Coffee helps keep the lights on at The Soft Spot — but the real reason to drop by is community.
At least that's the vision behind the new women-owned coffee shop in Garfield, founded by partners Samm and Aerin Adams-Fuchs.
The coffeehouse, which opened in April, bills itself as a Sapphic-centered business — a term derived from the ancient Greek poet Sappho to describe women who love women — with a goal of creating a safe space for the queer community.
Everyone is welcome, Samm said. "Just don't suck. Love people the way you want to be loved."
Up front, a library is stocked by community members, alongside queer and disability books for sale.
The walls are lined with work from local artists, and shelves stocked with jewelry, art and trinkets from vendors rotating every two months.
In the back of the coffee shop, is a nook with a TV, board games, crafting supplies and a fish tank where you can, as Aerin puts it, "let your brain float for a minute" between orders.
The Soft Spot is also an intentionally sober space. Alongside coffee and tea, the menu includes nonalcoholic beer and spritzers from the Open Road next door, an attempt to re-create the social atmosphere of a bar without the alcohol.
Pittsburgh has plenty of queer-friendly bars. Samm and Aerin wanted to build something different — a quiet, comfy space for people to gather.

Another library at one end of the shop is stocked with children's books. On the opposite side of the shop is a corner with kids' toys and crafts.
For inspiration, Samm cites former popular hangouts like the Beehive on the South Side and the Quiet Storm, which once stood just across the street on Penn Avene. Both coffee houses had been cornerstones of the city's eclectic arts scene before closing in the 2010s.
"I wanted to see another community hub come back here," she said.
Fast-tracking the plan
Samm and Aerin had talked about starting this sort of cafe in retirement, once their two children (ages 5 and 12) were grown up.
Then, Aerin was unexpectedly laid off from Meta last April.
As she searched for a new job, she realized that wherever she landed next, she would have to start from scratch to rebuild the community she'd spent years cultivating at the tech giant.
In hindsight, the couple don't regret the timing.
"There was no way we were going to be able to do this when we were 60 like we had planned," Aerin said. "It's so hard."
The first floor of the building on 5407 Penn Ave. had been vacant and gutted down to a dirt floor, with just one electrical outlet and no interior walls. Rather than hire a contractor to renovate the space, Samm and Aerin took on most of the work themselves — laying the floors, wiring the walls, building the coffee bar, and hauling in a salvaged sink from a reuse shop. The furniture and glassware were found in local thrift stores or donated.
Early on, Aerin had searched online for what it might cost to open a coffee shop and found estimates ranging from $150,000 to $200,000. She and Samm set out to do it for half that and ended up spending around $130,000.
Aerin used her house as collateral to secure a loan from the Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority. To cover the rest, Samm sold her own home after she and Aerin married last fall.
All told, it took the couple almost a year to get everything in order and build out the space. After a soft launch in February, Samm and Aerin organized a grand opening in March.
Like all small businesses — coffee shops and restaurants especially — The Soft Spot runs on thin margins.
And yet, walk in on any given evening and you’d find the place full of people. Since opening, The Soft Spot has hosted an event almost every day, many of them free.
Last month, Samm and Aerin threw a Faerie party on the summer solstice, filling the shop with flowers left over from a wedding the night before. They hosted a meetup for queer late bloomers. They held a sold-out “Bob's Burgers”-themed burlesque and drag show produced by local queer troupe the NeuroSpice Girls.
Last week’s schedule included a board game night, poetry reading and zine-making workshop.
Among the groups that have used the space is a support group for parents of queer children — the kind of quiet, careful gathering Samm and Aerin had in mind when they built this place. Members of the group asked specifically to hold their meetings at The Soft Spot, Samm said, worried that elsewhere, someone might overhear and judge them.
"Everything is safe here," Samm said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.