Question: You seem to prefer plasma TVs. But when I shop and compare, I always seem drawn to the LCD models because they seem so bright and sharp. Are their situations where you prefer LCD?
G. BRINKS, Sacramento, Calif.
Answer: Though I have indicated a clear preference for plasma, LCD TVs can be excellent as well. LCD TVs produce a bright, pixel-sharp image that some prefer, especially for playing video games or for use in rooms with lots of ambient light. You are better off with an excellent LCD TV than a mediocre plasma model; and in smaller sizes (less than 42 inches), LCD models are your only choice. Smaller TVs do not exhibit motion blur as prominently, so even 60 Hz models are fine performers.
Samsung is the LCD TV leader, with cutting-edge technology, excellent picture quality, and a wide variety of models at all price points. You also would do well to check out Toshiba. Toshiba has some of the nicest-looking LCD TVs out there, and selling prices often undercut Samsung significantly, especially in larger screen sizes and for LED models.
Speaking of LED models, "LED TV" is something of a misnomer. The "LED TVs" you see sold in stores are simply LCD TVs that use an LED backlight instead of a fluorescent backlight. LED light sources create very precise, pure light that produces better color and deeper blacks than ordinary LCD TVs. The difference in picture quality can be astounding. In fact, some of the most beautiful images I have ever seen displayed on a flat panel TV were on Samsung LED-LCD sets.
What keeps me from buying one of these TVs for myself is problems with moving subjects. I have not put a Samsung LED-LCD through a comprehensive test yet, but when watching demo material in stores I often see fuzziness on the edge of moving subjects that a TV salesman I know refers to as a "swarm of mosquitoes." These moving image artifacts come from this particular set's video processing and not the LED light source, and not all LCDs or LED-LCDs have this problem.
Plasma technology does not have these issues at all. Combined with plasma's natural colors, wide viewing angle, and low cost, it leads me to believe it is the way to go for most people.
Still, if that pure, near-perfect, ultrasharp image makes you reach for your wallet to take an LED-LCD home for yourself, I would never fault you for it. It is a matter of perception and taste, and you may not see the motion artifacts as much as I do.
LED-LCD TVs are typically much more expensive than plasma or LCD sets of similar size. There are exceptions, notably some recently introduced small HDTVs that use LED technology. Best Buy recently introduced two LED-LCD televisions under their Insignia house brand, and both are excellent. The 19-inch Insignia NS-19E430A10 lists for $249 and the 22-inch NS-22E430A10 for $299. I consider the latter to be one of the best buys going (pun unintended) if you are looking for a small television. The picture is sharp, clean, smooth and colorful, standing out noticeably compared to televisions placed beside it, just as you would expect from an LED-LCD TV. The two-year warranty seals the deal.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.