Facing new legal challenges, the Delaware River Basin Commission on Thursday approved a permanent ban on hydraulic fracturing of natural gas wells along the river.
Environmentalists hailed the fracking ban as historic. The DRBC’s vote maintains the status quo — it formally affirms a drilling moratorium imposed in 2010 by the commission, the interstate agency that manages water use in the vast Delaware watershed.
The formal ban came a month after a federal judge set an October trial date to hear a challenge to the drilling moratorium. And Pennsylvania Republican lawmakers, along with Damascus Township in Wayne County, filed a separate federal legal action alleging that the moratorium illegally usurps state legislators’ authority to govern natural resources.
Representatives of the four states that are drained by the river — Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware and New York — cast votes in favor of the ban. A federal government representative from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers abstained because he said the corps needed additional time to “coordinate” with the new Biden administration, but he said that it respects the outcome.
The DRBC’s rules prohibit high-volume hydraulic fracturing for fossil fuels within the 13,539-square-mile basin. They also reinforce policies to discourage importation of wastewater and exportation of water related to hydraulic fracturing, as well as rules governing the treatment and disposal of frack water.
The ban effectively only impacts Pennsylvania, since Delaware and New Jersey have no developable natural gas and New York, which does have gas, has banned fracking statewide. In Pennsylvania, hydraulic fracturing is conducted extensively and legally across a broad swath of the state underlain by Marcellus and Utica shale formations, which since 2009 has turned the state into the nation’s second-largest gas producer.
Patrick McDonnell, Pennsylvania’s secretary of environmental protection, said he cast the state’s vote in favor of the ban “after careful analysis and consideration of the unique geographic, geologic and hydrologic characteristics” of the river basin.
The commission conducted six public hearings three years ago on the proposed regulations, but it delayed a formal vote until Thursday. It had received more than 8,900 comments on the regulations, and environmental activists had organized fierce opposition to any fossil fuel exploration in the basin.
“We have been calling for a decision for years now and been making the point that really the time is now,” said Maya van Rossum, the head of the Delaware Riverkeeper Network, an advocacy group that has intervened in the lawsuits. She said there was “no reason to slow down protection” because of the legal challenges.
The American Petroleum Institute Pennsylvania denounced “overreach” and said the decision “ignores a robust regulatory system and strict industry standards that ensure the environment, public health and local communities are protected.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.