Carnegie Mellon University has joined a federal lawsuit against the National Science Foundation challenging the agency’s new cap on reimbursement for research-related expenses, which would cost the university millions of dollars a year.
The four-count lawsuit was filed Monday in the U.S. District Court in Massachusetts on behalf of 13 universities by the Association of American Universities and against the National Science Foundation. At issue is a new NSF cap of 15% on payments for research-related expenses such as building maintenance and special computer systems.
The new rate went into effect Monday and the lawsuit seeks a permanent injunction prohibiting the rate cut and other relief.
Historically, universities negotiated individually for indirect costs related to research grants to cover such things as special equipment needed for a project.
CMU’s indirect cost rate had been 51.8%, which was added to the direct research part of awards. If the 15% cap stands, the university would lose $7.5 million a year, based on CMU’s 690 active NSF grants totaling $332.6 million, according to the lawsuit.
The losses would be steeper for other plaintiffs. The University of Pennsylvania, for example, would lose $10 million annually based on its 132 active NSF grants valued at $73.3 million.
Read More
Nationally, indirect cost ratios for grant awards at universities range between 50% and 60%.
“A 15% facilities and administrative rate cap would cause a sudden and severe shortfall in federal funding for U.S. research universities, effectively crippling some of our nation’s greatest and surest engines of innovation and economic prosperity,” CMU President Farnam Jahanian said in an email to faculty.
Since January, CMU has seen five NSF grants canceled outright, which were valued at $3.3 million.
Cancelation of NSF grants had been extremely rare before the Trump administration took office in January. Since then, more than 1,000 awards have been revoked, according to crowd-sourced data compiled by rOpenSci, an Austin, Texas-based nonprofit.
The University of Pittsburgh has had $44.7 million in federal grants canceled since February, including 10 valued at $16.2 million in March from the National Institutes of Health. Pitt is an AAU member, but not a party to the lawsuit.
The new NSF cap is part of a larger broadside against higher education by the Trump administration, which has included freezing federal grants to Harvard and Columbia universities in recent weeks. President Donald Trump has also said he wants the Internal Revenue Service to revoke Harvard’s nonprofit status and to restrict admission of international students, a lucrative source of revenue for universities.
Legislation establishing the NSF was signed into law by President Harry S. Truman. The agency awarded $7.2 billion research grants last year.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.