When the Pittsburgh Athletic Association was launched in the city in 1908, its nearly 200 charter members were a reflection of the region’s business and cultural elite, including names like Mesta, Mellon and Heinz.

Just a couple of years later, with some 2,500 members and a waiting list of applicants, the group opened a million-dollar clubhouse on Fifth Avenue in Oakland. The “magnificent” five-story structure was hailed in newspaper headlines as the “Finest in the World” and a “Triumph of Architectural and Artistic Design.”

Among the amenities were eight bowling allies, a gymnasium, an indoor running track, billiard and fencing rooms, rifle ranges, Turkish baths, dining hall, library and a glass-enclosed roof-top tennis court. “Dish washing by machinery” was among the modern marvels.

But today, like many private clubs looking back on their heyday amid changing lifestyles, the PAA has fallen on hard times. The iconic social club and once grand dame in the region finds itself in a struggle to survive as the leadership contends with an aging facility, dwindling membership and declining revenue.

Advertise with us

If that weren’t enough, in recent months the PAA has faced some negative publicity over health department concerns about conditions in the club’s kitchen.

Despite the obstacles, board president Tom Trimbur, president of the Trimbur Insurance Agency in Murrysville, believes the athletic club’s future is secure.

He is counting on plans announced last summer to build a 10-story upscale Hyatt Centric hotel in the PAA-owned parking lot behind the clubhouse that would provide an undisclosed amount of lease revenue. And he noted that a committee was in the midst of polling members as part of a strategic initiative to attract new members while keeping current members happy.

“We look forward to a good future for the club,” Mr. Trimbur said in an interview this month, declining to talk specifically about the club’s financial condition.

Estimates from various sources put current membership somewhere between 320 and 750. Mr. Trimbur said the actual figure was closer to the high end, but he would not be more specific.

Advertise with us

Several other board members contacted by the Post-Gazette either declined comment or did not return telephone calls.

Tough times for private clubs

Private clubs in general have been falling out of favor as priorities change and as families strapped for time find new ways to socialize, including through social media.

“Do people see the need for private clubs like they used to? Probably not,” Mr. Trimbur said, adding that parents today often spend a big chunk of their free time involved in their children’s athletic activities.

In addition, under pressure from shareholder activists, corporations have increasingly balked at paying expensive club membership dues for their executives.

Advertise with us

“I just really think people are not as into joining clubs as they once were,” said Jerry Gaughan, CEO at St. Anthony Charitable Foundation in Franklin Park, who recently stepped down from the PAA’s board after serving for about a year.

In addition to competing with a proliferation of more affordable fitness centers, the Pittsburgh Athletic Association was hurt when Pitt Stadium in Oakland was demolished at the end of 1999, insiders note. Before then, members often entertained at the club on game days. The Panthers now play home football games at Heinz Field on the North Shore.

Figures from the PAA’s latest publicly available 990 filings — reports that nonprofits submit to the Internal Revenue Service annually — show the club in a downward spiral financially.

Over the four-year period from 2011 to 2014, losses amounted to just over $2 million, according to the filings. At the same time, annual revenue fell from $2.7 million to $2.1 million, while assets declined from $3.4 million to $2.8 million.

There are signs that those losses have been taking a toll.

Advertise with us

In recent months, periodic reports have surfaced about employees’ paychecks bouncing.

Mr. Trimbur said he couldn’t comment. The union representing PAA workers, Unite Here Local 57, did not return phone calls seeking comment.

One former employee, Tom Buell, who left a part-time bartending job at the club two years ago, said his final paycheck bounced, but he eventually got his money.

He described the atmosphere at the stately club, located across from the University of Pittsburgh’s Cathedral of Learning, as gloomy.

“When you walked in, it was like the movie, ‘The Shining,’ with this old frozen-in-time setting. It was the same 10 or 20 people every Friday and Saturday night, ordering the same thing, drinking the same drinks.”

Advertise with us

The air conditioner in the bar broke while Mr. Buell was there, making it uncomfortably hot. “The scuttlebutt was they didn’t have the money to repair it,” he said.

Food safety, pool maintenance issues

Late last month, the Allegheny County Health Department posted a consumer alert at the club for recurring problems in the kitchen. An inspector noted more than a dozen food safety violations, such as holding food at unsafe temperatures and problems with cleaning and sanitization. The alert was removed March 7 after high-risk violations were fixed.

Several months earlier, in August, the health department had posted a red “Closed” placard at the restaurant because of a lack of hot water and cockroaches in the kitchen, among other problems. The kitchen was reinspected and allowed to reopen the following evening.

In total, the restaurant was visited by a health inspector six times in 2015 and twice so far this year, county records show.

Advertise with us

Mr. Trimbur said the run-ins with the county did not make him concerned about the restaurant’s food safety.

He said he took issue with “the timing” of the inspections, saying the health department was relying on anonymous complaints.

With negotiations involving about 50 union employees ongoing, “Some people may think this is some way to get some leverage,” he said.

“It doesn’t seem right someone can anonymously harass a business,” he added.

It is health department policy to follow up on all complaints, said food safety program manager Donna Scharding. “We take complaints very seriously,” she said. “The public are our eyes and ears out there when we aren’t there.”

Advertise with us

In the case of the PAA, she said, two of the eight inspections in recent months were triggered by anonymous calls.

She said the club was classified as a “high priority” by the department, putting it on a schedule for more frequent inspections.

“When a facility demonstrates that it cannot manage its own food safety and allows for significant high or moderate violations ... they get bumped up” to high priority, Ms. Scharding said.

“Kitchens that are very old can be challenging” for the operators, she acknowledged. “But the bottom line is food safety.”

The club’s indoor pool also has run afoul of the health department.

Advertise with us

An inspector cited the PAA numerous times last year for problems including failing to have a lifeguard on duty and not monitoring the water quality daily. A report in December noted that results of weekly bacteria tests required to be done by an outside laboratory were being withheld by the lab for nonpayment.

Mr. Trimbur said the pool currently was closed for repairs to the water heater. He said he didn’t know when it might reopen.

A hotel and a strategic plan

It will be a couple of months before the club’s new strategic plan can be delivered to members, Mr. Trimbur said.

“The struggles are just like a lot of clubs struggling now,” said Mr. Gaughan, the former board member. “People’s priorities have changed and they don’t have as much discretionary income.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Gaughan, who remains a member, uses the club’s handball facilities but rarely eats a meal there. Unlike many other private clubs, the PAA does not require members to spend a minimum amount in the restaurant each month.

The status of the $30 million hotel project isn’t clear. Developer Concord Hospitality would not say whether construction, which was expected to take 18 to 20 months, would begin this spring as planned.

“The project is being designed at this time,” a spokesman for Concord Hospitality wrote in an email, declining further comment.

The developers “have been advising us that we need to be prepared for them to break ground,” Mr. Trimbur said.

Last summer, the PAA said it had reached a 99-year agreement with Concord to collect lease payments. The lease revenue “plugs some big holes that were suffered the past couple of years,” Mr. Trimbur said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gaughan is confident the club is poised for a comeback. “I certainly expect the PAA to make a recovery,” he said. “The club is still a great place. It’s in a great location.

“I have confidence in the board. I have the confidence they will straighten things out.”

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3066.