Paul Rogers is an oddball in the oil and gas industry.

He bikes to work from his home in Squirrel Hill to the offices of Catalyst Energy Inc. in the SouthSide Works.

When people ask him about peak oil and whether they should buy a gas-powered car, he tells them he drives a hybrid. (He owns two.)

“It re­minds me of that lit­tle bumper sticker: ‘Cool Prius, nobody has ever said,’” chuckled David Maniet, an investor in Catalyst and the first adviser to sell the company’s drilling programs more than a decade ago. The sticker on Mr. Maniet’s truck says it’s “powered by dead dinosaurs.”

Advertise with us

Another thing that sets Mr. Rogers apart is that he doesn’t much care for natural gas.

As Marcellus Shale development caught the imagination of the world’s largest companies and financiers — sending the old-time shallow drillers on a goose chase to rebrand and compete in the shale game — Pittsburgh-based Catalyst Energy has kept its distance. It remained focused on oil, which the company coaxes out of conventional wells in northwestern Pennsylvania.

Mr. Rogers said he likes the smell of it — that you can see it and touch it.

“It’s just such a rich odor that you get from a tank of oil,” he said.

Even as CEO, he tries to spend at least one day a week in the fields of northwestern Pennsylvania, smelling his fortune.

Advertise with us

Elsewhere in the country, shale deposits have also upended the oil industry — ushering in a jarring price collapse beginning in mid-2014.

Catalyst, which Mr. Rogers founded in 1992, took a two-year hiatus from drilling new wells to regroup and come up with a new strategy. Earlier this year, the company announced it’s headed to drill in Kentucky.

Even there, as anywhere, what makes a drilling program work is predicting the right amount of oil in the ground and getting lucky with the sales price. So, why would anyone want to invest in a risky proposition that could crash and burn on a price swing?

“It’s really the last standing tax shelter,” Mr. Rogers explained.

“You bet it is. And it’s a good one,” Mr. Maniet agreed.

Advertise with us

The last remaining tax shelter

The U.S. government has been trying to incentivize domestic oil and gas drilling for many decades through tax advantages for companies that do the work and for investors who fund it.

The generosity of those tax breaks has waffled over time, rising in times of high gas prices and tapering on the downswings. Politicians and academics talk about getting rid of the intangible drilling costs deduction — which allows the vast majority of expenses incurred in drilling a well to be deducted from an investor’s taxable income the same year as the money is spent — but none follow through.

That tax break remains an attractive way for investors who have an influx of income in a particular year to shelter it from taxes.

If a drilling program results in losses, those too can be deducted from other income, for example, an investor’s salary or capital gains liability.

Advertise with us

Investors do it for the tax savings as well as the potential dividends that come from the sale of the oil in the years after it’s drilled.

The strategy comes down to this, Mr. Maniet said: “You can give your money to the government and get a zero percent return for sure. Or you can put your money in oil and gas and hopefully get a nice return.

“Potential [return],” he stressed. “They don’t all work out.”

Every one of the companies whose drilling programs he’s sold to investors has had wins and losses over the years.

An investment he made for his mother-in-law supported her for a decade in a nursing home at $70,000 a year, Mr. Maniet said.

Advertise with us

“Then I’ve had clients where the total return including tax breaks was less than 15 percent, which I would qualify as horrible. I’ve had some programs where they’re never gonna see all their money back.”

Mr. Maniet said he would love to sell investors on Catalyst’s newest Kentucky venture but isn’t sure he can at this time.

“We are very cautious, and with them moving down to the South, we have to look at a track record of their performance there,” said Mr. Maniet, who is the founder and principal of Maniet Financial Services Network in the South Hills.

The family oil business

Catalyst Energy is a family business, and not just because Mr. Rogers’ sister Janet O’Malley is the company’s corporate secretary or because their brother Bill Rogers was president until his death in 2010.

Advertise with us

There are people at Catalyst who have worked there for decades, through several industry downturns, and who weren’t lured away by the big shale companies that came into town a decade ago.

The company has drilled more than 1,500 wells since its founding in 1992 — all of them shallow, vertical bores in Upper Devonian sandstones.

It started with money from local investors, friends, family, the machine shop owner down the street, the landowner-turned-investor. The first program was just under $1 million and its 31 investors received dividends for years.

