It takes a lot of energy to make a marijuana plant feel at home in a once abandoned warehouse.
Replicating the sun, warmth and moisture of a farm indoors requires light, air conditioning, ventilation and dehumidification — energy-intensive equipment that adds up to a stunning statistic: producing a pound of cannabis takes more than 80 times as much electricity as making a pound of aluminum in a smelter.
Grass, in other words, is not always green.
In Pennsylvania — where marijuana became legal for medicinal use in 2016 and the last batch of grower licenses was granted this July — some growers are trying to cut down their power demand before they draw their first kilowatt hour.
Maitri Genetics, which has a permit to grow medical marijuana in a 50,000-square-foot former warehouse in O’Hara, plans to use light-emitting diode, or LED, fixtures and a central chiller to manage the temperature in its grow rooms once it opens early next year.
Combined, the building’s high-efficiency lighting and mechanical equipment is expected to reduce Maitri’s energy use by 36 percent compared to a conventional indoor marijuana growing operation.
Corinne Ogrodnik, Maitri’s CEO, has a background in environmental policy and said sustainability is a central philosophy for the company.
It also is, she said, “good for business.”
“As the industry grows, margins are going to decrease. The operating costs — with energy consumption, lighting, water usage — can be significant. In the long run, our return on investment is going to pay for itself.”
18 pints of beer
Pennsylvania’s medical marijuana regulations put no requirements on growers to limit their energy use, unlike states like Massachusetts which this year put a demanding cap on the amount of lighting watts growers can have per square foot of growing space.
Instead, prospective Pennsylvania growers tended to tout their sustainability measures in the “community impact” sections of their permit applications.
Judith Cassel, an attorney in the cannabis law practice at Harrisburg-based firm Hawke McKeon & Sniscak, said almost every grower she has worked with in Pennsylvania addressed energy efficiency in its license application. It was “a selling point to Pennsylvania reviewers,” Ms. Cassel said, but it wasn’t a mandate.
“They are trying to minimize their footprint and reduce their energy consumption.” Still, she said, “This is an enormous amount of electricity.”
Twelve grower facilities are operational in Pennsylvania so far, and 13 that received permits in the second phase of the Department of Health’s rollout are still in the process of setting up their operations, agency spokesman Nate Wardle said.
While the department reviews and ensures growers are following the plans they submitted to the state, “We do not physically track their energy consumption,” he said.
As intense as they are, indoor marijuana growers’ energy demands appear not to be as extreme as early estimates suggested.
An October report released by New Frontier Data, a cannabis-focused data firm, used self-reported electricity usage from 81 cannabis cultivators in nine states to calculate that legal indoor growers in the U.S. use 1,270 kilowatt hours of electricity to produce a kilogram of cannabis.
That rate likely is better than average because the data comes from especially energy-aware growers.
But it is a promising update to a landmark 2012 study by researcher Evan Mills, which raised alarms about the industry’s energy appetite but had access to fewer real-world operations.
Mr. Mills estimated the average energy intensity of both legal and illegal cannabis operations was nearly five times as high — or 6,074 kilowatt hours per kilogram.
Put another way, the Mills study found that the “energy used to produce one marijuana cigarette also would produce 18 pints of beer.” The New Frontier Data study suggests it is closer to two bottles of beer.
In a rush, short on cash
Time and financial pressure contribute to indoor marijuana cultivators’ typically inefficient lighting and temperature systems.
With each new state that legalizes medical or recreational marijuana, a rush to a new buildout begins. The need to open fast often eclipses concerns about long-term energy efficiency.
“Thoughtful design takes more time,” said Nick Collins, an associate director at Massachusetts-based Energy & Resource Solutions, an energy engineering and consulting firm.
Mr. Collins has spent the last two years analyzing energy use at indoor cannabis growing facilities.
He said a common setup goes like this: growers install high-intensity discharge lights — the well-known industry standards that consume a lot of energy and give off a lot of heat — and then keep adding on the kinds of air conditioning units and dehumidifiers picked up at big box hardware stores.
“It’s plain to see why cannabis growers are moving in that direction,” he said. “It’s what they’re used to, it gets the job done, it’s the cheapest way to go, and they can’t get lending to move to more efficient options.”
The upfront cost of energy-efficient equipment is significantly higher, even though energy savings will more than make up the difference over time.
The standard 1,000-watt high-pressure sodium lighting fixture that nearly all growers use for marijuana plants’ flowering stage costs about $400, Mr. Collins said. An equivalent LED fixture is around $1,200.
Because marijuana is still illegal under federal law, growers can’t just go to a federally regulated bank and apply for a business loan.
They are more likely to get financing from private investors, who are generally looking for high yields and a quick payback, although concerns about energy and water demands seem to have caught investors’ attention in the last year, he said.
Mr. Collins said even thoughtful energy designs can be hampered by a lack of knowledge about how the plants themselves affect the conditions — how much moisture they give off when the lights are on, for example.
The marijuana growing community is also still broadly skeptical of efficient LED lighting technology, he said.
“Can you grow with LED? Absolutely. Can you grow impressive plants? Absolutely. Are they ‘as good’? Well, that becomes pretty subjective,” he said. “Until we can find a way to make more objective comparisons, it is very difficult to convince a grower to switch.”
Flowers in a bunker
In Pennsylvania, where marijuana growing licenses were issued in two phases and the total number of licenses is capped at 25, the rush is not necessarily to be first to market. Instead, growers are under pressure to meet a state deadline to be open six months after they get their license.
Pennsylvania’s climate and the medical marijuana law’s security requirements also contribute to growers’ energy use.
By far, the most energy-efficient way to grow cannabis is outdoors — it takes an indoor grower more than 18 times as much electricity to produce a gram of cannabis as an outdoor grower, according to New Frontier Data — but that is something Pennsylvania’s winters and laws make impossible.
In the commonwealth, medical marijuana must be grown “in an indoor, enclosed, secure facility.”
That would appear to rule out the second most efficient growing environment — greenhouses. Ms. Cassel said some Pennsylvania growers have installed greenhouse-like roofs around secure walls to cut down on the amount of artificial lighting they have to install.
Pennsylvania growers can also take advantage of incentives that utilities offer in order to comply with Act 129, the state’s energy efficiency law, she said. They may be eligible for funding for equipment or projects that reduce energy demand.
So far, it seems few have done so.
PPL Electric Utilities, which has the highest number of permitted growers in its service territory, has no record of any of medical marijuana growing facilities taking advantage of its Act 129 energy-efficiency programs, spokesman Joe Nixon said.
On the other hand, he said, PPL has not had to build any grid reinforcements in order to meet the growers’ power needs.
State utility regulators are interested in learning more about the industry’s energy use, but have not yet formally addressed it with new rules.
Ms. Cassel said her law firm recently gave a presentation on the energy demands of the marijuana industry to the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission at the commission’s invitation.
The grid will stand
New Frontier Data forecasts that marijuana production in Pennsylvania will consume 17,000 megawatt hours of electricity in 2018 and rise to 143,000 megawatt hours in 2022.
That would put Pennsylvania seventh in energy consumption among 31 states with legal marijuana markets that year.
“It is not going to bring the grid crashing down,” Mr. Collins said. But he thinks the opportunity for improvement is clear and urgent.
“Should we just sit back and let this high-energy-intensity industry come to be with a very low bar in terms of performance?” he said. “Or should we be trying to influence this nascent industry and push it toward a more energy-efficient start?”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.