Alcoa’s plan to invigorate its aerospace business by acquiring RTI International Metals, a Moon titanium producer, began with a Dec. 8 phone call from Alcoa Chairman and CEO Klaus Kleinfeld to Robert Hernandez, chairman of RTI’s board.
According to a lengthy document Alcoa filed last week with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, what followed was a series of back-and-forth negotiations that culminated March 9, when the two metals producers announced a merger agreement that valued RTI at $1.5 billion.
Under the terms of the agreement, RTI shareholders will receive 2.8315 shares of Alcoa for each of their shares. The $1.5 billion price tag also includes up to $157 million of RTI debt and $330 million in cash the titanium producer is holding.
The Alcoa document is loaded with the requisite verbiage regarding shareholder value, synergy creation and due diligence that one would expect to find in such a prime example of merger-and-acquisition nonfiction.
According to the timetable laid out in the filing, Mr. Kleinfeld and Mr. Hernandez — accompanied by RTI vice chair, president and CEO Dawne Hickton — met Dec. 17 in Pittsburgh. After Mr. Kleinfeld made the case that the two companies “would make strong strategic partners,” the RTI executives informed him “that RTI was not for sale” but that the company’s board “would be willing to consider strategic options that would deliver shareholder value.”
Mr. Hernandez said any transaction would have to be based on “relevant historical highs” in RTI’s stock price and not the $24-a-share the stock was fetching at the time.
Five days later, Alcoa told the titanium producer it was ready to offer $35 per share, a 43 percent premium to RTI’s stock price over the previous 90 days. The sale would be accomplished by RTI shareholders getting 2.2 Alcoa shares for each of their shares.
Over the next week or so, RTI’s directors consulted with investment banker Barclays and Jones Day, its law firm. That process included investigating whether there might be any other interested buyers, but no willing and able alternate suitors emerged.
On Jan. 9, RTI’s directors told Alcoa they had a higher price in mind and would prefer that an offer be based on a fixed dollar price for the company’s shares rather than RTI shareholders getting a set amount of Alcoa shares for their stock. Mr. Kleinfeld told Ms. Hickton he’d need more financial and business information from RTI before considering whether to offer more.
More meetings and information exchanges followed until Feb. 20, when Alcoa raised its offer to 2.5625 Alcoa shares for each RTI share. That valued each share of RTI at $41, or 44 percent above the Feb. 19 closing price.
RTI’s directors still weren’t satisfied. On Feb. 25, Mr. Kleinfeld told Ms. Hickton that the exchange ratio would be set to give $41 worth of Alcoa shares for each of their RTI shares.
RTI’s directors cited a number of reasons for accepting the offer, including the advantages of size Alcoa would give in pursuing customers in the aerospace and other industries as well as the favorable impact the combination would have on its relationships with customers.
In addition, they determined that $41 per share “was the highest price Alcoa would be willing to pay” and that over the short- and medium term, it “was highly unlikely” that the price of RTI shares would exceed the $41 per share Alcoa was offering.
The companies approved the merger agreement on Sunday, March 8, Based on Alcoa’s closing price of $14.48 per share, that Friday, the exchange ratio was set at 2.8315 Alcoa shares. The merger agreement was announced the following day.
The document also discloses that five RTI executives would be eligible for nearly $33 million in golden parachutes if they lose their jobs as a result of the merger, including an estimated $19.1 million Ms. Hickton would be entitled to receive.
Since the transaction was announced, Alcoa shares have drifted lower. If they remain where they have been trading of late, RTI shareholders will get about $39 worth of Alcoa stock for each share they own.
As of Wednesday, no date had been set for RTI shareholders to approve the merger, which has already been blessed by the boards of both companies. It must also pass muster with regulators.
Alcoa said in March it expects to complete the transaction within three to six months.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.