Alcoa and North Carolina are locked in a legal dispute over the Yadkin River, the site of four hydroelectric dams that once powered the aluminum producer’s Badin, N.C., smelter.
The aluminum producer idled the smelter in 2002 and permanently closed up shop there eight years later, a slow death that devastated the region. All that remains are Alcoa’s dams, strung out over about a 40-mile stretch of the Yadkin. The first was built in 1917; the last in 1962. Collectively, they can produce 215 megawatts of electricity annually, which Alcoa sells to utilities.
Although Alcoa’s smelting plans these days center on Saudi Arabia and other low-cost locales, the company wants to make a long-term commitment to the Yadkin dams. Since about the time it pulled the plug on Badin’s smelting operations, Alcoa has been seeking a 50-year renewal of a license to operate the dams from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.
That doesn’t seem right to some state officials. Since the dams no longer serve the public interest by supporting local jobs, they are no longer supporting Alcoa. The previous license expired in 2008 and Alcoa has operated on one-year extensions since then.
Former Gov. Bev Perdue, a Democrat, supported a state takeover of the dams, something her Republican successor is pursuing. Gov. Pat McCrory went to state court in 2013 seeking a ruling that the riverbed that the dams sit on are state property and that Alcoa does not have a right to the property.
“The benefits of the Yadkin River belong to North Carolina’s people,” Mr. McCrory said in a statement when the lawsuit was filed. “We should be able to use it for North Carolina water needs and to create North Carolina jobs.”
The lawsuit was transferred to federal court, where a trial is expected this year.
Alcoa views the issue as a pure and simple case of public theft of private property.
“It’s a clear threat to our property rights — and the rights of anyone who owns property along a waterway in North Carolina,” Ray Barham, the Alcoa official in charge of the company’s effort to relicense the dams, wrote in a post on Alcoa’s website.
In court papers, the company said North Carolina has never asserted ownership rights over the riverbed. In fact, the state recognized the company’s control of the property when it sought easements from Alcoa before building highway bridges over the river, the company noted in court documents.
“The state’s belated attempt to seize privately owned property would raise disturbing questions of constitutional dimensions even if supported by the facts,” Alcoa said in court papers.
Yadkin Riverkeeper, a nonprofit group that supports keeping the Yadkin clean and healthy, backs the state’s lawsuit. Riverkeeper Will Scott said the public benefit Alcoa provided by using the state’s property “is no longer there.”
Mr. Scott said many believe that if Alcoa’s license is renewed, it will sell the dams. That’s what it did in 2012 with its Tapoco hydroelectric dams on the Little Tennessee and Cheoah rivers in eastern Tennessee and western North Carolina. Alcoa received approximately $600 million for those four dams, which could generate 378 megawatts of power annually.
Others fear Alcoa would use a new license to sell water from the Yadkin, the source of water for more than 700,000 state residents.
Alcoa declined to provide current financial information on the dams. But a spokeswoman said 2008-10 results posted on the company’s website “are consistent” with current results. Over that three-year period, the dams generated profits of $23.2 million on revenue of $88.4 million.
Alcoa is not without its supporters. About two dozen government, business, and civic groups support renewal of the license based on the company’s commitment to make environmental, recreational and other improvements along the river. They include the boards of commissioners in Stanly and Davidson counties,
“Those benefits don’t accrue until that relicensing happens,” said Stanly County manager Andy Lucas.
The trial pits Alcoa’s claim to a return on the millions it has invested in the dams over nearly 100 years against the state’s claim that public property should be used in the public interest. The outcome will be much more than water over the dam.
Len Boselovic: 412-263-1941 or lboselovic@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.