The aisles in the Hill District’s only grocer are still full of vegetables, fruits, frozen goods, meat, bread, dairy and more. But there are a variety of empty shelves that lurk around each corner on the store’s last day.

Just over a year after opening, Salem’s Market will be pausing operations at the 1850 Centre Ave. location for an unknown amount of time. The announcement created uncertainty among regular customers. No exact timeline was provided by the company.

On Sunday, signs littered the inside of the store that read: “Salem’s Market Centre Ave will be temporarily closing as of Feb. 17. All of your international favorites are now available at 2923 Penn Ave in the Strip District.”

The Urban Development Authority announced the development in a Wednesday statement, noting that it’s “not the right time” to run a full-service grocery store at the site. The decision came in partnership with the market and the city of Pittsburgh, the statement said.

Advertise with us

This again leaves residents of Pittsburgh’s Hill District without a neighborhood grocery store. The new Salem’s outpost was seen as a major victory for the Hill District, ending the five-year “food desert” status in the neighborhood and providing more than 60 jobs to local residents when it opened in February 2024. But now, some customers are worried about what this means for their access to food.

“It’s going to be a problem because I don’t like Giant Eagle or Walmart. I’ll probably eat less,” Derek Payne, a resident of the Oak Hill section of the Hill District. “It impacts a lot.”

Mr. Payne said he lives right down street from Salem’s Centre Avenue location. He had the ability to walk to the store.

“I hope they can reopen, I hope they can work something out,” he said.

Jeffrey Anderson, a Hill District resident for more than 30 years, said he was upset but not surprised that the store was closing. Having grown up in the area, he remembered the Shop ‘n Save that was in the same location and closed its doors in March 2019.

Advertise with us
Michael Lorenz, from Oakland, left, waits in the deli line with Glen Cee, from the Hill District, at Salem's Market on Friday May 24, 2024, Hill District. (John Colombo / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“It will impact the community with traveling. It’s a couple more miles to get food when [Salem’s Market] was right here in the neighborhood,” Mr. Anderson said. “We haven’t had a grocery store here in the neighborhood in a couple years. It’s a decent store, fresh food, and yeah, we hate to see them go.”

He added that some of his friends, who no longer drive, will now have to take the bus to get to a reliable food source.

Some recurring customers also were disappointed that there would no longer be a location in the Hill District with a diverse selection of food to choose from.

Keivan Kapoutari, originally from Iran and now residing in Millvale for his engineering research at Carnegie Mellon University Portugal, said he appreciated going to the Hill District’s Salem’s location because it gave him a positive feeling.

“When I came to the United States, I noticed there was a market where I can buy the stuff that I need, and the stuff is way similar to my country — I didn’t feel like I’m a foreigner here,” Mr. Kapoutari said. “It made me comfortable regarding the situation here, I am newly here.”

Advertise with us

He explained that because he is new to Pittsburgh, he hasn’t had much time to explore. He said he was happy to land at Salem’s market.

Sarahjameela Martin, of Knoxville, said she travels to Salem’s Hill District location specifically for its selection of halal food. She said she will likely still go to the Strip District location while the Centre Avenue location is closed, but is still disappointed in the store’s closure.

“We are heartbroken. It was a great store” Ms. Martin said.

Many of the goods sold at the Centre Avenue location will still be available at the Strip District location, including its long-standing halal food operation. But some residents are hoping that Salem’s Market reopens quickly in the Hill District.

Dana Bohince, the URA’s communications manager, said last week that officials don’t have “the answers” yet, but the hope is to keep the store in the community by downsizing or reconfiguring the existing building.

“Hopefully, they reopen back up if this is temporarily and hopefully the process is not long and will speed up a little faster,” Mr. Anderson said.