Kraft Heinz shares fell more than 27 percent Friday, as Wall Street shoved back hard against a fourth-quarter earnings report that served up anything but comfort food.
The market’s disappointment came through in analysts’ reports issued after the food giant’s shocking fourth-quarter earnings release Thursday evening in which it detailed a $15.4 billion writedown of the value of household brands like Kraft and Oscar Mayer. Oh, and it disclosed a Securities and Exchange Commission subpoena related to its accounting policies. And cut its dividend.
“It is times like these that we rethink our investment process and what led to and supported our Buy rating for Kraft Heinz so confidently of late,” wrote Stifel analyst Christopher R. Growe in a report that downgraded the stock to “hold” status and revised the target price from $72 per share to $35.
Kraft Heinz shares closed at $34.95, down $13.23.
Wolfe Research analysts noted it might be time to recognize that growing sales of products like processed meats and cheeses was always going to be harder than anyone thought.
“We certainly were aware of the risks in our Outperform rating ... but those risks now read like a checklist demonstrating Murphy’s Law (Anything that can go wrong, will go wrong).”
Read More
Nobody likes a surprise, said Catherine Seifert, an analyst with CFRA.
She wasn’t impressed with Kraft Heinz management’s explanations of what happened and why investors should keep the faith in the company created in 2015 through a marriage of Pittsburgh’s H.J. Heinz Co. and Illinois-based Kraft Foods.
“I think people came off that call with more questions than answers,” Ms. Seifert said in an interview Friday morning.
Kraft Heinz, partially owned by a joint venture of private equity fund 3G Capital and Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway, has been seen as a model of how old-line companies can be made more profitable through smart consolidation and cost-cutting to improve efficiency.
That appeared to work when the joint venture ran Heinz from 2013 and again when it merged with Kraft in 2015. Another transformative merger was expected a couple of years later, but nothing worked out.
CEO Bernardo Hees has been promoting Kraft Heinz’s work bringing new life to established products like mayonnaise, mustard and frozen meals. In Thursday’s conference call, he called out good results in new product launches and argued that trends are heading the right direction.
But analysts have heard that before, and they weren’t pleased to hear that management now expects 2019 to be a rebuilding year. “While we continue to believe that we can deliver top tier growth, it will take hold from 2020 onwards,” Chief Financial Officer David H. Knopf said on the call.
Other food companies like General Mills and Campbell Soup have also struggled in recent years, but Kraft Heinz was expected to do better.
Ms. Seifert said the market is now realizing consumer product companies are really running up against a wall that will be hard to surmount. “I also think this speaks to a fairly significant transition that’s happening in this space,” she said.
And it raises the issue of whether the team at Kraft Heinz is up to the challenge. “The question is how do you pivot a company this size?” Ms. Seifert said.
Kraft Heinz reported total 2018 sales of $26.3 billion, up slightly from the year earlier.
Growing trust issues between the company and its investors won’t be helped by the fact that it didn’t disclose the SEC subpoena that arrived in October. The company released third-quarter earnings results in early November.
Kraft Heinz said Thursday that it has launched its own investigation and implemented changes to its internal controls, and that the impact of changes made is not expected to be material. It said it is collaborating with the SEC.
Ms. Seifert said the disappointing earnings results may force a decision on Berkshire Hathaway, which is a famously hands-off investment partner. Should it get more involved?
“I think there’s more to come with this story,” she said.
Teresa F. Lindeman: tlindeman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2018
Updated at 6:22 p.m. Feb. 22, 2019




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.