Federal securities regulations governing the disclosure of transactions like the one reported this week involving Mylan and real estate developer Rodney Piatt, the Cecil generic drug maker’s lead independent director, leave ample room for interpretation about which business deals must be reported, according to securities lawyers.

Whether it’s a lease for office space owned by the chairman or purchases from a supplier owned in part by a member of the board, the concern is that a transaction between a public company and its officers, directors and their family members could benefit the insider, but harm shareholders.

To protect investors, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission requires companies to disclose certain types of transactions involving individuals with close connections to the business.

“Related-party transactions are always problematic because of the nature of the conflict of interest,” Ernest Badway, a securities lawyer with Fox Rothschild in New York said. “The SEC is always concerned about that because of what could happen.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Badway said the “vast majority” of transactions involving company officers, directors and their family are beneficial to shareholders. Securities lawyer Irwin Kishner said some related-party transactions can be good for shareholders, but that they should be scrutinized nonetheless.

“You’re always going to look twice at related-party transactions, as you should,” said Mr. Kishner, a partner with Herrick, Feinstein in New York.

The SEC’s last major revision of regulations covering disclosure of related-party transactions occurred in 2006. The rules require companies to inform investors how they determine whether to disclose the transactions.

Companies are required, in general, to disclose transactions involving $120,000 or more. But they do not have to report deals above that level if, in their judgment, the transaction is not material, Mr. Badway said.

Material means there is a substantial likelihood that knowing the details of the transaction would change a reasonable investor’s opinion, said Geeyoung Min, an assistant law professor at the University of Virginia. She believes the regulations leave too much room for companies to decide not to disclose.

Advertise with us

“The question is, how can you know that they are not disclosing enough?” Ms. Min asked.

The Wall Street Journal reported Tuesday that Mylan did not disclose that it obtained real estate for its Robert J. Coury Global Center in Cecil through a transaction involving Mr. Piatt. The real estate developer, a Mylan director since 2004, is chairman of Mylan’s compensation committee, a group of directors that determines what executive chairman Robert Coury and other top Mylan executives are paid.

The Journal reported that in March 2012, a company partly owned by Mr. Piatt sold a seven-acre parcel in Southpointe for $1 to a firm owned by a business partner in Southpointe II, the real estate development where the parcel was located. That firm immediately sold the parcel for $2.9 million to Mylan, which announced plans the next day to build its new headquarters there.

Critics said Mylan’s failure to disclose a transaction involving such a powerful director raises questions about the independence of Mr. Piatt, who is obligated to protect shareholder interests.

“To me, this one is obvious. How can you possibly think that this was not a disclosable transaction?” Mr. Kishner said. “I’m not saying it’s illegal, but you’ve got to show me it’s arms length.”

Advertise with us

In an emailed statement, Mitchell Langberg, an attorney representing Mylan, stated: “Mylan has met its disclosure requirements with regard to related party transactions, and has appropriately disclosed these relationships in its filings with the SEC.”

The generic drug maker told the Journal that it consulted with outside advisers and determined that there was no need to disclose the transaction because Mr. Piatt and Mylan did not deal directly with each other.

“Mr. Piatt was not a party to either transaction” and “had no direct or indirect material interest in the transactions,” Mylan told the newspaper.

“There was categorically no relationship between decisions related to executive compensation and the real-estate transactions,” a company spokeswoman told the Journal.

Mr. Piatt did not return a telephone call Wednesday seeking comment.

Advertise with us

Brian Mayhew, a University of Wisconsin accounting professor who studies related-party transactions, questioned why the real estate deal had to be done in two steps if it was in the interest of Mylan’s shareholders.

“Why structure the transaction this way if it’s a good deal for the company?” Mr. Mayhew said.

Mylan and other Western Pennsylvania-based companies reported an assortment of deals involving officers and directors last year.

Mylan disclosed that it paid about $935,000 last year to three firms whose principals are the brothers of Mr. Coury. The firms provided strategic business consulting, corporate benefits advice and other services.

Dick’s Sporting Goods paid $240,000 in rent to a company founded by the estate of the father of chairman and CEO Edward Stack. The sporting goods retailer also disclosed it paid $324,094 to a landscaping company owned by Mr. Stack’s brother-in-law.

Advertise with us

Consol Energy reported that it paid $1.5 million in “market-based” commissions to a firm owned by director David Hardesty Jr.’s brother.

American Eagle Outfitters disclosed it paid $652,850 for merchandise and designs to a firm partly owned by the sons of chairman and interim CEO Jay Schottenstein. The apparel retailer also said that it has a lease with an affiliate of Mr. Schottenstein under which it expects to pay annual rent of about $270,000.

S&T Bank’s related-party transactions included purchasing $542,063 in furniture and furnishings last year from a company owned by the father of president and CEO Todd Brice.

Various interpretations can be applied to the SEC’s disclosure regulations, according to securities lawyers.

“It’s hard to draft a rule that is one-size-fits-all,” Mr. Kishner said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Badway said he “always errs on the side of disclosure” when counselling clients.

“You can never be faulted by a government regulator for disclosing something truthfully,” he said.

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.