Saturday, May 31, 2025, 12:36PM |  58°
MENU
Advertisement
A plume of exhaust extends from the Mitchell Power Station, a coal-fired power plant in New Eagle, in September 2013. FirstEnergy Corp. closed the plant a month later, citing pressure from low natural gas prices and environmental regulations.
1
MORE

Study finds clean energy would create jobs, but are they the right ones?

Jeff Swensen/Getty Images

Study finds clean energy would create jobs, but are they the right ones?

A coalition of environmentalist groups and trade unions expressed optimism Wednesday that even a coal-dependent region like Pittsburgh could significantly grow jobs while transitioning away from fossil fuels and toward investments in renewable energy and energy efficiency.

But the report highlighted a mismatch between when those jobs will be created and for how long they will last.

Jobs created by the renewable sector will more likely be more temporary, more nonunion and lower paying than those currently in the fossil fuel industry, said Mick Power, membership and campaign coordinator for the U.S. Climate Action Network and author of the report.

Advertisement

“The challenge lies not in the number of jobs created and lost,” Mr. Power said. “The big challenge for policymakers lies instead in the transition between different types of jobs, at different times in the future.”

From left, former Hatfield's Ferry Power Station employees Andy Sinclair, Butch DiBease, and Derek Santini in front of the now-closed station in Masontown.
Daniel Moore
Will shale boom, pending regulations leave coal industry jobs behind?

The 94-page report, discussed with reporters at the Center for Coalfield Justice offices in Washington, Pa., examined four possible scenarios for coal’s near future and the corresponding employment possibilities across 12 counties surrounding Pittsburgh.

Two different scenarios look at assumptions about market conditions, one of which has coal prices dropping more rapidly. A third includes an analysis of how plants would be affected by the Environmental Protection Agency’s carbon regulations finalized in the Clean Power Plan in August. A fourth assumes the “worst-case scenario,” with plants shuttering due to the most oppressive market forces combining with stringent environmental policy.

Depending on the scenario, Mr. Power found, the economy would gain anywhere from 20,713 to 80,279 so-called job years — a measure of jobs multiplied by the number of years that those jobs span — by 2030.

Advertisement

The meeting Wednesday took a conciliatory tone toward coal mining communities in Greene and Washington counties. Mr. Power, who is a native of western Australia where he organized rallies against the coal industry, said he witnessed economic devastation when coal-fired power plants shut down.

The report, which Mr. Power produced from several months of market and policy research during a fellowship at Harvard’s Kennedy School, was delivered to the BlueGreen Alliance, a group advocating for both blue-collar workers and environmental issues.

“We’re taking a compassionate approach,” said Khari Mosley, BlueGreen Alliance regional program manager. “We’re not doing end-zone dances when a power plant shuts down. Even though we want a clean air environment, we’re also keeping in mind how are we going to do this and not leave communities to figure it out on their own.”

The report found job gains would be concentrated during the first five years. Construction and manufacturing see the biggest job gains as new wind and solar plants come online.

The report projects the loss of jobs in the mining and utilities sector would be far outweighed by growth in the renewable sector.

But the transitioning of laid-off miners and power plant workers into those emerging jobs is a serious question, Mr. Mosley said.

The report explained that workers laid off from power plants or mines need clarification on what kind of skills and training is needed and available to them.

A safety net must exist to protect workers’ benefits and pensions and the tax base of particular municipalities in the short-term.

Mr. Power stressed the conclusions are broad findings and dependent on the actions of policymakers. A section of the report recommends policy options, with the most favorable being that a state-based plan to comply with the Clean Power Plan include a worker transition package.

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.

First Published: October 1, 2015, 4:00 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
President Donald Trump arrives to speak at U.S. Steel Mon Valley Works-Irvin Plant, Friday, May 30, 2025, in West Mifflin, Pa.
1
news
Trump announces new tariffs, bonuses and no layoffs in touting U.S. Steel-Nippon deal
The Pirates' Henry Davis reacts to striking out in the eighth inning Friday against the Padres in San Diego.
2
sports
'We gotta go out and earn it': Frustrating loss due to missed call serves as unifying moment for Pirates
Mother-daughter duo Deborah and Victoria Sfamenos graduated from the Community College of Allegheny County in May with degrees in nursing.
3
news
McCandless mother-daughter duo ready to enter nursing field together after CCAC graduation
Rookie running back Kaleb Johnson (20) runs a drill at Steelers Minicamp at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex on the South Side on Wednesday May 28, 2025.
4
sports
Jason Mackey: Why Steelers running backs could legitimately become a 'great show' in 2025
Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker T.J. Watt (90) talks with linebackers coach Aaron Curry as they walk off the field during halftime of an NFL football game against the Philadelphia Eagles, Sunday, Dec. 15, 2024, in Philadelphia. The Eagles defeated the Steelers 27-13.
5
sports
Paul Zeise: Giving T.J. Watt a historic big-money deal would be bad business for the Steelers
A plume of exhaust extends from the Mitchell Power Station, a coal-fired power plant in New Eagle, in September 2013. FirstEnergy Corp. closed the plant a month later, citing pressure from low natural gas prices and environmental regulations.  (Jeff Swensen/Getty Images)
Jeff Swensen/Getty Images
Advertisement
LATEST business
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story