In a brief history of sinkholes and troughs, features that form when a part of an abandoned coal mine collapses, Pittsburgh-based engineer Richard Gray offered two basic principles of such subsidence:
It can happen over deep mines and shallow mines, although the less distance between the mine void and the ground, the more likely it is to show at the surface.
It can happen years, decades, even a century after mining is done, more than once, and with stretches of quiet in between.
There’s no sure way to predict when old, abandoned voids — many of them created during a coal mining boom in the early 1900s — will announce themselves at the surface, Mr. Gray wrote in a 2020 edition of the book Surface Subsidence Engineering. Pennsylvania has the dubious distinction as the state with the largest inventory of abandoned mines and estimates say millions of homes and buildings sit on top of these relics.
What appears to have happened to Elizabeth Pollard, the 64-year-old woman whose body was recovered from a sinkhole 30 feet deep, is unusual.
But sinkholes aren’t. They’re just typically much shallower than that.
Read More
So much of Pennsylvania has been undermined, and those mines were left abandoned and destabilized. The state sells mine subsidence insurance and hosts a website where people can check if the coal under their homes has been hollowed out.
In much of southwestern Pennsylvania, the answer will likely be yes.
Coal extraction in Pennsylvania progressed from small digs with pick axes to the more industrial room and pillar method in the 1800s, where the coal seam would be carved out in some places but not in others, leaving pillars intact to support the roof of the mine.
That left as much as 60% to 70% of the coal still in the ground, Mr. Gray wrote. By the turn of the 19th Century, coal operators were looking to extract more of the commodity that was fueling a steel boom in Pittsburgh. New mines had smaller pillars and some had begun retreat mining, where the pillars were mined on the way out, allowing the roof to collapse.
More work to be done
The Marguerite Mine, where the sinkhole in Unity Township developed, was a room and pillar mine that was abandoned sometime in the 1950s. At the site of the tragedy, there was about 20 feet of overburden, the layers of rock and soil above the coal seam.
This is where sinkholes appear most, research shows – where the overburden is less than 50 feet.
And typically, they’re not very deep, said Joe Bonetti, a geologist and project manager with Cecil-based Howard Concrete Pumping Co Inc. They form as a result of a mine roof collapsing or a pillar giving way.
Typically, the depression at the surface will be less than the space in the void that closed up underground, Mr. Bonetti explained, because as solid rock breaks up into chunks, it needs more room to settle. If you scooped out balls from a watermelon half and placed them inside the hollowed out rind, they would take up more space than before the fruit was disturbed.

He’s been doing mine stabilization since the 1980s, filling abandoned mine voids with grout to prevent subsidence. Awareness of the problem has grown substantially in recent decades, he said.
The company also bids on emergency contracts with the Department of Environmental Protection whose Bureau of Abandoned Mine Reclamation has responded to 578 incidents of mine-related subsidence since 2017, DEP spokeswoman Lauren Camarda said. That includes 75 emergencies this year.
Pennsylvania has been chipping away at the abandoned mine problem and says it has rehabilitated 91,000 acres. But the state believes about twice that much still needs attention.
In April, it hosted U.S. Secretary of the Interior Deb Haaland in Bovard, a Westmoreland County town just six miles north of Unity, to showcase a $6 million project funded through the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021. The legislation gave a $11.2 billion jolt for abandoned mine reclamation efforts. Pennsylvania is set to get $3.7 billion of that money over the next 15 years.
Howard Concrete was the contractor on the Bovard job, where it would fill voids inside an abandoned mine to stabilize 100 structures. Most of it was preventative, Mr. Bonetti said, but the company had already done two emergency stabilizations in the town.
Typically, Howard Concrete works on mines that have between 20 and 100 feet of cover. Less than that, and it’s easier to just dig out the overburden and fill it from the surface. Deeper than 100 feet, and the risk of subsidence is considered much lower.
Modern mining takes place hundreds of feet below the surface.
Mr. Bonetti has done “hundreds, if not thousands” of projects, he said, but wouldn’t call himself an expert in predicting when subsidence will happen.
“No one is,” he said. “You can say it’s likely to happen. You can’t say it’s going to happen tomorrow.”
If you see a hole in your backyard, call Roger Rummel, environmental program manager for the DEP, at 814-472-1800 or email rrummel@pa.gov.
There are other tell-tale signs.
“Mine subsidence is usually pretty abrupt, not slow like soil settlement” said Doug Clark, a geotechnical engineer and principal at Civil & Environmental Consultants, a Moon-based engineering firm.
The shifts caused by mine subsidence could manifest as a crack in the foundation, doors that suddenly jam or don’t close.
There’s also has a three-dimensional quality to it, Mr. Clark said. When a mine roof collapses or a pillar pierces through the overburden, causing it to sag, the forces pulling on a structure are both lateral and vertical, “so you have a lot of twisting.”
Instead of sinking straight down into the ground, a damaged structure could appear to have been wrung out, cracked diagonally or separated at the seam.
The state’s mine subsidence insurance program has about 62,000 subscribers although many more structures are at risk. An average of 200 claims are made annually, but only a fraction are paid. Last year, only 24 were approved.
The insurance fund has paid out more than $30 million since its start.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.