PNC Merchant Services, a credit and debit card payment processing company majority owned by PNC Bank in Pittsburgh, is being sued by a handful of businesses for allegedly over-billing them through fraudulent sales practices.
According to an amended complaint filed in New York federal district court in Brooklyn, the company “hides the upcharges so that merchants cannot reasonably detect that they have been over-billed,” by failing to provide itemized statements.
The suit accuses sales agents of tricking businesses into signing up for card processing services.
PNC notified the court on March 23 that it intends to file a motion to dismiss the case.
A PNC spokeswoman Tuesday declined comment on pending litigation.
Among its claims, the suit said that sales agents asked prospective customers to sign “applications” that turned out to be three-year binding contracts subject to early termination fees.
In addition, the suit said, it was standard practice to inflate a merchant’s projected sales volume on applications. “If merchants notice the error,” they were told the numbers were “just the industry average,” or “nothing to worry about,” the suit claimed. Some customers who did not meet the numbers were subsequently charged a monthly minimum processing fee, according to the suit.
The complaint alleged that clients were assessed “junk fees” and “markups” not negotiated or described in their applications, and that agents regularly opted merchants out of receiving billing statements through the mail or electronically.
Merchants that later requested an accounting of fees had a hard time getting statements, said Adam Webb, managing partner at Webb, Klase & Lemond in Atlanta, which is representing the plaintiffs located in Florida, Ohio and Maryland.
His law firm specializes in class-action suits, and was part of litigation earlier this decade accusing big banks of manipulating debit card transactions to maximize overdraft fees. The litigation resulted in multi-million-dollar settlements, including a $90 million settlement with PNC Bank.
First Amended Complaint Dkt 12 (PDF)
First Amended Complaint Dkt 12 (Text)
According to the suit, PNC Merchant Services last year made changes to its bonus structure for sales agents and dropped early termination fees for new customers. The complaint alleged the moves were an effort to avoid a Wells Fargo-type scandal, which involved employees opening fake bank accounts to hit sales targets.
The allegations were based on interviews with alleged victims, industry experts and former employees of PNC Merchant Services, according to the suit, which is seeking class-action status.
Plaintiffs include Healing For The Abused Woman Ministries, Kelwin Inkwel, Anita’s Skin & Body Care and D.B. Kosie & Associates, which were PNC Merchant Services customers at various periods from 2012 to April 2017.
They are asking for refunds of improper fees and unspecified punitive and other damages.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.