One hundred and fourteen years ago, U.S. Steel became the world’s first $1 billion company.
Last week, the troubled Pittsburgh steelmaker revisited that milestone as its shares briefly traded below $7. That’s about $3 below levels U.S. Steel shares hit during the 2003 steel recession, when dozens of steel producers disappeared in bankruptcy.
The share price slide put the company’s market capitalization — the market value of its outstanding stock — at about $1 billion.
U.S. Steel shares rallied later in the week, a jump tied to falling imports. One analyst quoted by Bloomberg believes steel prices, which have fallen to 2003 levels, could be stabilizing or modestly improving.
Even if the cyclical industry has touched bottom, it remains a sad state of affairs for Pittsburghers who grew up in times when U.S. Steel was a solid part of Pittsburgh’s corporate bedrock — a steady, dependable supplier of thousands of well-paying, middle class jobs.
One of those who remember those better days is Amy Crist of Hampton, who says her father worked his entire career for U.S. Steel and passed his stock along to her and her brother.
“I check the stock price every day and it takes my breath away,” Ms. Crist said last week, wondering how low it can go.
“This is our General Motors,” she added.
A flood of cheap imports fueled by excess steelmaking capacity in mercantilist China, as well as sharply lower oil prices, have done in U.S. Steel despite the efforts of an efficiency campaign named after the company’s founder, Andrew Carnegie. After recording its first profitable year since 2008 in 2014, U.S. Steel lost $509 million in the first nine months of this year.
U.S. Steel shares have tumbled about 70 percent this year. They are trading at a mere fraction of the $190 per share they fetched in the summer of 2008.
Even though many still think of the steel producer as a large company, some Pittsburgh companies perceived by some to be smaller have larger market caps than U.S. Steel. They include teen apparel retailer American Eagle Outfitters (market cap of $3.1 billion); banker FNB Corp. ($2.3 billion); and memorial and casket maker Matthews International ($1.8 billion).
The company’s stature has also shrunk among its competitors. Charlotte-based Nucor, the nation’s largest nonunion steel producer, has a market cap of $13.1 billion. Another non-union producer, Steel Dynamics of Fort Wayne, Ind., has a market cap of $4.3 billion.
◊ ◊ ◊
Our fair city didn’t fare so well in the annual Best-Performing Cities index compiled by the Milken Institute, a Los Angeles think tank founded by former junk bond king Michael Milken and his brother.
Pittsburgh tumbled 34 spots to 113th on the list, just behind Duluth, Minn., and Beaumont-Port Arthur, Texas, and just ahead of Ocala, Fla., and Washington, D.C.
The San Jose-Sunnyvale-Santa Clara, Calif. metro area grabbed the top spot, followed by San Francisco; Provo, Utah; Austin, Texas; and Dallas.
The rankings are based on job and wage growth, as well as the concentration of high-tech industries in the 200 major metropolitan areas the think tank analyzed.
Minoli Ratnatunga, a co-author of the report who formerly worked at the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, said that in previous years Pittsburgh’s stable economy had helped the city move up in the rankings while other cities harder hit by the recession moved down.
Now that the economy is growing again, the harder hit cities, especially those affected by the housing downturn, are recovering faster than more stable Pittsburgh, she said.
Cities tied to the energy industry also took it on the chin. Lafayette, La., fell 116 spots to 135th while Texas, which had five cities in the Top 10 last year, has only three among the Top 25 this year, Ms. Ratnatunga said.
Pittsburgh’s best performance came in the category of five-year wage growth between 2008 and 2013, where the city ranked 29th. The worst performances came in one-year job growth between 2013 and 2014, where the city ranked 189th, and in economic output by high-tech industries in a metro area, where Pittsburgh placed 154th.
The rankings do not include such factors as the cost of doing business, cost-of-living and quality of life indicators like the crime rate or commuting times.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.