One of us recently attended a program presented by Mark Lachs, MD, MPH and Jason Karlawish, MD describing the Cornell-Penn Interview for Decisional Abilities (“IDA”).
As Elder Law attorneys, we’ve spent many years assisting clients dealing with diminished capacity and the problems related to undue influence, elder financial abuse and the need for and the use of protective services agencies and their value to clients.
These issues are important as most individuals with some degree of diminished capacity struggle to maintain the highest degree of independence.
The IDA is an evolving tool that differs from other cognitive testing tools traditionally used in this area. The focus is designed to help an individual understand risks and their ability to make sound decisions about service options.
According to the New York City Weill Cornell Medicine Geriatrics and Palliative Medicine website (www.geriatrics-palliative.weill.cornell.edu) this tool is necessary to complement other traditional “testing” methods because cognition and capacity, though related, are not the same. This is because many patients with highly impaired cognition retain decision making abilities to make simple decisions. And conversely, many patients with perfect cognition may not have good or adequate decision-making ability.
The bottom line is that different decisions, depending on their level of complexity, require different levels of decision-making ability.
Read More
The IDA website goes on to describe what it is not:
1. IDA is not a scale that produces a numerical score (like some mini-mental state exams).
2. It is also not yet a legally recognized determination of capacity or a petition for guardianship.
3. The IDA is not a replacement for an overall Adult Protective Services (“APS”) investigation/assessment; and
4. And it is not a tool designed to persuade clients to accept services.
Here are some of the advantages of using the IDA:
1. It standardizes the assessment of decision-making ability so that different APS workers can have higher degrees of agreement when assessing the same older person’s abilities.
2. It helps us to understand a client’s thoughts and reasoning, which can be particularly important in dealing with a client’s financial issues.
3. It assists APS workers when they are discussing clients with their supervisors.
4. It enhances referrals for more formal evaluations.
5. It allows more efficient use of APS Psychiatrists, and
6. It helps insulate against liability issues when a client is deemed to retain decision making ability and an untoward/negative event subsequently occurs.
The program presently has an online IDA Practitioner course combined with a live facilitated workshop and discussion session to enable the practitioner to incorporate the IDA interview into their case assessment practice. The continuing evolving theme in the laws and courts of Pennsylvania is to promote independence for personal decision making and to utilize the least restrictive methods for surrogate decision making.
The IDA appears to be a revolutionary tool to help individuals more accurately assess their needs and live an enhanced quality of life. In addition, it can be a future tool for Elder Law attorneys in evaluating and assisting clients carry out their wishes.
Julian Gray and Frank Petrich are certified elder law attorneys who practice in the Pittsburgh area at Gray Elder Law. Send questions to elderlawguys@grayelderlaw.com or visit www.grayelderlaw.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.