When the Rivers Casino opened 10 years ago, the goal was to attract people like John and Mary Kaye Baccelli, a retired husband and wife waiting in line with dozens of others for discounted buffet dinners Wednesday evening.

The North Shore gambling hall has drawn the Baccellis and plenty of others, to the tune of some $3.3 billion that patrons have left behind in slot machines and at table games since Aug. 9, 2009. Some of that is out of the pockets of the Baldwin Borough couple, which doesn’t bother them a bit.
“I think it’s good for the city,” Ms. Baccelli, 70, said of the casino. “It brings in revenue and provides opportunities for jobs and recreation.”
“When you get to a certain age, and you have extra money, you don’t mind spending it on wagering as a form of entertainment,” added her husband, describing a limit of several hundred dollars he sets on his slot play per visit.
The Baccellis ended their occasional Las Vegas trips after the arrival of the Rivers. That was the point stressed by state officials who pushed for 2004’s law legalizing casinos: Pennsylvanians were gambling elsewhere anyway, so why not keep them close to home and capture the revenue, create jobs and derive any related development benefits?
The Rivers, one of 12 casinos now in the state, can be viewed largely as achieving those goals during the past decade, though it has not been immune from problems such as early revenue shortfalls; attracting compulsive gamblers, including those who make headlines for embezzling funds used at the casino; fines from the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board, most commonly for gambling by those under 21; and instances of community friction years ago over issues such as riverfront trail use and minority hiring.
Read More

Any public criticism is hard to find today, however. The Rivers is, instead, more often commended as a community-minded entity that has enhanced Pittsburgh’s riverfront and helped enliven the North Shore.
“They’ve been a terrific partner on a lot of fronts,” said Peg McCormick Barron, chairwoman of Riverlife, a nonprofit group that promotes positive development along the rivers. “They’ve been kind of a model for a public and private partnership, with respect to providing access to everyone on the riverfront, making a beautiful space that has high design standards.”
‘Lots of energy and excitement’
For the Rivers Casino itself, things have never been better.
Its $370.5 million in pre-tax gambling revenue in the 2018-19 fiscal year ($291.1 million from nearly 2,900 slots and $78.8 million from 123 table games) marked a new high. Its 7% annual increase in revenue exceeded that of any comparable casino in the state, exceeded only by the much smaller Valley Forge Casino Resort, which benefited from a special expansion granted by the state.

It’s a far cry from 2012. During unsuccessful efforts to reduce a $199.5 million county property assessment (today it’s $246 million), representatives of casino owner Rush Street Gaming contended they needed a break because the casino was underperforming expectations. When the casino opened in August 2009, Chicago-based Rush Street had estimates from consultants that it would generate at least $400 million in slots revenue alone. It never has reached that figure, even after the state enabled addition of table games a year later, but has generally ranked third among casinos in the state in slots revenue and fourth in table games revenue.
“When those projections from consultants were made, it was prior to the Great Recession,” Rush Street CEO Greg Carlin said in a recent interview. He said people had less discretionary income for entertainment including gambling in the first few years after the casino opened. Its North Shore location, initially viewed as somewhat of an accessibility problem due to traffic concerns and Pittsburghers’ aversion to crossing bridges and navigating tunnels, has become more favorable as other nightlife options have increased nearby, he said.
“Now our business is positive, the revenues are good,” said Mr. Carlin, regardless of reaching the $400 million figure. “The whole feel on the casino floor is different — lots of energy and excitement.”
Since December, the casino has been attracting new customers — first from opening of a sportsbook attracting a lot of younger patrons, then from creating a 2,200-capacity events center attracting crowds such as those expected for Aug. 10-11 anniversary concerts by Frankie Valli & The Four Seasons.
“We’re attracting people that have never experienced our brand — never been on the property — and they get here and experience what it’s like on a Friday or Saturday night, and we have a great opportunity to get them back again,” said Rivers General Manager Bill Keena. The casino does not take a head count of customers, but several thousand patrons typically visit at its busiest on weekends, their cars filling the bulk of its 3,800-space garage.
Mr. Keena, who helped manage six casinos in other states before joining the Rivers in January 2018, said the facility began seeing a revenue upswing last year even before adding sports betting and the $3.5 million events center. He attributed that, in part, to better outreach to customers, particularly high-rollers. In the casino’s high-limit table games area, maximum wagers were increased from $5,000 to $25,000.
“The place was ready for a change,” Mr. Keena, 64, said of the casino. “I’m more of a risk taker.”

Despite the recent success, he pointed out during an informal tour a number of changes taking place on the spacious casino floor. For one, a group of tables for blackjack, craps and other games are being relocated for higher visibility near the main elevator entrance, in place of slot machines.
“We want people to see the excitement when they walk in,” Mr. Keena said.
Elsewhere, some older slot machines are being moved out, with more room to be devoted to a highly popular configuration of hybrid slots-table games. They feature a live dealer for blackjack and another for roulette, who run games displayed on electronic screens for play by dozens of players simultaneously. It takes out the “intimidation factor,” Mr. Keena said, for inexperienced players otherwise sitting at a traditional table with just a few other players plus a dealer.
Meanwhile, work is progressing behind walls in the casino’s center on a new $5.5 million sportsbook that will double the size of the temporary one. It’s to open in September in time for the Steelers’ second game, Mr. Keena said. Sports betting itself — including the online version the Rivers began offering in June — is not a huge money-maker for the casino, but it has had other benefits, he said.
“The piece I didn’t think was going to happen, as much as it has, is the additional food revenues and beverage revenues — even the other gambling revenue has gone up,” as a result of patrons attracted to sports betting, Mr. Keena said. “I didn’t think it was going to rise as much as it has.”
Financial impact on the region
A range of local entities have benefited from the casino’s presence. In addition to state taxes applied to all casinos, host taxes of up to $10 million annually go to the city and county. A separate tax on table games revenue has generated $11.5 million earmarked for local libraries since 2010, according to the casino.
By virtue of an agreement signed by original owner Don Barden, who was bought out by Rush Street Gaming after financing difficulties, the casino is committed to pay $7.5 million annually for 30 years to help cover PPG Paints Arena’s construction cost. The casino also committed $3 million early on to community groups in both the North Side and Hill District to assist housing and economic development projects.

