The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection has granted a permit for an oil and gas wastewater disposal well in Plum, but cratering oil prices and widespread economic disruption have made the controversial project uncertain.
Delmont-based Penneco Environmental Solutions received approval from federal regulators in 2018 to operate the disposal well. Pennsylvania regulations required DEP to conduct a second review.
The Sedat #3A well would be the first disposal well in Allegheny County and one of about a dozen permitted facilities in the state.
Penneco Chief Operating Officer Ben Wallace said the company has no clear timeline for developing the facility.
“Candidly, with the whole COVID shutdown and the collapse of oil prices yesterday and Appalachian production being questionable, we’re still trying to figure out what we do now that we finally got a permit,” he said on Tuesday.
“All bets are off today, I can tell you that.”
The benchmark price for U.S. crude oil fell to an unprecedented low of negative $37 a barrel on Monday, spreading shocks to other oil markets.
The posted price for a barrel of Pennsylvania Grade Crude Oil was $0.20 on Monday, with lighter liquid hydrocarbon products from Marcellus and Utica wells priced between negative $38 and negative $58 a barrel.
“We started this process four years ago. The oil and gas landscape has changed quite a bit in the last four years,” Mr. Wallace said.
DEP issued the permit on April 15 for the company to change the well’s use from a natural gas production well to a disposal well. The permit expires in a year “unless drilling is commenced,” although it is unclear how that date applies to a well that has already been drilled.
The federal and state permits allow the company to inject 54,000 barrels of oil and gas waste fluids per month at the facility off Old Leechburg Road. Wastewater from Marcellus and Utica shale wells would be deposited in the 1,900-foot-deep Murrysville sandstone.
In response to residents’ concerns, Pa. DEP said distance, confining rock layers underground, and the well’s cemented steel casings should keep injected fluids from reaching fresh groundwater or a shallower abandoned mine.
Penneco will be required to monitor for signs of subtle earthquakes associated with the well, although DEP said the well’s target depth and an absence of known faults in the area suggest earthquakes would be unlikely.
The company will also be required to turn an existing production well on the site into a monitoring well to ensure fluids do not rise within 100 feet of the deepest groundwater table.
Plum Mayor Harry Schlegel said borough leaders will discuss their options for challenging the permit when they can meet again in person, but they have been advised that a legal fight would be expensive and unlikely to succeed.
The borough’s residents have a variety of opinions on shale gas drilling, he said. “However, in one unified voice, we are against turning Plum into a sewer for them to store toxic waste. No one — no one has said they are for this.”
He said he wants local police to inspect trucks if and when they begin hauling fluids to the site.
He also said zoning changes that came too late to block the Sedat well will prohibit more disposal wells from being developed in the borough.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.