Like any rabid Pittsburgh sports fan, Kait Magee of Bloomfield desperately wants the Penguins to win their fourth Stanley Cup title.

As soon as possible.

It’s not the butterflies in her stomach that are getting to her. Rather it’s the moths in her wallet. As a server at an upscale Italian restaurant, Stagioni, she said business on game nights during the 2016 NHL playoffs has been slower than San Jose’s Logan Couture in the faceoff circle.

“I love the Penguins and this is so exciting, but it’s killing me money-wise,” she said. “I’m dying right now.”

Advertise with us

The South Side restaurant typically does a brisk Wednesday night business, but to quote the league’s slogan, “Because It’s The Cup,” during Wednesday night’s game, she was the lone server and waited on exactly two tables.

“This is usually easily a $100 night. Tonight it was $40.”

Stagioni proprietor Cara DelSignore is suffering from the same bit of cognitive dissonance: fandom vs. finance.

“We’re loyal Pittsburghers. We love our city and our teams and the energy it brings. We have a lot of regular customers who have season tickets. But being a small independent restaurant – you feel the void. We would expect to have more walk-ups and more last-minute reservations – so you feel it. We’ve definitely noticed it statistically.”

She cited the sheer length of the playoffs, which will be 21 games and 8 and a half weeks old for the Penguins after tonight, and the unpredictable game dates.

Advertise with us

“Wednesday nights are one thing, but it’s a bummer when it hurts your Saturday night. You have a staff and you’re ready to go and then you do a significant percentage – 20 to 25% less than you expected – that hurts. Your week is disjointed and hourly employees are being sent home early.”

Conversely, just a block away at Smokin’ Joe’s Saloon, Game 2 brought another boffo night of box office. Manager and bartender Tommy Carroll said that game night register totals are double the norm, and servers’ and bartenders’ tips are up by a corresponding factor as well. And like players in an overtime game, the hourly kitchen workers are getting more and longer shifts.

He said it’s almost been too busy of late.

“It’s gotten to where the game nights are affecting non-game nights because on the non-game nights, people are either staying home and recuperating from the previous game or saving their money to go out for the next game night,” Mr. Carroll said.

This feast for bars and pubs during games and relative famine at upscale restaurants – most of which don’t have a television by design – is a scene that has played out similarly in this and other neighborhoods around the city throughout the 2016 NHL playoffs. Stagioni co-owner and chef Stephen Felder says that it’s more like a moving shell game of expendable income: If they are spending it in one place, then they aren’t spending it somewhere else.

Advertise with us

“Even if we had a TV, I’d probably go somewhere else to watch the game,” Ms. DelSignore laughed, conceding that upscale dining and major sporting events are not a natural pair.

For instance, at trendy Station on Liberty Avenue in Bloomfield when the puck dropped Wednesday night, only one couple was at the handsome bar – despite the seldom-used televisions being turned on and tuned in to the game, and the happy hour food specials extended through the evening. But across the street at favorite neighborhood dive Armand’s, every barstool was occupied and down the block at Silky’s, an overflow crowd in Penguins sweaters lined the sidewalk patio.

The Braddock Avenue corridor in Regent Square is no different. Brandi Duffy, a bartender at The Loft, said business is up, but down the street chef Jennifer Burfield at Cibo, also an upscale Italian destination, said the opposite.

“It has definitely had an effect on us here, even to the point that patrons have canceled reservations to watch the games. Bad for business, but great to be in a city that offers up so much support to their teams.”

Over in East Liberty, Pizza Taglio proprietor Tony Giamarita said, “We’ve done some takeout on game nights and some pregame eat-in business, but once the game starts” – he made a motion of wiping his hands – “That’s it.”

Advertise with us

“I wish they played in the afternoon because we don't do lunch,” he laughed while tending to a packed house Thursday – a non-game night.

He has adopted his own version of the team’s standard chant: “Let’s Go Pens! ... But get it done quickly.”

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412