Bert Sperling has some great news for those who believe that Pittsburgh as we know it is doomed if the city wins the taxpayer-funded arms race to host Amazon’s second headquarters.
The man who The New York Times nicknamed the “guy who picks the best places” is predicting the lucky town will be Oatlands, Va.
While Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald will no doubt be crestfallen if Mr. Sperling is on the money, they could take consolation in the fact that at least it wasn’t Cleveland or Philadelphia.
The unincorporated Virginia town is located in Loudoun County, close to Dulles International Airport and a little more than an hour drive west of the White House. As such, it is in Northern Virginia, one of the 20 communities that the Seattle online retailer (and soon to be everything else) named as a finalist.
Mr. Sperling, the numbers cruncher behind Money Magazine’s inaugural Best Places to Live feature, said Oatlands is close enough to many of the big city, quality-of-life amenities Amazon is looking for, but undeveloped enough to give Amazon more flexibility in creating a second home.
“They’re like the 900-pound gorilla. They can transform whatever area they go to,” Mr. Sperling said in a telephone interview. “They could create their own community and this would definitely be a big win for them.”
Mr. Best Places is not going out on a limb by picking the Washington, D.C., area as the winner. A year ago, Richard Florida, who made a name for himself at Carnegie Mellon University espousing the creative class as an economic engine, said the mere fact that Amazon founder and Washington Post owner Jeff Bezos shelled out $23 million for a Washington, D.C. home makes the nation’s capital a probable location for HQ2.
An East Coast location also makes sense in terms of Amazon spreading its geographic reach, Mr. Sperling said. He noted that 14 of the 20 finalists are in the Eastern time zone.
Mr. Sperling said the political implications of the decision have intensified since the finalists were revealed months ago.
With Congress and federal agencies nipping at the heels of Facebook and other technology companies for disclosing user data and other sins, analysts say being close to the seat of power has become more important. Mr. Sperling said another factor is Georgia’s decision to punish Delta Airlines for cutting its ties with the National Rifle Association.
“If Amazon were to locate in a conservative state like Florida, Texas or North Carolina, they could find themselves being held hostage,” he said.
Mr. Sperling’s free website, bestplaces.net, is used by homeowners, students, retirees and others to research relocation decisions. Companies and labor unions use it to set pay levels or demands, he said. The website is funded by advertising and licensing the data to real estate companies that use it in marketing materials.
For insurer State Farm, Best Places developed a list of Fiscally Fit cities based on 27 criteria that measured how residents are financially preparing for the future. Pittsburgh finished fourth on that list.
“The folks in Pittsburgh are very down to earth in terms of planning for their future,” Mr. Sperling said.
Pittsburgh ranks 8th on Best Places’ list of cities that offer a healthy and more affordable retirement and 11th on a list of “most secure” cities that Mr. Sperling developed for Farmers Insurance. Those calculations included crime statistics as well as extreme weather, the risk of natural disasters, environmental hazards, the frequency of economic dislocations, and other factors.
Winning the Amazon beauty contest would be a mixed blessing for Pittsburgh, according to Mr. Sperling, adding “it would carry a lot of baggage with it.”
But being a finalist has brought more attention to a city that has already gained notice for its burgeoning tech community, affordable housing and quality of life, he said.
He expects Amazon to make a decision by Thanksgiving, probably in the next three weeks. In the end, it will be based on the quality-of-life factors important to Amazon, not on the taxpayer dollars that elected officials are tripping over each other to offer to the ubiquitous company.
“Amazon is going to get the kind of place they want and, in the end, incentives are not going to mean a lot,” Mr. Sperling said.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.