladder removal in Europe in early 1997. Then in July of that year, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration approved its use for surgical assistance. In July 2000 it was approved for laparoscopic procedures, and, a company spokeswoman said, it was approved for use in a radical prostatectomy in May 2001. It was approved for gynecological procedures in 2005.

It was, and sometimes still is, greeted with skepticism by gynecologic surgeons who do traditional laparoscopic procedures by hand.

They cited the $1.6 million price tag, saying it made the procedure much more costly than a regular laparoscopy. They also pointed to the fact that it requires four or five dime-sized incisions compared to traditional laparoscopy's three or four slightly smaller cuts; the loss of the surgeon's sense of touch; the fact that the surgery takes a little longer; the need for special training -- and even what they saw as a direct patient advertising campaign to create demand for the procedure and the product.

"It's a little bit of a gimmick," said Dr. Vladimir Nikiforouk, a surgeon at Ohio Valley Hospital.

Intuitive Surgical and its advocates argued the hospital could quickly make up the purchase price because patients heal faster and with fewer complications, thus leaving the hospital sooner; that bleeding is greatly reduced; and training amounts to just a couple days and a learning curve that is dependent upon previous laparoscopic experience.

Advertise with us

Some who specialized in laparoscopy couldn't see messing with success.

"Because we are so good with traditional laparoscopy, we didn't jump on the robot immediately," said Dr. Ted Lee, director of minimally invasive gynecological surgery at Magee-Womens Hospital of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. But Dr. Lee did his first one back in December 2007 anyway, and Magee now is getting what will be UPMC's second da Vinci. Shadyside Hospital of UPMC, Western Pennsylvania Hospital and the Veterans Administration Hospital have one each.

Dr. Garver understands the doubts -- he had them too.

"I'm a fairly skeptical person, and I'd been doing laparoscopy quite a few years," he said. "My initial feeling was why would the hospital even buy something like this?" After training he was ready to use it.

"I'll try almost everything, and after using it a few times I really was impressed," he said, citing reduced bleeding; greater range of motion with the instruments; fewer complications; reduced recuperation periods; and a greater ease in operating on larger uteruses and/or larger women.

He said, "With da Vinci, everything is much, much better."