Rail inspectors twice failed to identify the problem that later caused a rail break and the fiery derailment of 27 crude oil tanker cars in West Virginia in February, federal regulators said on Friday.

The defect that eventually resulted in the derailment — a vertical crack in the rail — was missed by rail carrier CSX Corp. and Sperry Rail Service, a contractor that provides ultrasonic track inspections, according to an investigation into the accident by the Federal Railroad Administration.

Investigators reviewed Sperry’s test data logs and found evidence of the rail defect at the point of derailment in two inspections in December 2014 and January 2015. The inspection in January showed “similar but more significant rail flaw indication at the same location,” the report said.

The Sperry operator neglected to take a second look at the rail or examine it with a handheld ultrasonic tool, the protocol when encountering a possible defect, the report said.

Advertise with us

FRA acting Administrator Sarah Feinberg discussed the accident Friday at a news conference at BridgeValley Community and Technical College in Montgomery, W.Va., a town near the derailment site that served as makeshift headquarters for federal officials after the accident. Montgomery’s water treatment intakes were temporarily closed following the incident on fears oil had leaked into the Kanawha River.

Ms. Feinberg urged rail carriers to work with Sperry to provide better training for rail inspectors and recommended CSX draw up a plan to replace track with similar flaws on hazardous train routes.

“All railroads, not just CSX, must be more diligent when inspecting for internal rail flaws or when contracting out inspection work,” Ms. Feinberg said.

At about 1:15 p.m. on Feb. 16, an eastbound train with 107 fully loaded tank cars of crude oil jumped the tracks about 30 miles southeast of Charleston, destroying one home and one garage. Within 10 minutes, law enforcement and first responders ordered a four-day evacuation of 1,100 residents living within a half-mile radius of the explosion and shut down West Virginia State Route 61.

CSX estimated about 378,000 gallons of crude spilled, much of it burned off or absorbed into the ground. One person suffered smoke inhalation, and families displaced by the accident fled to a nearby hotel as crews tried to contain the damage.

Advertise with us

CSX has agreed to require inspectors to review previous inspection data alongside real-time data to better identify conditions and flaws that have changed or worsened between inspections.

Friday’s findings highlight the inherent difficulty for inspectors to identify rail flaws that gradually develop internally.

Track defects are the leading cause of derailments, a Post-Gazette analysis found in May. Those often include largely visible deformities like an uneven foundation to a chipped rail to a broken cross-tie.

But seemingly smooth rail can suddenly break open from internal flaws that require ultrasonic sensors.

CSX has said it inspects its most heavily trafficked rail by ultrasound monthly, complementing the minimum twice-a-week visual inspections required by the Federal Railroad Administration. Connecticut-based Sperry is one of the largest providers of such inspection services to rail carriers, primarily through its inspection box trucks that inch along the tracks.

Advertise with us

Typically, one Sperry inspector drives the truck while another sits in the back and watches the data continuously appear on a screen, a complicated mosaic of color-coded dots.

The Sperry inspector who checked this rail told federal investigators that he had interpreted the data seen before the rail break as “rough rail surface conditions,” not a genuine structural flaw. But the report noted the inspector had never received enhanced training in his 15 years working on CSX’s rails.

Of the railroad administration’s 48 technical classifications of track defects, the crack — called a vertical split head — is one of the most frequently cited causes of track-related derailments.

In 2014, it caused 19 derailments across 13 states totaling $4 million in damage, according to federal accident data.

Similar defects have caused a handful of minor derailments in Western Pennsylvania in recent years, including a 2012 accident at the Edgar Thomson Steel Works in Braddock that damaged $79,000 worth of track and equipment, the data show.

Advertise with us

CSX said in a statement on Friday that it continues to experiment with better methods of testing, including continuous rail-testing that transmits Sperry data for overnight analysis as a way to identify potential defects for hand-testing within 72 hours. Continuous testing would allow the test car to cover more rail in a given time period, increasing the frequency of internal inspections.

“CSX currently has the lowest rate of mainline derailments caused by track defects in the industry, and early results suggest that there is potential to reduce that rate further through these techniques,” the company said.

Heath Vezza, vice chairman of the workers union representing company-employed track inspectors, said while Sperry cars are critical to detecting flaws, rail companies should allow union inspectors to run them.

“I would certainly prefer a [Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way] railroad employee to read and handle those results over a contracted employee every time,” Mr. Vezza said in an email. “These are the men and women that identify and access track integrity issues day in and day out.”