The regional electric grid operator for Pennsylvania and 12 other states agreed Thursday to extend a price cap that has curtailed surging prices for power generation capacity and that had been set to expire.

Valley Forge-based PJM Interconnection’s board of managers moved to continue the cap for its next two capacity auctions, which will determine the price that will be paid to generators for committing to be ready to provide power through mid-2030.

The proposal will be sent to federal energy regulators for approval.

Gov. Josh Shapiro had pushed repeatedly for an extension, writing to PJM’s interim CEO as recently as Tuesday that any increase in the current cap in the near term would be “futile and utterly wasteful of consumers' hard-earned dollars.”

Advertise with us

Continuing the cap also was a key part of a proposal agreed to by the Trump administration and the governors of the 13 PJM states last month to address electricity affordability and reliability in the region.

Capacity auctions are designed to safeguard reliability. They are one way the grid operator ensures there will be enough electricity supply ready to meet future peaks in demand.

Since 2024, as older power plants retired and projected electricity use — especially from data centers — grew, the buffer between supply and demand got tighter and capacity prices soared. Prices in the 2024 auction were more than 800% higher than the previous year.

Mr. Shapiro reached a settlement with PJM in January 2025 to impose a temporary price collar, with both a ceiling and a floor, to put a limit on surging prices.

The current collar had been set to expire before the upcoming auctions this year.

Advertise with us

Mr. Shapiro said continuing the cap at its current rate — $325 per megawatt-day — is expected to save the 67 million people in the PJM footprint $27 billion on energy bills, in addition to the $18 billion that would have been paid during the past two auctions if the cap had not been in place. He said that amounts to about $575 per household in Pennsylvania.

Mr. Shapiro said the results of a PJM survey of its stakeholders last week showed that 95% of those that responded favored extending the price collar, and 147 of the 170 responses favored keeping the cap at the current or lower price levels.

The organization representing public utility commissions in the PJM states, including Pennsylvania, also had written in support of extending the current price cap for the next two auctions.

The electric utilities Duquesne Light and FirstEnergy Utilities also backed an extension but said “more should be done” to protect customers from capacity cost increases, including setting a lower cap.

FirstEnergy said “the recent all-time-high PJM capacity prices” have resulted in average increases of 17% to its residential retail customers’ monthly bills in Pennsylvania, Ohio, New Jersey, West Virginia and Maryland.

Advertise with us

Duquesne Light said its residential retail customers’ monthly bills in Allegheny and Beaver counties had average increases of 10% because of capacity costs.

Others had pushed for the cap to expire.

New York-based LS Power, whose operations in Pennsylvania include natural gas-fired power plants and wind farms, said that federal regulators have determined that “high prices serve important market functions” even when new thermal generation — like gas-fired or nuclear power plants — can’t resolve the supply crunch in the short term because they take more than three years to build.

Other resources could be available sooner, LS Power said, like battery storage, enhancements to existing power plants to boost output or demand-response programs that pay large electricity users to shut down during periods of peak demand.

Allowing prices to rise closer to $550 per megawatt-day — or nearly 70% higher than the current $325 cap — would keep existing plants from retiring and incentivize developers to plan future projects and pursue projects that can be brought online quickly, the company said.

Advertise with us

In his letter, Mr. Shapiro argued that letting the collar expire or extending it with a higher cap “would be a mistake,” effectively raising prices in the hope of enticing generators to add significantly more power sources to the grid, without any realistic chance of that actually happening in the near term.

“In the end, such a move to unilaterally raise prices in your vote this week at PJM would be an unfair transfer of billions of dollars from consumers to existing generators,” he wrote to PJM’s CEO before the vote this week.

PJM has said that wholesale capacity “accounts for a relatively small portion of retail electricity bills.” After an auction last July came in with capacity prices 22% higher than the previous year’s auction, PJM said it would expect that to “translate to a year-over-year increase of 1.5–5% in some customers’ bills.”