Car rental giant Hertz Corp. paid Allegheny County more than $1.75 million last week to settle claims that it underpaid the county’s $2-a-day car rental tax in nine locations.

Michael McCabe, solicitor for the county treasurer’s office, said from January 2008 through June 2011, half of the tax due from Hertz’s Pittsburgh International Airport counter and eight other Hertz business-and-travel rental locations in the county mistakenly went to the state.

Since 2008, rental car companies have been required to collect a $2 tax for each rented vehicle per day, a sum remitted to the treasurer’s office each month.

Hertz spokeswoman Anna Bootenhoff said the underpayment was an “IT programming error.”

Advertise with us

“We worked cooperatively with the auditors and the Treasurer in this matter and resolved the matter to everyone’s satisfaction,” she said in an email.

Mr. McCabe agreed: “Hertz really bent over backward to solve this.”

Auditors with county Controller Chelsa Wagner's office first discovered the underpayment during a review last year of Hertz's airport location.

That audit found that Hertz failed to remit the entire car rental tax from May 2010 to June 2011; the company in January paid the county more than $740,000 it owed in those taxes and related penalties and interest. (The company learned of the error sometime before June 2011 and fixed it, Mr. McCabe said.)

Auditors from the controller’s office and treasurer’s office investigated further and found that other locations experienced the same glitch. They found that Hertz owed an additional $1.8 million — more than $840,000 in unpaid taxes and more than $930,000 in penalties and interest. In all, the settlement totaled more than $2.5 million.

Advertise with us

The money was deposited as revenue in the county’s transit fund to pay its subsidy to Port Authority, and county council will decide how it will be used.

Mr. McCabe said the statute of limitations has expired for the state to return the money to Hertz.

A state revenue office spokeswoman said any interaction between it and an independent taxpayer is confidential.