You could call 2020 the year that PNC’s wish came true.
In its first bank acquisition in eight years, the Pittsburgh-based financial services giant struck a deal to buy the Houston, Texas-based U.S. unit of Spain’s BBVA bank for $11.6 billion in cash.
“We’ve always had [BBVA] at the top or near the top of our wish list,” PNC Financial Services Group CEO William Demchak said during a conference call discussing the acquisition in mid-November.
You might say Pittsburghers got their wish, too.
The transaction, slated to close in mid-2021, gives PNC a foothold in Texas and other fast-growing markets in the southwest, giving it a big boost in its quest to become a true national player. That helps to ensure PNC remains independent and headquartered in Pittsburgh — where it employs about 12,000 in the region and serves as a benefactor to the community.
Some 25 years ago, “PNC was on everyone’s takeover list,” Wells Fargo analyst Mike Mayo said recently. “The consensus was PNC would go the way of Corestates, the biggest bank in Philly,” which was swallowed up in 1998 by First Union Corp. in Charlotte, N.C., and eventually ended up as part of San Francisco’s Wells Fargo.
Read More
“Over two decades later, not only is PNC surviving, it’s thriving and creating a stronger foundation to become a national bank,” Mr. Mayo said.
“This is one of the more unpredictable outcomes,” he said. “I’m not trying to disrespect Pittsburgh, but it’s not where you would expect a national bank to generate from.”
The bigger and stronger PNC gets, the more it controls its own destiny.
“Bill Demchak should be the person of the week in the Pittsburgh business community,” Mr. Mayo said last month when the BBVA deal was announced. “We expect Pittsburgh to retain its hometown bank for many years to come.”
PNC was able to snag BBVA USA with the money it generated from selling its roughly 22% stake in money manager Blackrock Inc. in May. Mr. Demchak said he believed PNC’s all-cash offer helped motivate the bank to sell.
PNC sold its Blackrock stake for about $420 per share for a total of $14.4 billion. Although the bank made a huge profit on the sale, one can imagine Mr. Demchak kicking himself for not waiting a bit longer to unload. Blackrock shares have climbed steadily since the sale and are now trading in the $700 range.
“I’m not certain anyone in May would have said that the U.S. equity markets by fall would be breaking record levels,” said Gerard Cassidy, managing director and bank analyst at RBC Capital Markets. “You can always second guess yourself. I think it was a smart decision.”
“You can’t time these things perfectly,” said Arnold Kakuda, an analyst with Bloomberg Intelligence.
“The key thing is the company was able to take a successful, but passive, investment in Blackrock and buy something they have direct control of.”
In the long run, investing in BBVA should produce better returns than hanging on to the Blackrock stock, he said. “This is what PNC can control and what PNC is good at.”
The price of PNC’s stock, which started the year trading at close to $160 a share, briefly sunk into the $80s with the onset of the pandemic this spring, but it has since recovered. As of Wednesday, it was trading in the $147 range.
The addition of BBVA would boost PNC to the fifth largest bank in the country, up from No. 7, with some $566 billion in assets.
Still, a big gap will remain between PNC and the nation’s top four mega banks, which all have assets in the trillions. They include JP Morgan Chase at No. 1 with about $2.87 trillion in assets, followed by Bank of America, Wells Fargo and Citibank.
A big challenge for PNC going forward will be boosting profitability at BBVA, which Mr. Mayo termed a “suboptimal” franchise.
“Can PNC spin straw into gold? There is a lot to accomplish,” he said.
PNC’s return on assets was about 1.3% in 2019 or roughly double that at BBVA. Return on assets is an indicator of how efficient a company’s management is at using its assets to generate earnings.
PNC is hoping to energize BBVA by cutting costs and cross-selling PNC’s much larger suite of products and services to BBVA customers.
The strategy is similar to what PNC did on a smaller scale with Raleigh, N.C.-based RBC Bank —- the U.S. banking arm of Royal Bank of Canada — which it acquired in 2012. About one-fifth the size of BBVA, RBC gave PNC a foothold in the southern states of North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, Alabama, Georgia and Florida.
Mr. Mayo called the BBVA acquisition the biggest strategic move for PNC since it took over Cleveland-based National City in 2008 during the financial crisis. The National City transaction, overseen by former CEO James Rohr, doubled PNC’s size and gave it the scale to compete with the biggest players.
One major difference between the two deals, however, was the acquisition price. National City was hemorrhaging hundreds of millions of red ink and was snapped up by PNC “at a remarkable, ridiculously good price,” Mr. Mayo said.
The price tag for BBVA wasn’t bad, he said, “just not compelling.”
Looking ahead, the challenge for all big banks will be to navigate through the pandemic and an uncertain economy.
“The economy is very cloudy over the near term. Investors and bankers don’t know if the U.S. economy will go into a double-dip recession,” Mr. Cassidy, of RBC Capital Markets, said. “We see light at the end of the tunnel with the vaccine coming, but we are still in the middle of the crisis.”
In any case, PNC is in good shape financially to weather a downturn, analysts said.
Like other banks, PNC has been building cash reserves during the pandemic in case the economy tanks and causes a cascade of bad loans.
But PNC has been particularly cautious in its approach by building an extra cushion.
“If things turn out badly, they are more prepared than most. If things turn out better than expected, they will have extra gains” when the bank releases unneeded reserves, said Mr. Kakuda of Bloomberg Intelligence.
He said 2021 will be a transition year for PNC as it integrates BBVA and absorbs roughly $1 billion in merger costs. Merger synergies that are projected to slash some $900 million from expenses are expected in 2022.
The cost cuts are expected to come from eliminating redundant legal, personnel, accounting and other back office functions, plus some branches in the southeast, where there is some overlap, analysts said. In addition, BBVA’s investments in technology will no longer be needed because PNC will convert those systems to PNC’s superior platform.
“The jury is still out. We won’t know for a couple of years how successful this transaction will be, ” Mr. Cassidy said. “On paper, it looks very strong.
“If they execute as well as they did with the National City and RBC deals, this should be a real win for PNC shareholders.”
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.