Arch2, the hydrogen hub planned for the Tri-State area, has already produced some steam and sizzle, even though there’s nothing in the ground yet and won’t be for at least the next few years.

The contours of plan are still fuzzy, a fact that’s irking community activists and environmental groups that want to know what projects are being planned to make blue hydrogen in this corner of Appalachia.

Last month, the Ohio River Valley Institute, a nonprofit think tank that advocates for clean energy and economic opportunities in Appalachia, circulated a petition asking the U.S. Department of Energy to suspend its negotiations with Arch2 — the DOE selected the effort to be eligible for up to $925 million in federal funding — until project details, and a better account of how the agency is evaluating them, are made public.

Some of the projects announced so far include Fidelis New Energy’s Mountaineer Gigasystem in West Virginia, where hydrogen will power a hyperscale datacenter, and Hope Gas’s plans to blend hydrogen into its natural gas pipelines.

Advertise with us

Both Cecil-based CNX Resources and Downtown-based EQT Corp. have announced they’re working projects to turn natural gas and — in CNX’s case — coal mine methane, into aviation fuel.

But little beyond the announcements has been disclosed.

“The community that’s anxious to engage and get information about the projects are frustrated because it’s so early,” said Perry Babb, president of KeyState Energy, which is involved in two of the projects envisioned for Arch2, including the recently announced aviation fuel partnership between his firm, CNX and Pittsburgh International Airport. “Think of it like elementary school — everybody’s running around the classroom right now trying to figure out what they want to be when they grow up.”

During two public listening sessions organized by the DOE this spring, two clear themes dominated people’s concerns about Arch2.

One was the lack of transparency about project details, which Arch2 officials say will be rectified after an agreement with the DOE is signed — they hope in the next few months.

Advertise with us

The other recurring concern is more intractable. Many who spoke don’t want a blue hydrogen hub. Period.

The blue refers to hydrogen that’s made by reforming natural gas molecules, which is how most hydrogen is made in the U.S. But instead of releasing the considerable amount of carbon dioxide that process generates, a blue hydrogen facility would capture that stream of CO2 and pump it into the ground for permanent storage.

Arch2 is one of several hydrogen hubs planning to use natural gas that have received initial approval by the DOE, which holds access to $8 billion from the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021 intended to jump-start regional hydrogen economies. The legislation stipulated that two of the hubs receiving the money be located in regions with natural gas resources.

In other words, blue hydrogen was written into policy.

But the legislation also came with unprecedented requirements for communities to be informed, consulted and assured of benefits from funded projects. Some community members believe that process should have started even before blue hydrogen was etched into the infrastructure law.

Advertise with us

“It’s not community engagement when it’s a done deal,” said Leatra Harper, managing director of the FreshWater Accountability Project in West Virginia.

Ms. Harper brought up her concerns at the March 27 listening session, linking blue hydrogen to the fracking for gas that she doesn’t want to see expanded and casting doubt on whether the amount of infrastructure and energy necessary to produce hydrogen from natural gas would actually reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

What if instead of throwing this much money — $925 million is just the tip of the iceberg in terms of federal subsidies, with tax credits for hydrogen production and CO2 storage expected to eclipse that many times over — the government put all those resources into renewables and energy conservation, she asked.

Shawn Bennett, energy and resilience division manager at Battelle and a leader on the Arch2 project, said that it’s almost like having “two conversations.”

“I think maybe in some cases we’re talking past each other,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Bennett, who was assistant deputy secretary at the DOE during the Trump administration, said Arch2 formed to capitalize on the region’s competitive position, which is an abundance of shale gas.

“We’re just trying to fulfill what was essentially laid out by the DOE and be successful and provide jobs and opportunity in the region and participate in that decarbonization.”

No love for blue hydrogen

In February, the EFI Foundation, a Washington-based nonprofit that has an influential voice in how the hydrogen economy is rolled out, released its first factbook on community engagement for hydrogen hub development. It included a survey of about 5,000 self-identified members of environmental justice, tribal, labor and disadvantaged communities that showed 78% in support of hydrogen development.

The result thrilled Suzanne Baker, a stakeholder engagement specialist at DOE’s Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations, who spoke on a webinar organized by the EFI Foundation to discuss the factbook.

“We all feel like there are good vibes with hydrogen,” Ms. Baker said. “But to see this overwhelming support in numbers was like, ‘Oh, yeah, we really need to get this right and to continue to foster that trust.’”

Advertise with us

But the survey results seemed to stand in contrast to the more than 140 environmental justice groups that had signed public letters focusing on potential safety issues of hydrogen and its being used to extend the life of fossil fuels like natural gas.

So the foundation sent another survey to those groups to gauge whether their opposition was mainly about blue hydrogen. The results showed that 30% opposed all hydrogen development, and 70% were in favor of green hydrogen — that is, hydrogen made through electrolysis powered by renewable energy. Nearly none supported blue hydrogen or any other color for that matter.

One finding in particular caught the attention of Melanie White, director of strategic engagement with Allegheny Science and Technology who is leading community engagement efforts for Arch2.

Nearly half of the environmental justice groups surveyed said they believed the hydrogen hub process would increase community participation in these discussions. Ms. White found that “pretty encouraging.”

Less so, she conceded, was that most of the same respondents didn’t think that community participation would actually lead to community benefits, nor would it “allow their community to influence decision-making, or create a fair process, based on their experience engaging with H2Hubs,” EFI Foundation summarized.

Advertise with us

Ms. White is taking it one step at a time, she said.

“I think once those conversations happen, then some of the other metrics will shift as well,” she said. “Because they will start to see that they have an opportunity to potentially influence decisions that are made, and that it will be a fair process.”

Transparency

John Detwiler, a volunteer with the community group North Braddock Residents for Our Future who spoke at the first Arch2 listening session in March, boiled it down to this: “Which brings us back to transparency. Who decides what’s going to be built? And who decides who decides?”

Mr. Detwiler told the Department of Energy that the format of the listening session, where individuals say their piece but there is no response or interaction with officials, is the same playbook used by project developers who encounter local opposition but want to appear as if they are taking communities’ concerns into consideration.

The EFI Foundation surveys found members of environmental justice, labor and otherwise marginalized communities preferred that community engagement take the shape of public meetings or community advisory panels, where people in impacted areas convene regularly to discuss project developments and negotiate benefits.

Advertise with us

Arch2’s representatives said that will happen, both at the hub level and with individual projects shortly after the DOE gives the green light to proceed to the next phase.

DOE has also said it would make publicly available the contents of community benefit plans submitted by the different hubs. That would allow the public to see what metrics the federal government will use to evaluate whether the hubs are meeting their community engagement objectives — this accounts for 20% of the score that determines whether projects advance to the next phase and are eligible for the next batch of funding.

“Failure to meet the goals of this phase, including robust community engagement, will directly impact the decision to unlock additional funding to move the Hub forward,” DOE wrote in response to its listening session comments.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com