As U.S. Steel and Nippon Steel tried to bring their courtship to the finish line earlier this year, they agreed to give the U.S. government and in particular President Donald Trump a powerful say in how the new joint enterprise would be run.

It remains mostly unclear how Trump will wield his “golden share,” though the reversal this fall of U.S. Steel’s plans in Illinois offered an initial clue. Many employees see the provision as a means for greater job security. But critics argue the golden share is accelerating the march toward protectionism from a nation that long valued more open trade and a lighter government touch in corporate affairs.

Although Trump’s vision appears to align so far with U.S. Steel’s own plans for expansion and growth, future presidents could foreseeably push the company in a number of ways: toward greener operations, for instance, or toward even greater reliance on coal.

U.S. Steel executives declined to comment on the golden share, which appears to give the federal government unprecedented authority over a publicly traded company whose production is key to national security. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick did not respond to a request for comment.

Advertise with us

Former U.S. Steel executive Chris Masciantonio said Trump's focus on manufacturing and jobs will benefit U.S. Steel, though he acknowledged the same government stake could be used differently under a new administration.

“I've read recent articles where some writers say, you know, ‘This will be difficult for U.S. Steel to manage,’” he said. “I don't see it that way.”

Mr. Masciantonio acknowledged the provision could force leaders of U.S. Steel to consult more with their legal and government affairs teams, to ensure that any business decisions do not violate the letter or the spirit of the agreement. In such a case, the optics of a particular move could matter more to Trump than the specifics. But without the golden share, Nippon might not have been able to close the deal, Mr. Masciantonio said.

“Both parties knew the terms,” he said. “And again, more importantly, I think President Trump and U.S. Steel’s goals are pretty aligned. He certainly wants U.S. Steel and the steel industry to be successful.”

“I’ll qualify all my comments by saying: ‘as long as Donald Trump is president,’” Mr. Masciantonio added. “You never know how the next administration may handle this.”

Advertise with us

U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick, who helped Trump finalize the deal with Nippon, has publicly expressed support for the golden share, while cautioning it be used in a “nonpartisan” way that doesn’t set an overly zealous precedent for future administrations.

‘You don’t need government’

The Granite City plant in Illinois provided the first opportunity for the Trump administration to flex its new authority.

In September, shortly after U.S. Steel told workers it planned to shut down production at the factory, Mr. Lutnick called CEO Dave Burritt and told him the administration would not allow operations to cease, as first reported by the Wall Street Journal and confirmed by the Post-Gazette. Mr. Lutnick told the executive that Trump would invoke his golden share if the work did not continue.

KeyBanc analyst Phil Gibbs described the incident as a painful learning opportunity for U.S. Steel.

“They realize[d] they sold their souls to the government to get the transaction done and they can't do anything about it. That's the long and short of it, I think, for now,” Mr. Gibbs said.

Advertise with us

In some ways, Granite City was a strange place to intervene, observers said.

U.S. Steel’s production there had been vulnerable for a number of years. Mr. Gibbs described the operation as a “political football.” And the deal with Nippon only guaranteed its continued operation through 2027, according to Granite City Mayor Mike Parkinson and local union president Craig McKey.

In an interview with the Post-Gazette, Mr. Parkinson said he became so convinced of U.S. Steel’s eventual departure that he started looking for other businesses to take over the site. Mr. McKey was less convinced. He told the Post-Gazette that Granite City could fill a demand for steel from an Alabama plant that Nippon Steel sold as part of its bid to buy U.S. Steel.

But Granite City was also one of the few places where U.S. Steel was ramping down production.

Nippon plans to build a new hot strip mill in Pennsylvania’s Monongahela Valley as part of the company’s $11 billion investment by 2028, which includes planned upgrades to U.S. Steel’s blast furnaces, electric arc furnaces and mini mills. U.S. Steel also went to court this fall to defend international contracts related to its iron ore operation in Minnesota.

Advertise with us
U.S. Steel's Edgar Thomson Works steel mill looms over Braddock, PA, on Tuesday evening, Nov. 25, 2025. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

During his second term, Trump has taken a more active role in other industries beyond steel, surprising some Republican observers and rankling groups like the Cato Institute, a Washington think tank that champions limited government and free markets.

In August, Trump guided the government to purchase shares in Intel, a computer chip company that has struggled to keep pace with the rise of artificial intelligence computing.

Westinghouse Electric Co., the Cranberry-based nuclear firm, agreed last month to build nuclear power plants for the U.S. government under a deal that could eventually force them to spin out a separate public company, with the U.S. government owning up to 20% in equity.

Experts in international trade and commerce have struggled to point to a clear American precedent for that level of executive intervention.

The 2008 financial crisis prompted bailouts for banks and automakers, including General Motors and Chrysler. But those measures were temporary and designed to help companies avoid bankruptcy, said Scott Lincicome, Cato Institute’s vice president of general economics and trade.

Advertise with us

He said some of his colleagues still believe the government should have let GM go bankrupt as a more free-market way to force change.

“You don't need government” to step in, Mr. Lincicome said.

Protections for employees

But there are also larger differences between 2008 and 2025. The country is not in crisis now, and the symbolism of GM filing for bankruptcy might not be the same as U.S. Steel slowly becoming less competitive, analysts noted.

Nippon’s investment itself has sparked hope from steelworkers that their jobs are secure. But questions remain about how sustainable Nippon’s investments will prove for both the environment and employees.

“The Art of the Deal,” Mr. Lutnick wrote on X in June as the long-sought deal with Nippon was finalized.

Advertise with us

“The Golden Share held by the United States in U.S. Steel has powerful terms that directly benefit and protect America, Pennsylvania, the great steelworkers of U.S. Steel, and U.S. manufacturers that will have massively expanded access to domestically produced steel,” Mr. Lutnick stated.

He then listed the details of the provision.

Without the consent of the President or a designee, U.S. Steel cannot: move its headquarters from Pittsburgh, change the company’s name, “reduce, waive, or delay” Nippon’s planned $14 billion “near-term” investments, or transfer production or jobs outside the United States.

The company also cannot close or idle plants “before certain time frames other than normal course” which could include temporary idling for safety or upgrades. The share also includes protections for employee salaries, according to Mr. Lutnick’s post.

Todd Tucker, director of industrial policy and trade at the Roosevelt Institute, told NPR shortly after the announcement that other countries use similar golden share provisions to “ensure national ownership and control over strategically important industries.”

Advertise with us

As examples, he named Volkswagen in Germany and Heathrow Airport in the United Kingdom.

“This will be a lot like other board seats,” Mr. Tucker said.

To make that relationship more explicit, Trump’s golden share in U.S. Steel also allows him to select his own board director. On Nov. 20, Trump appointed David Shapiro, a Commerce Department chief counsel, to the U.S. Steel board.

The president also designated William Kimmitt, the Under Secretary of Commerce for International Trade, to oversee the golden share. U.S. Steel did not respond to a request for comment on the appointments.

“We appreciate President Trump’s support of the American steel industry, and we continue to abide by the provisions in the national security agreement,” the company said.