You may not have had a chance yet to redeem the Giant Eagle Advantage Card points you’ve earned, but the grocery store chain can still deduct those anticipated expenses on its taxes.

A federal appeals court has reversed a U.S. Tax Court decision that would have prevented the O’Hara-based grocer from deducting rewards that shoppers accumulated but hadn’t yet redeemed at the end of the year.

In 2004, Giant Eagle revised its Advantage Card program, adding “fuelperks!” that linked rewards at the pump to prior grocery purchases — for every $50 spent on qualifying groceries, a cardholder earned a 10-cent-per-gallon discount on gas. Those discounts expired in about three months.

On its 2006 and 2007 tax returns, Giant Eagle claimed deductions for as-yet-unredeemed discounts, using a formula it devised that included customer shopping history and redemption habits. But the Internal Revenue Service disallowed the deductions, which totaled $3.3 million and $313,490, respectively.

Advertise with us

After the IRS disallowed the deductions, Giant Eagle petitioned the U.S. Tax Court to allow it. Among its arguments, the company said the deductions satisfied a key legal test because the supermarket’s liability became fixed when it issued the discounts to customers.

Giant Eagle also argued the accrued discounts should be treated as sales-accompanying “trading stamps or premium coupons,” enabling it to offset the estimated costs against gross receipts from grocery sales, according to court documents.

But the tax court rejected the supermarket’s claims, stating that while the deductions were calculated with “reasonable accuracy,” the company’s arguments didn’t hold in this case.

Giant Eagle appealed. The case was heard before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, which ultimately found in favor of the grocer.

In the majority opinion, Judge Jane Roth said Giant Eagle was on the hook for discounts whether or not the customer redeemed them.

Advertise with us

“A customer anticipated the promised fuel discounts when deciding to shop at Giant Eagle in the first place — and thus deciding not to shop at a different store. Because she was then aware that she could apply the discounts as advertised if she spent $50 on supermarket purchases using her Advantage Card, she was indeed a party to a unilateral contract with Giant Eagle.”

In a dissenting opinion, Judge Thomas Hardiman wrote that Giant Eagle became liable to a shopper at checkout, but it didn’t become “absolutely” liable because the rewards had a built-in expiration date. Therefore, Giant Eagle didn’t totally guarantee that all the rewards earned would be granted in the end.

“Had Giant Eagle not included an expiration provision in its terms and conditions, I would be inclined to agree with my colleagues that the company incurred a fixed and absolute liability to each shopper at checkout.”

The court remanded the case to the tax court with instructions to grant judgment in favor of Giant Eagle. While customers won’t see a difference in their rewards, the decision should bolster the company’s bottom line.

Stephanie Ritenbaugh: sritenbaugh@post-gazette.com or 412-263-4910.