One thing that surprised Scott Buckiso when the 35-year veteran of U.S. Steel visited Nippon Steel mills in Japan was how familiar it all felt.
“How similar our facilities look,” the chief manufacturing officer at U.S. Steel marveled in a video posted to the company’s YouTube channel in February.
The novelty wasn’t in the big, hulking stuff — Nippon makes steel in blast furnaces the same way U.S. Steel does in the Mon Valley.
It was in “the capability that they have at all of these facilities,” he said. “Whether it was digital analytics or AI helping them make sure that everything they’re doing is proper.”
Both U.S. Steel and Nippon are experimenting with how to make steel differently. For example, they are looking at reducing or eliminating coal from the manufacturing process and using hydrogen for fuel instead.
But it’s best to manage expectations in the short term. The technology transfer and modernization promised as part of Nippon’s $14.9 billion acquisition of U.S. Steel won’t fundamentally change how steel is forged in the Mon Valley anytime soon.
Read More
It might get more productive, better monitored and tracked. A hot strip mill will be built that will help expand the number of products made in the Mon Valley. Nippon has pledged $2.4 billion for improvements at Mon Valley plants and signed an agreement with the U.S. government not to close any of them for a decade, at least not without approval from President Donald Trump.
Environmental groups active around U.S. Steel’s older plants are urging the company to immediately transition away from coal-based steelmaking — the kind that requires the Clairton coke ovens to keep cooking coal and the Edgar Thomson blast furnaces to burn the resultant coke in order to make molten iron and then steel.
“We're being told this is modernization, but what we see is maintenance,” said Qiyam Ansari, Western Pennsylvania organizer for the Sierra Club said during a press call last week organized by a global industry watchdog called SteelWatch.
“What is actually being invested here in Clairton and the communities that have carried this industry for over a century? A billion dollars to upgrade a hot strip mill — not to phase out coke ovens, not to eliminate the source of our chronic exposure to sulfur dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, fine particulate matter and benzene.”

While SteelWatch and others on the call argued that keeping coke ovens and blast furnaces alive is just kicking the can down the road, Nippon, which doubled the number of blast furnaces it operates when it bought U.S. Steel, believes they are here to stay, even in 25 years when the steelmaker expects to be carbon neutral across all of its global operations.
How to make steel
There are two main ways to make steel today: create it from mined iron ore or by melting recycled steel scraps into new steel products.
By and large, the make-it-from-scratch process now happens at integrated steel mills, facilities like those in the Mon Valley. They are in the minority in the U.S. but in the rest of the world, they’re the predominant steelmaking method.
The U.S. Steel coke plant in Clairton is the largest of its kind in North America. Its 10 coke batteries digest more than 18,000 tons of coal daily, cooking it until it releases organic compounds like sulfur and nitrogen and concentrating the carbon left over into coke. That coke then is taken to blast furnaces, including at nearby Edgar Thomson, where it supplies the heat to melt iron ore. The coke’s chemical properties also extract oxygen from the molten iron, further purifying the substance.
When the process is complete, liquid steel is rolled out to harden. From there, the metal goes on to be thinned, rolled, coated, or otherwise finished at downstream facilities, like at the Irvin Works in West Mifflin.
The coal, used both as a fuel and as a chemical agent to refine the iron, comes with hefty carbon emissions and air pollutants.
At Big River Steel, U.S. Steel’s complex in Arkansas, the process starts with steel that’s already been made and used before, with some virgin iron added to the mix. The metal is melted in an electric arc furnace — it’s heated with electricity — until it can be poured and hardened.
This process has up to 80% lower carbon emissions than integrated steelmaking, Jeff Becker, a sustainability consultant at U.S. Steel, explained in a recent appearance on the company’s Steel Stories video series.
These kinds of mills are also cheaper to operate. And while historically certain steel qualities could only be forged in a blast furnace, there is now a wide range of steels made in electric arc furnaces, and that technological gap is expected to keep narrowing, if not fade entirely, in the future.
It was Big River Steel that first attracted Nippon to U.S. Steel, according to public filings.

When Nippon initially bid on U.S. Steel’s assets in 2023, it was interested only in the mini-mill and its iron ore mining and pellet production facilities in Minnesota. The Japanese company bid $9.2 billion on those assets and, a few weeks later, said it would be willing to bid on the whole company, which it valued at $9.5 billion.
