It was billed as a public update on the proposed restart of the nuclear plant formerly known as Three Mile Island Unit One.

But at times, Tuesday’s Nuclear Regulatory Commission meeting in Middletown felt more like a point/counterpoint on whether, in 2026, the United States should still be willing to bank on nuclear power as a baseload energy source.

That’s what happens when the plant slated for reopening is the original twin of the reactor that experienced the worst commercial nuclear accident in U.S. history.

Make no mistake: There is ample evidence the restart is a winning case for many Pennsylvanians.

Advertise with us

A June survey commissioned by Clean Jobs for Pennsylvania, an advocacy group supporting the restart, shows 70% support for the project when respondents are told it can happen without taxpayer funding.

But at Tuesday’s hearing, the echoes of 1979, when a partial meltdown of TMI’s Unit Two reactor threw much of the Harrisburg area into a panic, were everywhere.

Residents attending in person and online peppered federal regulators with questions pertaining to potential hazards from flooding and terror strikes.

They also expressed great skepticism that emergency preparedness plans — specifically evacuation plans being updated now — would actually work in case of emergency.

“OK, say right now there’s an accident at Three Mile Island. Isn’t it safe to assume it’s every man for himself? ... Doesn’t that negate your evacuation plans?” asked one Middletown man who declined to identify himself beyond noting he lived through the 1979 accident.

Advertise with us

“You have these plans written up by the NRC or whoever ... just to get the approval [for restart] and tell the public were working for their best benefit.”

The regulators pushed back.

NRC spokesman Scott Burnell said history has shown in most cases safety hazards at nuclear power plants play out over hours, if not days.

That means, Burnell said, there is a critical period of time for emergency preparedness officials to execute their plans.

“Bottom line is, there is time available to carry out these plans,” he said.

Advertise with us

Another repeated concern was the prospect of storing more highly radioactive spent fuel on a Susquehanna River island that floods regularly.

So far, all the spent fuel from TMI Unit One’s prior operational life is being held there in dry cask storage, which has become a standard of the industry.

“If this plant restarts, there’ll be 600 more tons [of radioactive waste] without a forwarding address,” said Eric Epstein, chair of the Three Mile Island Alert, the grassroots watchdog group born out of the ‘79 scare.

“I can’t imagine a less secure, more challenging place to store waste.”

The NRC noted the stainless steel casks the nuclear material is contained in are built to withstand floods and other types of natural disasters. Armed guards are stationed nearby to take care of manmade threats.

Advertise with us

The plant itself, NRC officials said in response to another question, is designed so that all equipment needed to bring the plant to a safe shutdown is out of reach of the worst of all possible floods, said Nik Floyd, a senior project manager for the NRC.

For long stretches, the meeting took on the air of a debating society, with lifelong “no nukes” opponents — many from other parts of the country — and members of new advocacy groups like “Generation Nuclear” trading arguments.

“When you talk about nuclear power, most of the conversation ... is about safety,” said Nancy Muse, who called into the meeting from Alabama. “That should sound an alarm for all of us here.”

Meanwhile, local union leaders touted the jobs the restarted plant will bring.

“We wholeheartedly support the refire project which is more about than just producing energy,” said Jim Enders, president of the Central Pennsylvania Building and Construction Trades Council.

Advertise with us

“It’s about creating opportunities for the people who live and work here. ... These are jobs that help our local families thrive,” Enders said.

Beyond the safety fears and policy debates, all indicators suggest Constellation — aided by the tailwinds of a 20-year power purchase agreement with Microsoft — is well on its way to a 2027 restart.

NRC staff said the reactor, now formally renamed Crane Clean Energy Center, is meeting all of its technical milestones.

“There are no showstoppers from like a safety standpoint,” said Erin Carfang, an NRC official who is overseeing inspections at the shuttered plant.

“Equipment condition has been acceptable at this point. So their big ticket items for inspection — the steam generators, which are the large heat exchangers — those were in good condition.”

Advertise with us

Inspections of the nuclear reactor vessel also are passing muster, Carfang said.

NRC Resident Inspector Nate Mentzer had good words for the safety culture he’s seeing at the plant.

“If they find one issue, they’re not just fixing that single issue,” Mentzer said of Constellation’s restart contractors. “They’re going and looking at the rest of the system, the other systems, and trying to identify whether that cause spreads out across the plant.”

The proposed restart has hit several other key benchmarks in recent months, including:

• A decision from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission that will help Constellation send power from the restarted reactor onto the regional power grid without waiting several years for a backlogged queue of transmission improvements.

Advertise with us

• Approval by the Susquehanna River Basin Commission of permits to draw water from the Susquehanna River to support resumed operations.

• NRC approval to accept and store new reactor fuel on Three Mile Island in advance of the restart.

A preliminary environmental assessment also has found that the plant can return to operations with no significant impact on the local environment.

That’s based off of a 2009 baseline, NRC environmental lead Kevin Folk said, performed the last time the then-TMI Unit One was relicensed by the feds.

The updated result means the restart, including revitalization of the site and resumption of operations, should only have impacts “that are either minor or it’s not destabilizing on the resource.”

Advertise with us

Folk’s report, however, was sharply criticized by Epstein as “a rubber stamp, cookie cutter approach to looking at environmental impacts at a nuclear power plant.”

“It just didn’t appear that whoever conducted the environmental assessment had a firm grasp of the area in and around Three Mile Island. In addition to that, there’s too many assumptions based on what’s going to happen after the plant starts. I think that’s a prescription for bad things to happen,” Epstein said.

NRC’s Burnell said current timelines suggest the plant could be recertified for commercial operation as early as March, setting up a potential restart in the second half of the year.

The old TMI Unit One reactor operated safely from its post-accident restart in 1984 until it was shut down for economic reasons in 2019.

Then a sudden uptick in American power demand — spawned by data centers, the growth in artificial intelligence applications and other factors — created a window for Constellation to study a potential restart at the Londonderry Township, Dauphin County, plant.

Advertise with us

The unprecedented restart was green-lighted in late 2024, after Constellation secured a 20-year agreement with Microsoft to purchase all the power coming from the plant.

Now Crane is one of several shuttered nuclear reactors proposed to the NRC for restart, as interest in nuclear power as a stable, zero-emissions power source has revived.

None have actually powered up yet, though the Palisades nuclear plant off Lake Michigan, owned by Holtec International, may restart later this year.