The casino’s commitment to those community funds ended after three years, but Mark Fatla, executive director of the Northside Leadership Conference, credits it as largely a positive influence since its arrival.
A significant aspect, he said, is its employment impact. The Rivers has about 1,700 employees, and Mr. Fatla said it lived up to its initial commitment to give opportunity to residents of surrounding neighborhoods.
“I give them credit at the outset for putting their money where their mouth was in terms of hiring folks from low-income neighborhoods, creating that opportunity for them,” he said. “They are on a career track in a new industry that’s growing, whether you like that industry or not.”
The NAACP raised public questions in 2013 about whether minorities were being sufficiently hired and promoted, but its current president, Richard A. Stewart Jr., said discussions took place and any concerns were addressed. The casino reports that 12% of its staff is African American — about the same as Allegheny County’s black population — and minorities of one kind or another make up 14% of its management team.
“I’ve been over there numerous times — to eat, because I don’t gamble — and there are minorities all over the place,” Mr. Stewart said. “I don’t know if there was ever a real serious problem.”
There’s been nothing to indicate an increase in crime in the surrounding area, which was another initial concern, Mr. Fatla said. State police are stationed within the casino, in addition to the facility’s own security staff. They reported making 583 arrests there in 2018, for thefts, disorderly conduct or other offenses on the property, but little of that has spilled into the community.
“It certainly has added to activity on the North Shore —- certainly in comparison to the surface parking lot that was there, it’s better,” Mr. Fatla said.

A big unanswered question in his mind is whether the casino’s presence has increased the number of people experiencing gambling addiction problems, as past national research has suggested would be likely.
There is no statistical information to confirm that either way, locally. Josh L., a spokesman for the Western Pennsylvania-West Virginia region of Gamblers Anonymous, said the 20-plus regular meetings in the region and 100 to 150 regular attendees is not much different from the past. There’s been no call to add a regular meeting on the North Side.
But, he said, most people in need of help don’t seek it until in crisis, and the percentage of attendees reporting casino-related problems, such as slots addiction, has increased.
“It’s a deadlier animal than we knew,” said Josh L. (Gamblers Anonymous practice is to withhold use of last names publicly), comparing casino problem gamblers to those like him, who were addicted to horse racing and sports betting. With the 24-hour, state-sanctioned operation of the casino, “the capacity for destruction is much greater today.”
Debbie Kass, 60, who occasionally spends time risking $10 a spin on the casino’s Wheel of Fortune slots, knows a friend who had to put herself on the state’s “self-exclusion” list from lack of control, though she said she has no problem herself. She said she appreciates the chance to be entertained at night if she wants to get out on her own.
“There are people that get out of hand, but that’s anywhere,” she said. “The lights aren’t on because of winners, let’s be realistic. Fortunately, I can still eat and pay my bills, or I wouldn’t come. ...Anyone I know who’s a banker says not to come, and everyone else I know says, ‘I love that place!’”
Facing new competition
The Rivers’ biggest rival is the Meadows Racetrack & Casino in Washington County, which trails it in revenue, but it is facing new competition within a year or two from new gambling sites: mini-casinos to be developed in Big Beaver, Beaver County, and at Westmoreland Mall in Hempfield.
The Rivers had the option to bid for a license for its own mini-casino to prevent such threats, but it declined. Mr. Carlin, who is CEO of the casino as well as of Rush Street Gaming, said it made a strategic decision to spend $60 million to attach a long-planned hotel to the casino rather than invest in a separate location.

Groundbreaking for the 219-room hotel on the casino’s side facing the Carnegie Science Center is expected this month, with an early 2021 completion target.
“We’re going to have a pretty compelling product that should grow our business,” Mr. Carlin said, noting the accommodations that will be available to Steelers and Pirates fans, business travelers and others, in addition to loyal casino patrons who might be rewarded with rooms.
Mr. Keena said Pittsburgh, for now, is still a “locals” casino market, compared to a “destination” market like Las Vegas or Atlantic City. The hotel could help broaden its attraction from around the region, along with the other amenities recently added and Pittsburgh’s own gains as a tourism center.
As a full-service casino-hotel, he said, the Rivers will be better able to offset the future mini-casino competition than if it stood still.
There’s already plenty there for the Baccellis, who were surrounded by many others their age waiting to be seated in the buffet last week. Some 60% of patrons in the casino’s loyalty rewards program are at least 55 years old, Mr. Keena said, as they generally have more disposable income to spread around casinos than young adults.
“I lose, but I still come back,” Ms. Baccelli confirmed with a smile.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.