When you think of appropriating more than $1.5 trillion to something over three years, the phrase “government boondoggle” comes to mind.

But taxpayers didn’t pick up the tab for this astronomical spending plan. It was hatched in the bowels of Corporate America. It represents how much companies in the S&P 500 spent repurchasing shares of their stock over that period.

S&P 500 companies repurchased $166.3 billion of their shares in the first quarter alone, more than in any quarter since the Great Recession.

What’s behind this binge spending?

Advertise with us

It’s what the smartest minds in the room think is an appropriate use of the horde of cash that companies are sitting on at a time when interest rates are at historically low levels. At the end of last year, $1.8 trillion was burning a hole in the pockets of non-financial companies in the S&P 500, according to Ernst & Young, an accounting and professional services firm.

All of the above figures came from a study that examined how 44 directors at 95 publicly traded U.S. companies feel about share buyback programs. The study was conducted by the Investor Responsibility Research Center Institute, a New York-based nonprofit that researches corporate governance and other issues, and Tapestry Networks, a networking firm in Waltham, Mass., that advises public company executives on governance issues.

Companies can use surplus cash for many different purposes. They can invest in new plants and equipment; hire more people; research and develop new products; or acquire other companies. They can also share the surplus cash with shareholders — either through dividends or share repurchases which, all things being equal, support higher stock prices by reducing the number of shares on the market.

Critics of buybacks have faulted companies for pursuing them. One of the most credible, University of Massachusetts Lowell economics professor William Lazonick, calls them “an unhealthy corporate obsession.” Mr. Lazonick believes repurchases benefit two groups: short-term, activist shareholders who pressure boards to make them, then cash out their shares; and corporate executives who receive a hefty share of their pay in stock and benefit when buybacks drive up the share price.

The directors interviewed for the study begged to differ.

Advertise with us

They told researchers that boards have vigorous discussions about excess cash and that deciding how to deploy it is one of the most import aspects of their jobs. The directors said the four main reasons to repurchase shares are to: return cash to shareholders; invest in a company’s stock when it’s priced at what they believe to be a discount; offset the number of shares issued regularly to compensate executives; or change the financial structure of the company.

Many of the directors told researchers they prefer buybacks to dividends, which must be paid regularly. Reducing or eliminating dividends tends to drive stock prices lower.

They don’t think buybacks prevent them from taking advantage of growth opportunities, although one commented that there aren’t that many opportunities available.

“There are lots of cases right now where acquisitions and internal investments don’t look good,” one director said.

That board member may be on to something.

Advertise with us

While some companies remain convinced that mergers and acquisitions are a 1 + 1 = 3 proposition, the annals of business are littered with corporate corpses proving that’s not necessarily the case.

“Activists think you will use cash to do bad acquisitions instead of returning it to shareholders,” one director said.

An undervalued stock price is a main reason for repurchasing shares. Some directors doubted their colleagues’ ability to make that judgement, saying companies frequently buy when stock prices are high and don’t buy when they are low.

As for buybacks enriching executives, most directors said that’s not the case. They told researchers that compensation committees judge how much planned share repurchases will increase earnings per share, then adjust incentive targets based on that measure accordingly.

The purpose of the study was not to determine whether buybacks are good or bad, but to better understand how directors feel about them. The extent to which so few of them have any better — that is to say, longer term — ideas for enhancing shareholder value says a lot about the current state of American business.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.