WASHINGTON — The country’s largest labor federation on Tuesday endorsed a new North American trade deal negotiated by the Trump administration, a significant boost to get the rewrite of North American Free Trade Agreement across the finish line in Congress as early as next week.
If that happens, expect Pennsylvania Sen. Pat Toomey — a Republican and ardent supporter of lowering trade barriers — to protest loudly.
Mr. Toomey, after a briefing by Robert Lighthizer, the U.S. trade representative, told reporters the Trump administration gave away critical provisions in bargaining with House Democrats, who announced their support along with the AFL-CIO Tuesday morning.
The new agreement, called the the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement or USMCA, “clearly moved way to the left” by including stricter labor protections in Mexico, threatening tariffs, eliminating protections for investors and imposing a expiration date in 16 years unless renewed by Congress, Mr. Toomey said.
“It runs contrary to the principles of a free trade agreement,” said Mr. Toomey, who was the only Republican to state his opposition to USMCA during a Senate Finance Committee hearing in July. “Many of the changes are counterproductive.”
It’s unclear whether Mr. Toomey’s colleagues share his frustration and, if so, are willing to block what would be a significant legislative achievement for President Donald Trump.
Read More
Passage of the USMCA would notch a major victory for Mr. Trump, who campaigned in 2016 on a promise to tear up trade deals, calling NAFTA, signed into law in 1993, “the worst deal ever.”
It would also be a remarkable moment of compromise reached by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., as the House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry against Mr. Trump churns on. An hour before meeting with reporters on the USMCA, Ms. Pelosi joined top Democrats to unveil two articles of impeachment against Mr. Trump.
At the USMCA announcement, Ms. Pelosi said she was confident the deal had enough support among Democrats to become law. Months of Capitol Hill negotiations with Mr. Lighthizer had resulted in stronger labor, environmental and enforcement provisions, Ms. Pelosi said.
“It is infinitely better than what was initially proposed by the administration,” she said. “It’s a victory for America’s workers.”
Organized labor’s support was critical in the Democratically controlled House, and the AFL-CIO’s endorsement gives the green light for lawmakers to line up behind the pact. Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, and Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Mt. Lebanon, did not respond to a request for comment as of early afternoon.
Richard Trumka, president of AFL-CIO, said in a statement on Tuesday that the final language is a “vast improvement over both the original NAFTA and the flawed proposal brought forward in 2017.”
“President Trump may have opened this deal, but working people closed it,” said Mr. Trumka, a Greene County native and longtime leader of the labor federation, which encompasses unions with nearly 13 million members. “Now we have secured an agreement that working people can proudly support.”
The AFL-CIO’s statement said the final USMCA deal eliminates some of the Trump administration’s initial proposals, including loopholes designed to make it harder to prosecute labor violations.
“For the first time, there truly will be enforceable labor standards — including a process that allows for the inspections of factories and facilities that are not living up to their obligations,” Mr. Trumka stated.
In an interview with the Post-Gazette in August, Mr. Trumka withheld judgment on the deal, saying he wanted greater enforcement measures.
In June, Mr. Trumka held a NAFTA Trade Tour town hall in Pittsburgh to discuss the opportunity for a better deal. In September, he flew to Mexico City to press Mexican president Andrés Manuel López Obrador to commit to all the labor provisions.
The Trump administration appears to have allowed one such measure the AFL-CIO pushed for: trade penalties at the U.S. border for goods that skirt the new agreement.
Mr. Toomey, speaking with reporters on Tuesday, said he was still reading through outline language circulated by House Democrats. But new concessions by the administration regarding labor provisions include “facility-based enforcement of labor obligations” and penalties on goods and services “not produced in compliance with collective bargaining agreements,” he said.
“It sure sounds like there could be tariffs or quotas or some kind of penalty imposed on Mexican products if somebody alleges there’s a factory not in compliance with collective bargaining,” Mr. Toomey said.
He added that “these provisions are meant to diminish the only competitive advantage Mexico has, and that is that is a low-cost economy, and it has correspondingly lower wages.”
The Trump administration also appeared to roll back intellectual property protections for biologic medicines. U.S. law currently requires 12 years of exclusivity on promising new drugs, he said, allowing companies to earn a return on research and development costs.
Mr. Toomey called the move a “complete capitulation” to Democrats, who see the protections as benefiting drug companies and increase health care costs.
Yet the changes approved by Mr. Trump could build Democratic support in the House for the new trade deal, which governs a massive amount of commerce.
Trade with Canada and Mexico supports 12 million U.S. jobs, with exports supporting 2 million manufacturing jobs, according to the National Association of Manufacturers. Nearly one-third of U.S. agricultural exports go to Canada and Mexico.
Uncertainty about the fate of NAFTA — as Mr. Trump at times threatened to rip up the deal entirely — rippled through small firms in the Pittsburgh region, like DMI Companies, an HVAC components manufacturer in Monongahela, which ships products around the continent.
Business groups, which have been aggressively marketing USMCA for months in Washington, praised the deal.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce said “this development will open the door to final approval of USMCA on a bipartisan basis by the end of the year, which will especially benefit American farmers, manufacturers, and small businesses.”
The National Mining Association called it “a win not just for mining, but for our manufacturing, technology, energy and defense industries.”
In a case of strange bedfellows, unions agreed.
Darrin Kelly, president of the Allegheny County Labor Council, the local chapter of the AFL-CIO, said the USMCA was “without a doubt a win for the American worker.”
“The American people need to remember this is a win for the entire country,” Mr. Kelly said in a brief interview, “not for a political party.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.