Q: I want to buy a digital video recorder. I am only interested in the HD channels from my antenna and do not want to subscribe to any service.
I have heard that TiVo is significantly better than any other option. If it really is the only (or the best) solution, I could bite the bullet and pay the TiVo subscription fee, would just rather not. Also, any possibility of getting one machine that also has a Blu-Ray player and recorder included?
TODD MILLER
Oakland, Calif.
A: Answering your last question first, though Blu-ray recorders are very popular in Japan there are no plans to introduce home entertainment Blu-ray recorders in North America. This is due to content producers' piracy concerns.
You may find it interesting that Blu-ray was developed as a home recording format, and the discs came in cartridges you loaded into the player/recorder, just like the old RCA Selectavision videodiscs. The discs came in cartridges because the data layer is very close to the surface of the disc and any small scratch would ruin the disc. It was decided that a cartridge format would not be viable as a home entertainment format, so a scratch and smudge resistant hard coat was developed that you find on all Blu-ray discs sold today.
TiVo is widely considered the best, but as you have stated yourself there is a monthly fee and paying a fee when you don't have to goes against the grain of a lot of folks. I'd recommend checking out the DTVPal DVR, a product for Dish Network that sells for $249. It has two tuners so you can watch one channel while recording another, or record two programs simultaneously. It has an HDMI output for use with HDTVs and analog outputs for older televisions. The DTVPal DVR has been in high demand and is currently sold out, but they are accepting back orders. You can see it at www.dtvpal.com.
Q: I know you're a big fan of the Definitive Technology Mythos SSA soundbars and was wondering if you have had a chance to compare it with the new Samsung HTWS1G? For $350 (including the wireless subwoofer) for the Samsung, there certainly is a price difference that can't be ignored, though I imagine the Definitive sounds better.
TERRY BRICKER
Pittsburgh
A: Though they share the same form factor, it is an apples and oranges comparison. The Samsung unit is 2.1, which means stereo and a subwoofer. Signal processing creates a mild surround effect, but the information in the surround channels is not reproduced.
The Definitive surroundbars are five-channel speakers that reproduce the center and surround channel information and create a much more immersive soundfield with much better sound quality.
The price reflects the difference, of course, as the Definitive gear costs three times as much, and you still need a receiver. The Samsung is a standalone unit with built-in electronics.
Consider the Definitive Technology surroundbar as a way to get great home theater sound without running speaker wires around your room, and the Samsung as a way to get better sound than your TV's speakers. If you are looking for the latter, also check out the $499 Polk Audio SDA Surroundbar Instant Home Theater as well. It is likely to sound significantly better than the Samsung for not much more.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.