One team plays in a jewel among Major League Baseball parks.
The other has a tiny stadium — but also a feisty PR team, one that isn’t afraid to take friendly shots at its decidedly bigger brother.
“I'm the winningest [general manager] here in the city of Pittsburgh,” jokes Tony Buccilli, the director of baseball operations for the independent Washington Wild Things baseball team, 31 miles south of PNC Park. “All the other guys have been fired.”
The Pittsburgh Pirates and the Washington Wild Things are the only two professional baseball teams in Western Pennsylvania.
They are on completely different levels — a fact Mr. Buccilli and other team officials fully acknowledge.
But the Pirates’ struggles under owner Bob Nutting — just four winning seasons in 18 years during his regime, and no playoff wins in more than a decade — give the Wild Things a clear opening, team officials say, to appeal to baseball fans frustrated by ... well, by any number of grievances Pirates fans might have these days.
Read More
The Wild Things, meanwhile, have won. They have a record of 1,126 wins and 960 losses since they broke into the Frontier League in 2002 — a .540 winning percentage.
The Pirates’ record over that same time — albeit against vastly superior competition — is 1,636 wins and 1,983 loses, a winning percentage of .452.
Two different teams. In many ways.
So as the little brother in a pro sports region, how do the Wild Things market themselves?
‘Results matter’
The Pirates’ overall record as a franchise was, relatively recently, around 600 games over .500. But as of Friday, it was just four games over break-even.
That’s the result of the last three decades’ worth of losing seasons — except for a few playoff appearances in the mid-2010s.
So the Wild Things try to appeal to fans who are tired of paying Major League prices for a club that rarely produces a winning season.
“We try to be very vocal, saying, ‘Hey, we're different,’” Mr. Buccilli said.
“We're not operating off taxpayer dollars (and) our stadium is not taxpayer-built. This venue is here to be utilized. It's supposed to be fun, and we're gonna do everything we can to win.”
And to take jabs at the big club just a short drive away on I-79.
“Western PA, you have a choice when it comes to your professional baseball,” the Wild Things posted on X in 2024. “You deserve more than a ‘working towards winning narrative.’ Results matter.”
Since the Pirates last reached the postseason a decade ago, Mr. Buccilli notes, his team has been to five playoffs and three championship series. Through Thursday, the Wild Things were 26-22, leading the Frontier League’s Midwest Conference Central Division at the halfway point of the season.
Still, the Wild Things know they are far from the level at which the Pirates play.
The vast majority of the players at EQT Park — the team’s 3,200-capacity stadium just off I-70 — will never swing a bat in an MLB game. Whereas players are mostly drafted into the MLB, in the Frontier League, there’s simply a form for former college or pro players to fill out if they want to be considered for teams. The combined salary of the entire Wild Things’ roster is less than the salary of the lowest-paid player on the Pirates, who’s making the league minimum.
Frontier League players generally average a salary of about $1,500 per month, according to Front Office Sports.
And that’s only for the months in which they play — typically the season begins in early May and runs through September, for teams making the playoffs. They also get housing at no cost and a small per diem.
Playing for the Pirates is the ultimate goal of Wild Things players. But while they’re in Washington, winning matters, team officials said.
“Pittsburgh's still that way. You need to be a winner or they're gonna just ignore you,” Mr. Buccilli said. “That's something that we can control on the baseball side, and we put a lot of effort and resources into making sure we do our part.”
The Pirates did not respond to multiple emails and phone calls for comment on this story.
The EQT Park experience
Without MLB-level talent to promote, the Wild Things look for other opportunities.
A good place to start is cheap tickets. For $16.50, no matter your seat, fans get through the gates.
Then come the promotions: free tickets to fans over 50, and $1 hot dogs on Wednesdays.
To appeal to a somewhat younger crowd, the Wild Things offer $1 beers on Thursdays.
Other promotions and activities outside of baseball — including rapper Lil Jon’s appearance at the ballpark’s Tacos and Tequila Festival on June 28 — generate additional revenue and interest. The Four Chord Music Festival, featuring Blink-182 and Jimmy Eat World, comes to Washington in mid-September. The Wild Things will also host Steelers star Cam Heyward’s celebrity charity softball game on July 14.
Those events, in addition to donation drives, youth baseball games and theme nights, are important for the Wild Things’ ability to connect with their community, team officials said.
“There's a lot of fun in that, as an organization, of being an entertainment venue that brings in people and drives attention into the community,” Mr. Buccilli said. “[It’s] the first time some of these people will ever come out to the stadium, or they'll walk on the field and say, ‘This is awesome,’ and then they'll come back for a game.
“That's the exposure we can create, because we don't have a $2 million advertising budget.”
Lest the Big League club up the road think otherwise, Wild Things CEO Christine Blaine reiterated that her club knows “we're not MLB, and we know that we're not competing with the Pirates.”
However, she said: “I think they've probably taken more exception to us than we would ever to them. I’ve noticed that the Pirates seem to have taken some of our stuff. That's kind of a flattering thing, I think. But I wish them well.”
An intimate setting
In the stands, there is little, if any, bad blood between the Wild Things and the Pirates.
At a recent home game in Washington, black and gold gear was popular among the 1,000 or so attendees. Just as many fans donned jerseys with “Skenes” and “McCutchen” stitched across their backs as those who wore Wild Things jerseys (with no names).
Those same fans chased aluminum-wrapped hot dogs when the Wild Things used a launcher to toss them into the stands. And they groaned when the Wild Things’ pitcher couldn’t strike out the opposing team’s “beer batter” — for if he had struck out, beer would have been discounted that night.
Little moments like that, team officials say, are how the Wild Things strive to keep fans coming back. The Pirates put together a much larger show in their 38,747-seat stadium. So the Wild Things keep their baseball small, in a personal venue.
“When we opened this place, our whole campaign was based on the way it ought to be. Players in the same tax bracket as you. Thirty-three cents an inning is what you're paying,” Ms. Blaine said, sitting feet away from a baseball-shaped hole in her window.
“Our whole focus was on the fact that we were affordable, that our players sign autographs. … When you have a little child, your child doesn't know if that's Barry Bonds or if it's Joe Smith.”
Of course, Joe Smith doesn’t hit as many home runs as Barry Bonds.
But Mr. Buccilli insists there’s plenty of talent on the team he fields.
“We want to focus on being a winning product,” he said. “That's something that we can control, so that messaging resonates with a lot of people.”
The Pirates effect
As the MLB speeds up games to win over younger fans, Mr. Buccilli and Ms. Blaine said the Wild Things focus on a different demographic: grandparents and their grandchildren. Those in the middle are also responding: Fans in their 30s and 40s who came to games as kids are coming to games now with their kids, they said.
“I've got an 11-year-old son, a 13-year-old daughter, and every time we go out, it's just a fun night,” said Chase McClain, the Washington County Chamber of Commerce’s marketing director.
Wild Things management said they feel positive about their connection to the community and the future of the club.
“When we first started, it was such a hot new ticket, and we turned people away,” Ms. Blaine said. “We've seen the growth, and it's really cool to see that.”
“I think fun is always going to be relevant,” Mr. McClain said. “The Wild Things have been serving that up on a diamond-sized dish for like 20 years now.”
So are the Wild Things rooting for the Pirates? Is business better in Washington when the big club plays well, or when it loses?
Doesn’t really matter. The Wild Things say the Pirates' performance doesn't actually affect them.
“When the Pirates are doing well, people are interested in baseball, and so that helps us,” said Ms. Blaine.
And when they lose?
“They get mad at the Pirates,” she said. “And they'll come here.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.