A regional effort to build out a hydrogen hub in West Virginia, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Kentucky will receive up to $925 million as part of the Biden Administration’s effort to decarbonize the U.S. economy.
The Appalachian Regional Clean Hydrogen Hub (Arch2), a West Virginia-led effort that combines the production of hydrogen from natural gas with carbon capture and storage, is one of seven regional hubs that will be funded over the coming years. The administration projects the Arch2 effort will create 18,000 construction jobs and 3,000 permanent jobs.
Another winner is the Mid-Atlantic Clean Hydrogen Hub (Mach2), which envisions development in southeastern Pennsylvania, Delaware, and New Jersey that would generate hydrogen from renewable and nuclear sources and use it for chemical manufacturing and transportation. The proposal was approved for up to $750 million under the hydrogen hub program.
President Joe Biden and Department of Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm will make the announcement in Philadelphia on Friday.
Hydrogen, a gas that produces no greenhouse gasses when burned, is seen as a promising substitute for fossil fuels in industries that are hard to decarbonize, such as cement and steel making, shipping, and chemical production.
But the little hydrogen that is produced in the U.S. today comes from natural gas and results in large carbon dioxide emissions. So far, clean hydrogen is neither broadly available nor in demand yet. Funding a series of hydrogen hubs across the U.S. would help potential hydrogen makers and takers organize into regional networks that could form the basis of a clean hydrogen economy, Department of Energy officials have said.
Read More
This is part of the Biden administration’s ambitious decarbonization goals, which involve a net zero carbon electric grid by 2035 and a net zero economy by 2050.
With billions of dollars in service of that included in two major pieces of legislation — the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act and the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act — the Department of Energy has cast a wide net to pilot and commercialize technologies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Administration officials have talked about the need to seed different soils. For hydrogen, that means encouraging green hydrogen — which is made by splitting water molecules in electrolyzers powered by renewable energy sources — as well as blue hydrogen — derived from natural gas with carbon dioxide emissions produced in the process captured and either stored underground or turned into carbon products. There are a handful of other colors on the hydrogen spectrum, but it’s the blue hydrogen that’s most relevant to the effort here.
The Arch2 coalition includes a long roster of the region’s biggest players, including gas producers EQT Corp. and CNX Resources, utilities Peoples Natural Gas and Hope Gas, Battelle, TRC, TC Energy, Air Liquide, Chemours and others.
Several projects that were included in the application have been announced publicly, such as the Adams Fork clean ammonia factory in Mingo County and the Mountaineer GigaSystem and Monarch Cloud Campus in Mason County, which would use hydrogen to power datacenters. Both would rely on natural gas-derived hydrogen with carbon capture and sequestration.
But, according to a map of Arch2 projects presented at Marcellus Shale Coalition’s Shale Insight Conference last month, of the 15 hydrogen production facilities spread across Ohio, West Virginia, and Pennsylvania, six would make hydrogen from natural gas, four from carbon-free sources, and five show a mix of feedstocks which might include biomass.
The map also shows a sprawling network of transportation and industrial users, utility customers in West Virginia that will receive fuel cells, carbon injection wells, hydrogen storage, and power generation facilities.
A Pennsylvania-led application called Decarbonization Network of Appalachia (DNA) did not receive funding. Led by Team PA, a public-private economic development organization, it lost both of its founding members over the course of the application process. Norwegian oil and gas firm Equinor withdrew in the spring, before the application was submitted. Then, Shell Chemicals pulled out of the effort last month. The only named company that remained was Mitsubishi Power Americas.
Hilary Mercer, a senior vice president at Shell’s petrochemical complex in Potter Township, said the company withdrew to “reduce overall costs and improve the viability of DNA.”
“Since DNA was first conceptualized, there has been an evolution in the project and application as we’ve continued working together with Team PA and our business partners to optimize the opportunity,” she said. “This project is pivotal in kicking off the energy transition for this region as it will unlock other opportunities for other industries including Shell Polymers Monaca.”
Details about the Team PA effort with Shell and Mitsubishi have always been scant. Shell has said publicly that it would be interested in decarbonizing the cracker plant in Beaver County, but never said specifically how it would do so.
In her statement, Ms. Mercer said that Shell “continues to evaluate the potential use of hydrogen at our site.”
The road to transition
The hub funding, while much anticipated, will not be sufficient in itself to stand up a hydrogen economy. The awards pale in comparison to what it costs to build large-scale industrial facilities and may be more signals than supports.
“When you parse out even a billion dollars a hub might get between projects, that’s not gonna move the dial,” said Perry Babb, CEO of KeyState Energy, which is developing a project in Clinton County that’s part of Arch2. The project involves drilling for shale gas, using it to make hydrogen and ammonia and converting it into transportation fuel while storing CO2 underground.
“If you’ve got a project that’s dependent upon hub funding to be successful, you need to back off,” he advised at a recent industry event.
Instead, what will make projects work, he said, are the clean hydrogen production tax credit (up to $3 per kilogram of hydrogen) and the carbon sequestration tax credit ($85 per ton of CO2 captured and stored).
Defining what makes hydrogen clean and, therefore, qualified for such credits, has been controversial. In recent months, organizations like the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis and the Ohio River Valley Institute, both of which oppose natural gas-derived hydrogen projects, have argued that such a hub will not drive down emissions and will instead prolong and expand fossil fuel use.
In a report released last month titled “Blue hydrogen: not clean, not low carbon, not a climate solution,” IEEFA authors David Schlissel and Anika Juhn argued that the government’s calculations about the benefits of natural gas-derived hydrogen rely on unrealistic assumptions.
For example, the models assume that carbon capture systems placed at smokestacks will be able to trap about 95% of CO2 emissions whereas currently operating systems operate at much lower rates.
One of the main obstacles to hydrogen deployment will be pipelines and storage. In the U.S., the appetite for building new gas pipelines is met with fierce opposition, long permit reviews and litigation, which stretches the timeline and budget for such projects.
To make natural gas-derived hydrogen work might require a double pipeline challenge — both hydrogen and carbon dioxide conduits might be needed for a hub.
“The connective issue of a hydrogen hub is going to be transport,” said Jim Curry, managing shareholder with Babst Calland, during a webinar organized by Appalachian Energy Future in March. “It’s one thing to build a hydrogen facility (and) another thing to start moving that to places where people live.”
“If we want to do an energy transition, the only way to do that is build through it,” Mr. Curry said. “And it’s gotten hard to build.”
Nevertheless, local utilities are already preparing for a hydrogen future.
Peoples Natural Gas and Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania are both testing a blend of natural gas and hydrogen to gauge the impact on their infrastructure and home appliances. Pittsburgh Regional Transit is also starting a pilot program in which it plans to test up to 10 hydrogen fuel cell buses.
As for the large, hard to decarbonize users, they’re waiting for the market to catch up with the enthusiasm.
U.S. Steel Corp., which initially considered a role in the Shell and Equinor effort, has received solicitations from companies that want to deliver hydrogen to its facilities, to secure a large player like that as a key customer for a hydrogen market. But, “there has been a bit of a misalignment between the timing of all this and the willingness of our customers to pay a premium for a greener product,” Brenda Petrilena, U.S. Steel’s director of global decarbonization and program management, said at a conference last month called Decarb Connect.
Recognizing that, the DOE announced it would spend up to $1 billion to subsidize the buildout of demand for hydrogen. It is likely to provide a subsidy that closes the gap between market rate hydrogen and the cost to produce clean hydrogen. The agency hasn’t decided to whom the payment would go, supplier or buyer, but is looking to select an independent nonprofit to establish and run the process.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com; Jonathan Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.