The Pennsylvania Attorney General’s office announced that it reached a plea deal with Texas-based pipeline company Energy Transfer, concluding a criminal case brought against the firm for its Mariner East and Revolution pipelines.
Energy Transfer pleaded “no contest” to 23 criminal charges on Friday, without admitting guilt or wrongdoing while accepting a conviction in the case.
The plea deal includes a water grievance process where qualified landowners who believe their water may have been impacted by Energy Transfer’s Mariner East pipeline construction will receive a free evaluation from an independent geologist. If it is determined that the company was indeed the cause of the water issue, Energy Transfer will have to restore or replace the landowners’ water supply.
It also includes $57,500 in fines to be paid to the Department of Environmental Protection, and $10 million that will be distributed through grants towards water improvement projects.
Attorney General Josh Shapiro, speaking at a press conference on Friday, said the plea deal secures what Pennsylvania citizens impacted by Energy Transfer’s pipeline construction wanted most — a voice and a remedy.
The settlement caps a multi-year investigation and follows more than $32 million in penalties that Energy Transfer has already been assessed by state environmental and pipeline regulators.
Read More
The attorney general first filed 48 criminal charges against Energy Transfer in October — 47 misdemeanors and 1 felony charge — alleging that the company leaked thousands of gallons of drilling fluid during underground drilling operations when building the Mariner East pipelines. Those spills showed up in people’s backyards, caused sinkholes, and polluted waterways, a grand jury convened to hear the evidence concluded. It also found that Energy Transfer kept some of this damage from environmental regulators despite requirements to report it.
The twin Mariner East pipelines now carry natural gas liquids from Ohio and Western Pennsylvania to a processing plant near Philadelphia.
In February, Mr. Shapiro added nine more charges to the case. These stemmed from an investigation into the company’s 2018 Revolution Pipeline explosion in Beaver County. There, an early-morning landslide cause the newly-activated natural gas pipeline to slip, rupture and ignite. The grand jury that looked into the blast found that Energy Transfer failed to secure the ground along its right of way, which led to landslides.
But most of the charges in the state’s case against Energy Transfer, filed in the Daughin County Court of Common Pleas, and most of the emphasis of the investigation was about water pollution, Mr. Shapiro said during the press conference.
“That is the heart of this case,” he said.
As part of the deal Energy Transfer pleaded “no contest” to 23 charges with the remaining 34 dropped, including the felony charge.
In a statement that implied Mr. Shapiro was grandstanding to benefit his gubernatorial campaign, Energy Transfer nevertheless said it was pleased to put this matter to bed.
To those who wonder why his office accepted a plea deal instead of taking the case to trial, the attorney general said: “even if we won, Energy Transfer would have walked away paying pocket change. The residents would have been screwed.”
He said the $10 million payment stipulated in this plea deal is more than six times the maximum criminal penalty that could have been assessed under state law.
“If you feel that the company got off easy — well, look no further than some of the people who work in our legislature,” he said.
Mr. Shapiro urged citizens to demand that lawmakers enact higher penalties for environmental misconduct.
Last month, the attorney general’s office sent letters to landowners within the pipeline’s right of way asking if they have had any ongoing problems with their water supplies.
Mr. Shapiro said on Friday that 61 households have already responded. He urged anyone else who believes they may have been impacted to reach out by emailing watertesting@attorneygeneral.gov or calling 570-904-2643.
The plea deal gives a two-week window, ending Aug. 19. to register complaints. According to the plea agreement, Energy Transfer will pay $442,500 to establish a fund for the water grievance program.
The $10 million payment for water projects will be distributed through grants from existing state programs. Mr. Shapiro told community groups, environmental organizations, watershed associations to be on the lookout for instructions how to apply for these grants in the coming weeks.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.