The initial interest in Big River seemed in line with Nippon’s strategy of reducing its carbon emissions by 2030 by closing blast furnaces and adding electric arc furnaces.
That was the first of three prongs in Nippon’s decarbonization strategy. The other two involve using increasing amounts of hydrogen in its steel making, including in blast furnaces.
Nippon estimates it could reduce the carbon emissions of blast furnaces by 50% by swapping some of the coke with hydrogen. The remaining emissions would then be captured from the smokestack and either turned into other products or sequestered underground.
Nippon has been running a pilot project at a small blast furnace in Japan at its East Nippon Works Kimitsu Area and last year announced it achieved a 33% reduction in CO2 emissions there by injecting heated hydrogen into the furnace. Next year, it plans to scale up the test to a large blast furnace.
Closer to home, Chris Pistorius, who co-directs the Center for Iron and Steelmaking Research at Carnegie Mellon University, is eagerly awaiting the arrival of a small, custom furnace that will be installed at U.S. Steel’s research facility in Munhall. His team will use it to test different configurations for making direct reduced iron with natural gas and hydrogen.
The work is funded through a Department of Energy contract and, while Mr. Pistorius hasn’t yet talked directly with Nippon about the project, he plans to bring it up when a group from Nippon visits next month, he said.
Switching from coke ovens to other iron-refining technology would certainly decrease carbon emissions, Mr. Pistorius said. And also “sulfur, nitrogen, and jobs.”
In a study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in May, Mr. Pistorius and his co-authors calculated that about 2,000 jobs would be lost at an unnamed integrated steel facility in southwestern Pennsylvania if its current technology was replaced with a direct reduced iron plant and an electric arc furnace.
Production workers — those with lower wages and specialized skills that are the least transferable to other industries — would be disproportionately impacted, the authors found.
It’s no wonder that the United Steelworkers union, which represents some 11,000 employees at U.S. Steel’s integrated mills but none at its electric arc furnaces in Arkansas, was keen to secure assurances that Nippon would not close blast furnaces after taking over.
“That emotional aspect is real. I mean, there's a little subgenre of videos of blast furnaces being demolished, and those are really difficult to watch,” Mr. Pistorius said. “You see this big structure that produced millions of tons of iron being eroded as it falls over in a cloud of dust, and that is the end.
“There is definitely a path by which the operation here can be modernized and still be a blast furnace. And that's certainly a big part of the Nippon Steel plan.”
‘Social implementation’
Nippon’s strategy to be net-zero by 2050 is fortified by Japanese laws that require emission reductions and the government funding for technologies that deliver those reductions. The company has repeatedly warned its stakeholders in Japan that it cannot decarbonize in a vacuum.
“A well-structured system must be established where the cost of CO2 reduction is recognized as a CO2 reduction value, with the financial burden shared across the entire value chain and, ultimately, society as a whole,” Nippon wrote in a climate update in March.
“The three external conditions that must be established by government policies are the low-cost and stable supply of green hydrogen and green power, which are necessary for this purpose, and the social implementation of [carbon capture, utilization, and storage].”
In the U.S., these goals seem further away.
There is no price on carbon emissions and while the Biden administration attempted to incentivize decarbonization with generous federal grants, loans, and tax credits for clean energy, hydrogen, and energy efficiency, the Trump administration is not motivated by the same cause.
The hydrogen production tax credit created by the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act, which was supposed to be a medium-term support for the hydrogen hubs envisioned by the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, is on the chopping block of the One Big Beautiful Bill before the Senate now. The hubs are also in various stages of limbo.
“The reality is that right now hydrogen isn’t available at the scale one would need to make a lot of iron. And the cost is a challenge,” Mr. Pistorius said. “Long term, this is the pathway we should use.”
Mr. Becker, U.S. Steel’s sustainability consultant, said there are likely to be a variety of combinations for how and where steel is made as companies work to drive down costs and emissions over the coming years. It will depend on the cost and availability of iron and scrap metal and electricity, he said.
“We’re on a path that’s going to take a lot of money,” he said on Steel Stories. “Estimates are that to decarbonize the steel industry, you’re talking $4-6 trillion. These projects all need a business case.
“We’re making progress,” he said. “Could this progress be quicker? Always.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.