QUESTION: Do you use height speakers in your home theater, and if not, why? I would like to hear your thoughts on them.
RICHARAD SHIRLEY
Columbia, S.C.
A. Height speakers are a relatively new development in the world of surround sound. A typical surround system has five or seven speakers, plus a subwoofer. A five-speaker surround system has front left and right main speakers, a center channel and two surround speakers. A seven-speaker surround system adds two back speakers to the mix. Both setups create a 360-degree surround field. Height speakers are mounted on the ceiling in the front to add a dimension of height to this surround field.
There are several reasons I do not use height speakers in my own home theater. First of all, my home theater processor, an Anthem AVM 50, does not support height speakers. That means I would need a new processor, and it would cost more than $5,000 to get something comparable to what I have now that supports height speakers. Then I would need an amplifier and the speakers themselves on top of the new processor. I would not spend more than $5,000 to add height speakers, especially since I think the benefit is questionable and I am happy with a conventional surround sound experience.
Height speakers seem like overkill to me, at least in terms of the typical home entertainment consumer. My email inbox has a lot more messages from people looking to avoid complexity than those looking to add it.
For example, I regularly get emails from readers looking to buy surroundbars or wireless speakers so they can avoid running speaker wires across the room. I can think of two or three the past few days, just off the top of my head. Other than yours, I can't remember the last time I received a question about height speakers. They may be suitable for some people, though.
Let's say you want a surround system with five or seven speakers and a subwoofer. If you have a big, dedicated room, lots of money and want the best home theater experience possible, then I say sure, go for it! Get a projector or huge TV, a top-of-the-line receiver and lots of great speakers including two for height. Set it up properly and it will certainly sound great.
Next, let's take a more typical movie watcher who wants a home theater with five speakers and a subwoofer to be placed in his family room. Here I go back to thinking it isn't worth it.
First of all, you have speaker placement. Most people have trouble getting five speakers optimally placed in a family room or living room. Adding two more on the ceiling just adds complexity.
Next, you have financial considerations. Suppose you have a $2,500 budget, of which $600 is allocated for the receiver and $300 for the subwoofer. This leaves $1,600 for speakers.
If you buy five speakers, it works out to an average of $320 per speaker. If you need five speakers plus the two height speakers, it is only $228 per speaker, almost $100 less apiece. At the lower price points, that extra $100 per speaker goes a long way in terms of sound quality. I'd rather have great sound from five speakers than mediocre sound from seven speakers.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.