A handful of Pittsburgh Athletic Association members have filed an 11th-hour objection to the bankrupt club’s pending reorganization plan, saying the PAA’s board failed in its fiduciary duties by selecting an inferior bidder to buy the group’s iconic Oakland clubhouse.
The reorganization plan calls for selling the stately structure on Fifth Avenue for $12.6 million to Shadyside-based developer Walnut Capital, with proceeds of the sale to be used to repay creditors. Walnut Capital, which plans to redevelop the building into restaurant and office space, was selected in September as the winning bidder.
The objectors claim that Downtown-based developer McKnight Realty Partners submitted a revised offer “far superior” to Walnut Capital’s on April 23 that the PAA wrongly dismissed. McKnight, which joined in the objection, also submitted a bid last year.
The PAA’s current reorganization plan won conditional approval in bankruptcy court on April 24.
Club members Irwin Kotovsky, Richard Velan, Yvonne Rose and Kay Merge argued that McKnight’s revised bid would assure a certain level of amenities in the refurbished building for club members — including a fitness center, pool, squash courts and grille room — and allow them to retain a 5 percent interest in the building.
In contrast, club amenities under Walnut Capital’s plan hinge on the amount of taxes owed on the building when it is sold.
Read More
The higher the taxes, the fewer the amenities. If taxes were to eat up too much of the tax reserve fund, then Walnut would not be obligated to provide the club with any space and members would be left without a home.
The PAA’s bankruptcy attorney, Jordan Blask of Tucker Arensberg, said the Pittsburgh Athletic Association strongly disagreed with the objectors’ claims.
“These matters are in litigation and will be fully addressed during the confirmation hearing, at which time we are confident that the court will confirm the debtors’ plan,” Mr. Blask said in an email.
A confirmation hearing before Judge Jeffery A. Deller is set for May 30, one year after the 110-year-old club filed for Chapter 11.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.