Just as another proxy war appeared inevitable, activist hedge fund Barington Capital has called off its campaign against Matthews International Corp., bringing a turbulent boardroom saga to an abrupt close.

The truce ends another brewing showdown over the North Shore-based company’s board, with Barington agreeing to withdraw its director nominations for Matthews’ 2026 annual meeting, scheduled for Feb. 19. Barington also agreed to cast its votes in support of whatever Matthews’ board recommends over the next three annual meetings.

Matthews, in turn, will pay a one-time lump sum of $750,000 to cover certain expenses incurred by Barington, effectively closing the book on a conflict that had pushed Matthews, a memorialization products company, to sell major assets and reshape the company’s strategy and portfolio.

The retreat follows one of the most bruising proxy wars in recent Pittsburgh corporate history.

Advertise with us

Around this time last year, Barington launched an all-out assault on Matthews’ leadership, seeking to unseat three board members and oust longtime President and CEO Joseph C. Bartolacci.

Matthews employs more than 11,000 people worldwide, including 850 workers in southwestern Pennsylvania. The activist fund, which owns 2% of the outstanding shares of Matthews (which has a market capitalization of $805 million), accused management of overseeing years of chronic underperformance.

Barington argued that Matthews’ stock had badly lagged its peers and the broader market under Mr. Bartolacci’s tenure and said the company had failed for nearly two decades to simplify its portfolio, conduct a strategic review and meaningfully reduce costs and debt.

Matthews, for its part, didn’t pull any punches, either. The company blasted Barington’s nominees as unqualified people who lacked any real understanding of Matthews’ complex global operations and warned shareholders they would bring no relevant skills and have a track record of poor oversight.

When the showdown finally came to a vote in February 2025, Matthews prevailed, with a majority of shareholders backing the company’s slate and blocking the activist challenge.

Advertise with us

The fight played out against the backdrop of a company that had grown far from its roots in manufacturing caskets and memorialization products for the funeral industry and had been quietly transforming into a technology-driven industrial player, placing big bets on the future of manufacturing, logistics and energy storage.

But it was a strategy that Barington said left the company bloated, unfocused and burdened with debt.

Pressure from Barington ultimately helped force change.

Over the past year, Matthews sold two major noncore businesses to streamline its operations, strengthen its balance sheet and refocus on its bread-and-butter funeral and memorialization products segment and its industrial technologies business.

“Matthews has taken steps over the past 12 months to simplify our business mix, strengthen our balance sheet, and enhance our board composition and corporate governance,” Mr. Bartolacci said in a statement.

Advertise with us

“Our extensive multi-year engagement with Barington has yielded valuable insights and helped us refine these ongoing strategic initiatives,” he said. “Looking ahead, we remain focused on continuing to advance our strategic review and position Matthews for long-term shareholder creation.”

Matthews sold its warehouse automation business in December for $232.1 million. In May, it finalized the sale of its SGK Brand Solutions Division for $350 million.

Both transactions were expected to generate significant cash, much of it earmarked for debt reduction.

James A. Mitarotonda, chairman, president and CEO of Barington said, “We appreciate the dialogue that we have had with the Matthews board and are pleased to have reached an agreement.

“We believe that Matthews’ continuing strategic review, value creation plan and corporate governance changes are critical in achieving greater near- and long-term value for all shareholders,” he said.