Then came the 2000s, when Catalyst engaged broker-dealers across the country to pitch its prospects. At one point, it had as many as 350 investors during a single round.

By 2014, it was oil’s turn to plummet. The fuel being sucked from newly tapped shale formations in Texas and North Dakota had become a victim of its own success, pulling conventional oil drillers like Catalyst down with it.

Advertise with us

Catalyst has been through cycles before. “I think us, like everybody that we knew, thought it was going to rebound,” Mr. Rogers said.

But in early 2015 the company did something it had never done before. It mothballed all of its wells.

Mr. Rogers said the team calculated that it wouldn’t make sense to turn production back on until oil prices reached $51 a barrel again. That turned out to be in June 2016.

The last drilling program that Catalyst launched — its 46th — was in 2016. It involved just a handful of wells, an ink dot compared with the usual 100 or so in prior years.

Moving to Kentucky

Advertise with us

The 2014 price drop was not like the others, Mr. Rogers realized. It was a game changer for the company, which last year decided it needed to find another area to drill. Its staff of more than 90 trickled down into the mid-20s. More than half of its Pennsylvania wells have now been sold.

After a national search for new places to work, Catalyst settled on the Berea sandstone in eastern Kentucky.

The wells it plans to drill will be horizontal, not vertical. They will cost about $1.2 million each, 10 times more than its Pennsylvania wells. But the expectation is that they’ll produce much more oil too and over a longer horizon.

When it came time to recruit investors, the company decided to go back to its roots in Pennsylvania, and especially in the Steel City.

“Some of our favorite investors have been the guys that have the little manufacturing companies,” Ms. O’Malley said. These are owners, operators, decision makers — Catalysts’ small business peers who see Mr. Rogers and the Catalyst team across the table as a reflection of their own pursuits.

Advertise with us

“This isn’t a bunch of guys from New York raising capital,” she said. “They are engineers. They strap their boots on and get on the rigs.”

Earlier this year, that familiar touch brought Mr. Rogers to the Bradford Regional Airport one day in the spring to pitch the 16-well Kentucky project to John Satterwhite.

Mr. Satterwhite is the publisher of the Bradford Era newspaper. “I’m not in the oil business, but I am,” he said.

Years ago, he leased some of his property to Catalyst for one of its drilling programs and ended up investing a few years later.

“They drilled it and did well with it,” he recalled. “When they came up and asked if I’d be interested in investing, I said, ‘Yeah, I’ll do it.’”

Advertise with us

He thought it would get his money back, which it did, in the first five years. Mr. Satterwhite continued leasing to Catalyst but never invested again.

“It was a question of availability of money,” he explained.

He put in about $25,000 or so, about 15 years ago — both data points too long ago to remember, Mr. Satterwhite said. But he wasn’t at all surprised when Mr. Rogers flew to pitch him the new venture. They’d established a relationship.

They sat at the airport for a few hours, talking details, asking questions, catching up.

Mr. Rogers didn’t ask for an answer that day — “he’s never been a hard sell on anything” — and Mr. Satterwhite still hasn’t given him one.

Advertise with us

Break from the past

Catalyst is hoping to raise $20 million for its Kentucky project. Much about the program will be a break from the past: a new state, a new type of well, new economics.

The current price of oil at the West Texas Intermediate trading hub is around $63.

Five years ago, Mr. Rogers said the company “does all right when oil is above $85.”

Back then, he was also stressed out about the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection’s push to update oil and gas regulations for shale gas development. Conventional operators mounted a high-fevered push to exempt their activities from the new scrutiny that accompanied the massive horizontal shale wells.

Advertise with us

“We are on the verge of getting out of the state due to the costs imposed in the past along with the costs to be imposed by these regulations,” general manager Doug Jones wrote in comments to the DEP in 2014.

Last month, Mr. Rogers downplayed the regulatory story, saying instead that Kentucky and Pennsylvania have very similar rules and enforcement regimes.

“Regulations really didn’t drive our decision to drill in Kentucky this year,” Mr. Rogers said.

“The reasons that I got into the business are still here,” he said. “And although there’s some frustrations, there’s still plenty of oil to find.”

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.