An activist investment group said it wants to push aside PPG’s chairman and chief executive Michael McGarry and put former chair Charles Bunch back at the helm of the Pittsburgh coatings giant because, “We are confident Chuck is the right person to get the company back on track.”

Trian Fund Management, which recently disclosed a 3 percent stake in PPG, on Thursday issued a white paper that detailed why it believes the Downtown-based company has significantly underperformed under Mr. McGarry’s leadership.

Known for its efforts to shake up management and strategy in its corporate investments, Trian also called for PPG to split into two businesses: one for architectural paints and one for industrial coatings.

PPG issued a response, saying its board stands unanimously behind Mr. McGarry but is willing to listen to Trian’s suggestions on other matters.

Advertise with us

Trian’s 2.9 percent position in PPG equals 7 million shares and was valued at about $685 million as of Wednesday, the fund said.

After Trian made public its criticism of PPG and its leadership, shares in the company spiked and were up by more than 5 percent  in mid-afternoon trading. The shares closed at $103.71, up more than 6 percent.

The stock had been near a 52-week low since PPG warned its third-quarter earnings wouldn’t meet Wall Street’s projections.

Speaking at an investors conference Thursday in Toronto, Canada, Ed Garden, Trian’s chief investment officer and a founding partner, cited a host of reasons PPG needs a change at the top because of what he termed “operating and strategic mishaps.”

Among them, he said, were the loss earlier this year of business from home improvement chain Lowe’s, a key retail customer which struck an exclusive supplier deal with PPG’s rival coatings maker Sherwin-Williams; an accounting scandal that forced PPG to restate earnings for six quarters; lower-than-expected third-quarter earnings; and PPG’s attempt in 2017 to acquire Dutch paints maker AkzoNobel in a hostile takeover.

Advertise with us

In its white paper, Trian described PPG’s $29 billion bid for Akzo as “flawed” and said “management demonstrated lapses in judgment.”

PPG said two of its independent directors, who it declined to name, met with Trian after the fund disclosed its investment earlier this month.

The directors “established a framework for a constructive and private dialogue, with which Trian agreed,” PPG said.

In a conference call with analysts last week to discuss the third-quarter results, Mr. McGarry acknowledged PPG had held discussions with Trian but declined to say whether they were friendly or hostile.

Mr. McGarry became chief executive in 2015 and was long considered the heir-apparent to Mr. Bunch. He took on the chairman’s role after Mr. Bunch retired in 2016.

Advertise with us

Though the 135-year-old company’s transformation from a maker of chemicals and glass to a global paints giant took place largely under Mr. Bunch’s tenure, Mr. McGarry has been credited with overseeing many of the deals that helped boost PPG’s coatings portfolio.

Those include the acquisitions of Mexico’s Consorcio Comex and AkzoNobel’s North American architectural coatings business.

He also helped to lead PPG’s spinoff of its commodity chemicals business and after he became chairman, PPG sold off much of its glass segment.

It’s no surprise Trian is pushing for Mr. Bunch to return.

Nelson Peltz, Trian’s founder, sat on the board of Pittsburgh-based H.J. Heinz with Mr. Bunch after Trian waged a high-profile proxy battle at the food maker in 2006.

Advertise with us

Mr. Bunch was among five former Heinz directors who praised Mr. Peltz’s contributions to Heinz last year when the activist investor was going after a seat on the board of consumer products maker Procter & Gamble. Heinz was sold to a joint venture in 2013 and then merged with Kraft Foods in 2015 to create the Kraft Heinz Co.

Mr. Peltz and Mr. Bunch also served together as directors at Mondelez, the food company that owns the Cadbury and Nabisco brands.

Though Trian said Thursday that Mr. Bunch “has indicated his willingness to return as CEO,” at least one analyst wasn’t sure that’s the case.

Frank Mitsch, senior analyst at Fermium Research, issued an update saying that when Trian waged a proxy fight for DuPont in 2015, Mr. Peltz claimed he was recruiting Jim Gallogly, former chairman of chemicals maker LyondellBasell, as a board member.

“Jim called us directly to emphatically refute the notion that he was part of Trian’s plan,” said Mr. Mitsch, who acknowledged Mr. Gallogly later joined DuPont’s board under the chief executive who successfully rebuffed Trian.

Advertise with us

He’s of the opinion that Chuck wouldn’t go against his hand-picked successor but left open the possibility that circumstances and his close relationship with Mr. Peltz during their time on the Heinz board may have played a role.

Other Wall Street analysts Thursday said they expect PPG’s board and management to continue backing Mr. McGarry and that a split might not be in the best option for the company.

Christopher Parkinson of Credit Suisse said that PPG will likely “rigorously” defend its chairman and that a split could be “an uphill battle.”

Michael Harrison of Seaport Global questioned the benefit of a split and said PPG is likely gearing for a fight against Trian’s proposal.

Joyce Gannon: jgannon@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1580. Bloomberg contributed.

Updated at 4:50 p.m. Oct. 25, 2018