Businesses in Pennsylvania have tapped into at least $1.9 billion in state grants, loans and subsidies in the past five years, promising everything from new jobs to green-friendly buildings to the revitalization of down-and-out corridors.
As part of a state-by-state project last fall, a Washington, D.C., economic policy group, Good Jobs First, sought answers to two questions:
One, how easily can the public find out details online about who's getting the money and why?
As a bonus follow-up: How easy is it to find out whether those companies kept their word?
Pennsylvania came out ahead of nearly all other states, finishing fourth for the relative ease of its economic development Web site in letting surfers find details on grant recipients.
On the other hand, Good Jobs First gave the site a grade of only C, or 73 percent, which suggests the field as a whole wasn't exactly awash in sunshine.
"We're as transparent as the law allows," Pennsylvania Department of Community and Economic Development spokesman Kevin Ortiz said, referring to the open-access search program at www.dced.state.pa.us/investmenttracker. The engine allows the public to ferret out facts based on county, program, applicant and date range.
Mr. Ortiz said, "The main purpose behind our tracker is to serve the general public. I think we're far more transparent than other states about where taxpayer dollars go in terms of economic development."
"The State of State Disclosure" also assessed two other Web site online databases concerning lobbyists, where Pennsylvania finished 31st, and state procurement contracts, where it came in at 29th but with a thumbs-up asterisk.
Few if any changes have been made since the report came out in November, said lead researcher Phillip Mattera, that would earn the Department of State's relatively new lobbying site or DCED's a new grade.
But that's not the case with the Department of General Services' "e-Marketplace" overhaul regarding state procurement, which he said would now put it among the nation's best.
As a result, he said, Pennsylvania might well deserve to rise a notch or two above its overall 12th-place finish.
Ironically, Pennsylvania's point total for lobbying disclosure, its weakest link, was only 3 points lower than for economic development. Mr. Mattera explained that the respective rankings mirrored the level of competition: states overall have done a much better job at disclosing data on lobbyists than who's getting economic development funds.
So, Pennsylvania came on strong in a relatively weak field.
Still, Mr. Mattera credited Pennsylvania with having one of the best economic development sites because it was well-designed, relatively robust and easy to navigate, not requiring someone to click his way to other Web domains.
As an example, enter Eaton, Allegheny County, and a recent date range. The next screen produces Eaton Corp. in Moon, an electrical equipment manufacturer that received a $600,000 Keystone Opportunity Grant good for 30 new jobs.
So why only a C-?
Mr. Mattera said the tracker occasionally had old data, hard-to-find links and only summary information. In Eaton's case, for instance, the online result bore no mention that the grant was for a $24 million, green-certified addition in Moon. The 120,000-square-foot facility should be open in August.
At an Open House in May, Eaton officials suggested the job total might also change, to reflect a total work force closer to 850 and not 800.
In Eaton's case, the online data might reflect an off-target estimate few would complain about.
Good Jobs First is more concerned about what happens when companies come up short.
If the first step of its initiative was to assess each site, Mr. Mattera said "the second step was to go beyond the simple facts and look at some outcomes."
"That's where I'd say all the states have some ways to go, to look at the effectiveness of the subsidies and the contracts at reaching the desired results."
Mr. Ortiz said it would be difficult but not impossible to provide Web updates to let the public know when a company hasn't delivered.
While laggards aren't flagged online, the department does audit companies, and the results are made public upon request.
"They sign a contract for a particular grant. The norm is that we provide a three-year window to meet those requirements," Mr. Ortiz said. "Then we will go back to them and ask them to provide documentation that they actually provided those jobs."
"There's times when they've come up short and we actually asked them for the money back," he said, although this occurs rarely -- about 2 percent of the time since 2003 based on a review of Opportunity Grants, the main funnel for job-creation money.
One local example: National Real Estate Information Services in Kennedy committed to creating 1,105 jobs in return for a $500,000 grant in 2004. It was able to create only 465, Mr. Ortiz said, so the state is in the process of collecting $135,000.
A company official said the mortgage settlement firm fell victim to the mortgage lending crisis.
That's the kind of follow-up Good Jobs First recommended as being a long-term goal in this age of so-called "Google Government." not just for Pennsylvania but all 50 states.
"On the one hand, it is encouraging to see what some states are doing to harness the power of the Internet," the report concluded.
"What Illinois is doing with subsidies, what Wisconsin is doing with lobbying and what several states are doing with procurement provide good models of online transparency."
"We commend the disclosure leaders and urge the laggards to emulate them."
The full Good Jobs First report can be found online at www.goodjobsfirst.org.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.