Vendors supplying laundry care products to the dollar store industry heaved a sigh of relief last month when Family Dollar shareholders accepted an $8.5 billion merger offer from Dollar Tree. The deal might force 300 store divestitures — but not the 1,500 or more that might have come with a rival offer from the industry’s other big player, Dollar General.

Some analysts weren’t quite as pleased. They saw the similarities between Family Dollar and Dollar General as a plus, and figured slowing down new store openings might be a good thing.

How customers will view the marriage of Family Dollar and Dollar Tree — assuming it wins a thumbs-up from the Federal Trade Commission — may depend on whether their neighborhood store is sold or whether the deals get better.

Jamie Opoku is a pro at shopping the three discount retailers. The Crafton resident works for an organization that helps seniors stay in their homes, a goal that includes helping them get good deals on things they need.

Advertise with us

Standing in the Dollar Tree store on Noblestown Road in Crafton last week, Ms. Opoku held an armful of boxes of food and candy, some of which were impulse finds. That’s OK at the Dollar Tree chain, she said, because everything costs $1.

Family Dollar and Dollar General use the word “dollar” in their names to signal that they’ve got deals, but they don’t stick to that price point.

Ad fliers in the bins at the Family Dollar store on Foster Avenue in Crafton had a 100-ounce bottle of Gain detergent on sale for $8.95 and a Vtech cordless phone with answering machine for $25. Dollar General ran an offer in the weekly SmartSource coupon flier for a 12-pack of Lipton Tea bottles for $5 and two-liter bottles of Pepsi for $1.25.

“I look at the adverts before I shop them,” said Ms. Opoku, who also noted some dollar stores are dirtier than others and that Dollar Tree stores tend to be better organized than those of its competitors.

“They are very much different,” she said.

Advertise with us

And there are lots of them.

Considering the FTC

North Carolina-based Family Dollar had 2,500 stores nationwide about 20 years ago, but now has more than 8,000. Virginia-based Dollar Tree has grown from 3,000 stores in 2006 to more than 5,200.

Dollar General, based in Tennessee, has 11,500 stores — up from 7,000 in 2004 — and claims on its website to have “more retail locations than any other retailer in America.”

All three have dozens of locations in southwestern Pennsylvania, illustrating the sort of overlapping service areas that draws the attention of antitrust experts at the Federal Trade Commission. Typically in such deals, FTC approval comes with requirements that certain stores be divested to avoid any one player acquiring too much of a dominant position.

Advertise with us

Just how many stores the government might see as problematic was a major discussion point in recent months after, first, Dollar Tree offered to buy Family Dollar, and then Dollar General made its own play.

Government regulators took a different tact than some expected, focusing on prices the stores charge in different markets.

In a mid-January update on the status of its bid, Dollar General sounded unhappy about that. “The FTC has departed from the approach used to analyze retail mergers over recent years and has instead relied heavily on an untested theoretical model for predicting circumstances in which pricing will increase,” the company said.

Both Family Dollar and Dollar General — like many retailers — charge different prices in different markets. Such differences can reflect things such as overhead costs and payroll expenses, but competitive pressures also are factors.

In an analysis last fall, Jefferies analyst Daniel Binder said a check of 100 items sold at Dollar General stores in 12 markets found about a 2 percent price difference between the markets where it is the only player and the places where Walmart and Family Dollar also have stores.

Advertise with us

PG graphic: Dollar Store locations

(Click image for larger version)

Mr. Binder, who thought antitrust officials would be more worried about a price swing of 5 percent, felt that boded well for the FTC price review.

But a Family Dollar letter to shareholders in January said the price issue would be an important factor in increasing the number of store divestitures that the FTC would require in a merger with Dollar General.

Dollar General still felt it could keep the number below 1,500, particularly if Family Dollar wanted to make the deal work. But Family Dollar favored the Dollar Tree offer, citing both fewer overlapping stores and an approval process expected to move much more quickly.

Advertise with us

Dollar Tree cheered the successful shareholder vote on Jan. 22.

“We intend to operate and grow both banners,” said CEO Bob Sasser in his company’s official announcement.

“At Dollar Tree stores, everything is $1 while Family Dollar will continue to serve low to middle income customers with name brand consumables, home basics, variety and seasonal products at discount store prices. By utilizing the $1 fixed-price point in Dollar Tree and multi-price points at Family Dollar, we will deliver even greater value and choice to a broader range of consumers.”

If the acquisition goes through, Dollar Tree will end up with more than 13,000 stores and annual sales of more than $18 billion.

And the dollar store industry will consolidate further.

Advertise with us

A changing landscape

Just a decade or so ago, it seemed to be an entrepreneur’s gold mine, with independent stores popping up in nearly every empty space. But many of those stores in Pittsburgh and elsewhere have closed in recent years.

The sector overall grew 8.9 percent in 2013 to $28.7 billion, according to a June report from consulting firm Willard Bishop in Barrington, Ill. Store counts were up just 5.2 percent, perhaps reflecting some of those closures.

Jim Hertel, managing partner at Willard Bishop, was at a food industry conference last week and talked there with a number of vendors who supply dollar stores with laundry care and household cleaning supplies. He said they were pleased with the Dollar Tree deal, if only because it would mean less disruption.

Still, the dollar store chains might do better with slower growth, according to Mr. Binder from Jefferies. In his October note, he wrote that the industry is maturing. “In part, this is one of the aspects we like about about a Dollar General/Family Dollar merger since Dollar General would slow growth from about 7 percent to something closer to 4 percent during the integration period.”

Advertise with us

He said a store saturation analysis showed room for between 8,000 and 14,000 more stores in the U.S., but the Jefferies team felt the lower end of that was more realistic.

One reason that Family Dollar is a takeover candidate is that it has been putting up lackluster results in recent quarters. In an earnings call with analysts in early January, the retailer’s CEO Howard R. Levine said the company’s shoppers are still struggling even as the economy improves.

Scott Mushkin, an analyst at Wolfe Research, issued a report around the same time offering the opinion that new management might help: “We maintain that Dollar General would be best suited to turn Family Dollar’s business around because of the significant synergies and similarities of the business models.”

Dollar Tree is expected to work out a preliminary agreement with the FTC by the end of January, identifying the stores that need to be divested. The company will then finalize deals with buyers for those stores.

The two parties have agreed to give the FTC four weeks’ notice before closing the deal. Dollar Tree predicted it could complete the acquisition as early as March.

Teresa F. Lindeman: tlindeman@post-gazette.com or at 412-263-2018.