It’s 15 minutes past noon on a sunny October weekday — typically a bustling time for the food court at Fifth Avenue Place, Downtown.

But with the pandemic still raging and much of the city’s office staff working from home, the lunch counters are dark — and it’s eerily quiet.

Instead of the chattering din of a crowd, the only sound that can be heard is the whirring of the escalators rotating in a ghostly, endless loop. A sign declaring “Line Starts Here” at the end of a retractable rope at the shuttered Rosso Pizzeria stands as a mocking reminder of normal times.

Just outside, despite the unusually warm weather, the sidewalks are sparsely peppered with pedestrians.

Advertise with us

Across the street, there are no lines at McDonald’s, while the swanky Eddie Merlot’s restaurant is closed except for takeout until dinnertime. Down the street at the Sly Fox Taphouse, just two outdoor tables are occupied. There are no customers inside.

During these unsettling times, parking garages sit nearly empty, and many restaurants and businesses that rely on the regular swarm of office workers into town have been forced to close, at least temporarily.

Amid a fall surge in COVID-19 cases and with the governor’s mandate to work remotely still in force, the scene is unlikely to change any time soon.

"Closed until further notice" sign posted in a store window in the deserted Fifth Avenue Place on Thursday, Oct. 29, 2020, in Downtown. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

One of Pittsburgh’s signature skyscrapers, Fifth Avenue Place is the headquarters for health care giant Highmark Health, which occupies 26 floors in the now largely empty 31-story building.

“We continue to plan for a safe, phased and gradual return to work for our non-clinical employees after Jan. 1, subject to re-evaluation ... as we draw closer to that date,” spokeswoman Janice Maszle said recently in an email. “The health and safety of our employees remain paramount.”

Advertise with us

In early July, Highmark was ready to begin recalling a limited number of office personnel across its Western Pennsylvania and West Virginia footprint, but scuttled the move due to a jump in COVID-19 cases.

Companies are proceeding with caution for good reason. According to health experts, among the riskiest places for catching the virus are enclosed spaces with poor ventilation where people gather for long periods — such as in open office settings and restaurants.

In addition to Highmark, other major employers in the city also are uncertain about when office staff may be able to return in full force as they await the nod from the governor amid hopes for a vaccine.

At PNC Financial Services Group, Pittsburgh’s biggest bank, “Those who are working remotely will continue to do so until at least until the start of the new year,” spokeswoman Marcey Zwiebel said in an email.

PNC employs some 12,500 people in the Pittsburgh region. The majority of the company’s non-customer-facing workforce has been working remotely since the beginning of the pandemic, including nearly all employees at the bank’s corporate headquarters, Downtown, and call center at Firstside Center on First Avenue.

Advertise with us

At Bank of New York Mellon, employees are being told they also will continue to work remotely at least through Jan. 1. Roughly 95% of the New York-based company’s global workforce of 47,900 people are staying at home, a spokeswoman said.

No parking

With so many workers rolling out of bed and slipping directly behind their laptops, the dramatic decline in commuter traffic has decimated business for parking lots and garages around town.

Alco Parking Corp., the city’s largest private operator, is on track to have its worst year since it was founded in 1925, according to company president Merrill Stabile.

“I tell people I can’t complain about parking revenue because there isn’t any,” Mr. Stabile said last week.

Advertise with us

A few properties are doing better than others — such as lots that serve apartment residents, and the nearly 1,000-space Gold 1 Garage on the North Shore where employees at Allegheny General Hospital park and get shuttled to work. But overall, business is down about 80%, he said, which has resulted in the layoff this past spring of about half of the company’s 200-person workforce.

Lately, Mr. Stabile has seen a slight improvement in his overall business, which he attributed to more companies letting workers sporadically venture into offices. The uptick has allowed Alco to recall a limited number of employees, he said.

A staggered return

A deserted Fifth Avenue Place on Thursday, Oct. 29, 2020, in Downtown. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

North Shore-based Peoples Natural Gas is one of those companies that Mr. Stabile is talking about.

In early October, Peoples began rotating employees back into its headquarters building, with one-third of the 435 staffers reporting to work on alternating weeks.

Advertise with us

“With only a third of our people in the building [at one time], we can space ourselves out very widely,” spokesman Barry Kukovich said.

He said Peoples officials don’t believe the move violates Gov. Tom Wolf’s order, which requires businesses to keep employees home “unless that is not possible.”

“The ramp-up of service through October-November and into the winter is the most demanding time for a natural gas utility,” Mr. Kukovich said in an email. “We are an essential service. For safety and efficiency, we believe this limited return is necessary.”

Peoples had started to recall office workers in phases back in mid-June, but sent them all back home in July when COVID-19 cases spiked.

As normalcy waits, some companies are taking advantage of low occupancy in their buildings to make upgrades — from replacing outdated restroom fixtures with touchless soap and paper towel dispensers to more ambitious projects like modernizing their heating and cooling systems.

Advertise with us

In preparation for when the majority of employees return, Highmark has added toe pulls on doors so people can open them without having to touch any handles.

A dining area in the deserted Fifth Avenue Place, Thursday, Oct. 29, 2020, in Downtown. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The company also has made major upgrades to the air-filtration systems in all its buildings, adding HEPA filters, antimicrobial prefilter blankets and increasing the exchange of fresh air. The work means the air is sanitized to the standard found in hospitals and other clinical settings, said Dana Garcia, vice president of corporate real estate services at Highmark.

When the time comes, “We want people to feel like the space they are coming back to is safe,” he said.

What comes next

Although many businesses nationwide that count on packed offices for their survival are hoping the massive work-at-home experiment is temporary, some experts predict COVID-19 has changed the way many people work for good.

Advertise with us

“Our best estimate is that 25-30% of the workforce will be working from home multiple days a week by the end of 2021,” Global Workplace Analytics president Kate Lister said in a recent forecast. That compares with 3.6% of the U.S. workforce that worked at home half the time or more before the pandemic, she said.

One big reason for the expected increase is less fear about lost productivity by managers and top executives who also have been working from home during the crisis.

“The research shows that managers who have worked at home themselves are more likely to endorse it for others,” the report said. “Their worries about lost productivity go away.

“As they and their people get used to using virtual tools, their worries about not being able to collaborate are proven wrong. And they see for themselves just how much happier and engaged they are without the stress of commuting, being away from loved ones [and without] workplace interruptions,” the report said.

“Our prediction is that the longer people are required to work at home, the greater the adoption we will see when the dust settles.”

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.